How do I know whether to buy bottom drop whorl, or top drop whorl or drop spindle whorl or whatever? I am brand new to this and would love to know how to figure out the answer to this question. I would hate to spend the money on something I will never use.

Also, just to show my ignorance, what is a Niddy Noddy?

Cindy Jo

Comments

Caroline (not verified)

hi Cindy Jo. I would recommend one of the starter kits made up from toy wheels. They are a good workhorse spindle to learn on, and if they come in a flat pack, you will be able to try both ways, and see which you prefer, because it is purely a matter of preference. Generally the bottom whorl spindles are slower, and many are heavier, which is good to start with, but also proves why they are called drop spindles. Top whorl spindles can fly away in the hands of a learner, but generally are a bit lighter and spin faster. I have and use both styles, depending on what I am spinning, but do prefer the top whorls for most things because I can get up quite a speed and length of spin.

It doesn't really matter what you start learning on - we are very concerned about this in the West, but people elsewhere learn on what is available. Back in the dark ages I learned using cotton wool balls and a big heavy boat anchor "student" spindle of 5 ozs because that was all that was available to me. Nowadays that is considered impossible to do. I can also spin on spindles that many spinners would consider primitive, if not unuseable, because they are not hand-turned exotic wood, and often out of perfect balance. But even the expensive ones are not perfectly balanced once you start winding on yarn. If you really want to learn to spin, you will learn on whatever spindle you have access to, but I would not recommend the heavy student ones, they put off more people than they help! If you start with something about 1.5 ounces, that should see you get good use from it, and its a good all-purpose weight.

A Niddy Noddy is a piece of wood with a cross piece at each end, off-set from each other, so you can wind on a skein of yarn. Its a handy piece of equipment, and worth having. They are usually made of wood, but you can find some in PVC pipe, and they are not usually expensive.

Hope this gives you a few ideas of where to start - I find spinning very relaxing. It centres me, and I love how the fibres draft through my fingers and magically turn into yarn. It satisfies my creative urges, and I suffer withdrawal if I cannot spin for several days.

Caroline

Cindy Jo (not verified)

Thank you Caroline.

Cindy Jo

suzyhok (not verified)

Cindy Jo...

I have been spinning for a long time... usually with my old Ashford spinning wheel, but this summer we are living in our boat in a marina on Lake Champlain, NY -- no room for a wheel, but a drop spindle is ideal.

My favorite is a Turkish Drop Spindle.  It is the best spinning spindle I have... and I have several.  It holds the spin really well and when wound correctly you pull it off the shaft and pull out the cross pieces and you have a ball of your handspun.  

The photos are of what I am spinning now -- a blend of two beautifully dyed fibers that I bought on the internet... mohair and silk.

Have fun... Once you get the hang of it spinning can be very relaxing and meditative!

:-) Suzy

 

 

sgt_majorette (not verified)

I like the 1.1oz Schacht Hi-Lo. It's basicall a top whorl with a sturdy hook that you can turn upside down a use with the whorl on the bottom. It's a good starter spindle because you won't outgrow it; it'll always be a solid workhorse even after you get good and acquire a few more elegant spindles. Also almost everybody sells it, so you won't go crazy trying to find one.

sally orgren

I am a one trick pony when it comes to spinning. Many have tried to teach me various types, but the only one that stuck so far was top whorl. (The first person tried to teach me on a bottom whorl, and as it didn't take, I just assumed for the next 10 years that I couldn't spin! It never dawned on me the gear might not be suited for my style.)

I learned on a CD drop spindle, and thanks to an attentive guidemate, I now spin on a Bosworth. You just need to find good spinning friends who will let you try some of their gear first and have patience with your attempts. Best advice an experienced guild mate gave me — be sure to use decent materials when experimenting with different gear, not someone's cast off fleece or roving. (thanks Jerri!)

Aunt Janet (not verified)

I like those kind of spindles that don't drop.  I spin off the point something like a Navaho spindle, but suspended instead of supported.  I use a number 2 double pointed knitting needle, and a bead, either round or disk shaped.  My latest spindle is a jade knot with a hole in the center for the #2 dpn.  I also have a clay disk and a wooden disk that I like a lot.  I'm using these tiny spindles for longest thread competitions. 

For larger spinning I use the same type of spindle, but larger.  Toy wheels make very well balanced spindles when placed on a dowell or skewer.  One of my favorite spindles is one of Alden Amos's bead spindles.  He splits the shaft from a very straight piece of wood, so it will never go out of balance. 

CraftinSusan

I have been spindle spinning for around 15 years now and have taught a number of people.  Most people feel more comfortable using a top whorl but there are exceptions.  And there is the weight issue.  Most people make the mistake of starting with heavy spindles.  I call them boat anchors and these turn people off to spindling or leave them with the idea that they can't use a spindle.

It is hard for any of us to recommend a spindle for you.  What works for one person won't work for another.  In the beginning I purchased spindles without being able to try them out.  I found that I hated some but liked others.  There was one spindle that I really disliked initially but it was one I purchased when I was first learning.  I picked it up again after a few years of spindling and found that I could spin on it after all.  Now my preference is to test spin a spindle before I purchase it.  I know that this is not always possible.

An easy and inexpensive spindle to use is a CD spindle.  You also might want to look at wooden spindles between 1-2 ounces.  Do you know anyone who spindles and can lend you a spindle or two?

Also please purchase roving that is well prepared.  For a beginner good roving will be easier to spin.  Start with wool before jumping into silk, bamboo, etc.

Leatherweaver (not verified)

Well all I can do is share a little bit of my own spinning story. I joined a spinning and weaving guild over 7 years ago with dreams of learning to spin. People were nice and tried to help me out. Oh, I'll make you one from plywood, or this or that. Even, hey, I've starting to turn my own drop spindles in my husband's shop. Would you want one? I tried off and on to spin on all of these. However, it did not come easy, and I never really felt that I conquered it. This last yr. I decided that if wanted to really learn to spin that I needed to put out the money for a good "tool" to spin with. I did some research on the web, and people kept mentioning how great a Jenkins Turkish drop was. So I got two of them. Each of them a different size. I have fallen in love with spinning. I spin more than I knit now. I can even go back and spin on all those drop spindles that I collected over the yrs, however, they are just not as much "fun" as my Jenkins. lol

The rest of the story is that my sister decided to try spinning. Went to a guild in another state. She started down the same road I did. I tried to tell her to buy a good "tool". This is working she would say... She got a chance to try out a Jenkins drop spindle at a fiber show. lol She bought it, and I got an phone call where she said, "You were right!"

I hope that there is some place local that you can try several different styles out. I personally like to learn the history behind different stlyes of tools. Believe it or not sometimes knowing the history pulls me towards a certain tool. lol

 

Good luck on your own spinning adventure!

Liza

 

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on