As a beginner weaver, reading and listening, I knew that selvedges would be an issue . . . but I didn't really expect to have this problem: my selvedges are actually pretty good, except for plain (tabby) patterns.  I have really bad looping or a huge amount of draw-in . . . my twill selvedges look great, though!  Is this a common problem?  Any suggestions?

Mary Kaye in Oregon

Comments

Caroline (not verified)

Hi Mary Kaye, we all have problems with selveges at one time or another, its not confined to new weavers! And if there is a magic cure, I don't think anyone is passing it on,:-(, but there is hope!

Practice, of course, helps, but so does arcing, bubbling or otherwise careful placing of your yarn in the shed, and consistency as to which method you are using. You need to lay more weft in the shed than you would put in just laying the weft straight across, so it can go around the warp. How much will depend on the yarn you are using and the pattern, but basically I angle my thread up in the shed, make sure that the yarn is bending snuggly around the outside warp thread, without drawing it in, then change sheds to beat, but there are so many variations on this - some people say don't touch the weft at the edge, others say it doesn't matter, etc. Others hold the last warp thread to ensure the weft is not too tight, and give the weft a little tug to make sure. The only thing that seems set in concrete is that the more you worry about what your selveges are like, the worse they are, and for some reason one side is always nicer than the other!

Before you start your woven piece proper, you need to try a practice piece or sample, and this is where you will try a couple of shots to see how much weft needs to be left in the shed before you beat it gently. Once you have worked that out, try and make each shot the same way. You will discover that there is a sweet spot on every loom where its very easy to get selveges right and everything to look fine - this may only be as long as an inch or so, but that is how you know to wind on, and how far to wind on. It may be a pain to wind on so frequently, but if that is the sweet spot for your loom, thats how it goes.

I know this sounds a bit vague, but each loom is different, and its up to us to learn how our looms like to be used, and to  read the signals. Weaving is much more than just warping up and throwing the shuttle, and while we need to adapt the techniques in the books to suit the loom, the way we weave must also suit the loom and the fabric we wish to weave. Learn to relax and stop obsessing about your selveges. You might even investigate the Saori style of weaving and ignore your selveges altogether! Either way, once you stop worrying about them, they will improve as your hand-eye co-ordination improves and your muscles learn what movements they need to make. The main thing is to enjoy what you are doing - life is too short to worry about the odd little loop hanging over the edge of your weaving!

marykayejn (not verified)

Thanks Caroline.  I guess I didn't ask the question right, though.  Since there's such a vast difference in my selvedges on a plain weave vs. a twill, does that mean that I will need to adjust how I throw the weft for each type of pattern?

 

lkautio (not verified)

The answer is  "maybe"!  Sett and fiber also have an effect, as may the specific reed and dentage.  Watch how you are handling the shuttle for each structure.  Is there anything you do differently?  Are you beating at a different point in the treadling cycle?  There is more friction with pw than twill because of the higher number of intersections.   It may cause you to beat a little differently without noticing.  Try beating the plain weave on an open shed (weft angle not critical if you don't stop the bobbin from moving) or on a closed shed with a good, consistent angle.  Put on a long narrow plain weave project and just throw and watch without fiddling.  If it is just this one warp and not all plain weave warps, perhaps there is uneven tension at the edges of this particular warp.  Another factor is that most people have less draw in with plain weave than twill.  You might find Laura Fry's website, or Alan Fannin's or Peggy Ostercamp's books helpful.

Laurie Autio

marykayejn (not verified)

Thank you!  So, I know I just need to keep on doing what I'm doing and all will be well (eventually).

dognapper2 (not verified)

This must be what is meant by Draw In?
 
I leave an arc when I throw the shuttle but perhaps not big enough? The actual edges don't look bad but esp. the left side of the warps were going to take abuse. This must be the cause of broken warp?
 
I was trying a set-up using Mastering Weave Structures (pg 208)
"Plain weave ground with a Rib Weave stripe..."
There seemed to be so much draw in that I switched to plain weave and quit trying to make the Rib weave.  I should have had the same weight warp & weft to duplicate what I was attempting from page 209. Will have to try again!
 
Gory details blogged... ;)
 
I had never heard of a temple but wondered if this is the reason for them - or the weighted clips attached hanging over the side?
 

Laurie in Maine

claudia (not verified)

A temple can be helpful. I, personally, do not use one unless I am making a rug.  A certain amount of draw-in is expected and natural in weaving. Placing you weft in an arc before your beat helps reduce draw-in but cannot prevent it totally.  Perfect selvadges with a minimum of draw-in come with time and weaving. Try not to fiddle with your selvedge thread, place your weft in with lots of room for it to wrap around the warp and beat gently. Observe what works best for you and do your best to repeat it for consistent results.

If you go to the "Search forums" function on the left side of the page and type in "temple" you will find a thread where there was a lot of discussion about temples and a link for a temple you can make yourself with paper clips. 

Hope this helps. I have only been weaving for about 5 years but try to weave daily. The more you weave, the less a problem this will be.

Claudia

Joanne Hall

Hi Laurie,

Yes, you are right, the temple eliminates the problem you see in the photo you posted.  Plus it eliminates the wear on the selvage threads, gives you a slightly wider result and gives you about 5% more wefts per inch, which is important when you want a stable fabric.  Plus it makes beating easier, so you can better control your beat for an even result. 

When you have taken the weave off the loom, your weft will stay straight if you use a temple.  If you don't use a temple, you may end up trying to press the weft stripes straight, as they will curve up at the selvages.

I find it very hard to weave without a temple.  If I take the temple off and then continue to weave (I do this as a demonstration when I am teaching), I have to loosen the tension in order to weave at all and I have to beat really hard.   It really shows the difference.   

Using a temple will also help you to keep a nice tension across your warp as you weave a long warp.  And in the end, it improves your selvages.

Joanne

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on