topenchilada (not verified)

Interesting question. I'm a new weaver, and no one has told me which way to do it, but I've always beat on a closed shed. I just assumed that would be better since I use a jack loom, and the threads are all tensioned evenly with a closed shed. With the shed open, the lifted threads are under more tension, and I think beating then could cause breakage.

 

Laura in Orlando

topenchilada (not verified)

Interesting question. I'm a new weaver, and no one has told me which way to do it, but I've always beat on a closed shed. I just assumed that would be better since I use a jack loom, and the threads are all tensioned evenly with a closed shed. With the shed open, the lifted threads are under more tension, and I think beating then could cause breakage.

 

Laura in Orlando

ilaine (not verified)

That isn't necessarily true of jack looms.   In mine the at-rest position is not flat, it is raised half the shed-heigh (it is a sinking shed style)  so when the shed is open tension is even on all shafts.  There's a dingus that goes into the cams to hold the shafts at mid-level for threading.

ilaine (not verified)

That isn't necessarily true of jack looms.   In mine the at-rest position is not flat, it is raised half the shed-heigh (it is a sinking shed style)  so when the shed is open tension is even on all shafts.  There's a dingus that goes into the cams to hold the shafts at mid-level for threading.

Lodi_Weaver (not verified)

Personally, I'm beating the shed in as I'm closing it - probably just hitting the fell as it's closed.  It seems to work fine for the weaving I've been doing and it's significantly faster for me to do it this way.

Lodi_Weaver (not verified)

Personally, I'm beating the shed in as I'm closing it - probably just hitting the fell as it's closed.  It seems to work fine for the weaving I've been doing and it's significantly faster for me to do it this way.

rosethorn (not verified)

During a recent workshop with Jane Stafford, she recommended that you start your beat with the shed still open, then as beater is all the way forward, change sheds. Jane says this will help to ensure even selvedges.

The reason for this is that as the last weft thread is beaten in, it has to pack in around the warp thread, and it's path will become longer as it goes over and under the warp. IWeavers compensate for this somewhat by throwing the shuttle in such a way that the weft either "bubbles" or lies at an angle to the fell, but there is not usually enough extra weft here for all of the take-up required, especially on wider pieces. The extra has to come from somewhere, and there is only two possibilities:

  1. it can come from the shuttle, drawing off a bit of extra weft from the bobbin as the pick is beaten in.  But this can only happen if the shed is still open during beating

  2. it can come from the other selvedge, and cause draw-in as the weft is pulled tight. This is what happens if the shed is already closed during beating.

During the workshop, she had everyone try beating on the open shed and then changing sheds when the beater was all the way forward. Immediately, most people's seveldges became more even and had less draw-in. An added benefit was that for sticky warps (wool, and very closely set warps) changing the shed and then moving the beater clears the shed nicely.

 

rosethorn (not verified)

During a recent workshop with Jane Stafford, she recommended that you start your beat with the shed still open, then as beater is all the way forward, change sheds. Jane says this will help to ensure even selvedges.

The reason for this is that as the last weft thread is beaten in, it has to pack in around the warp thread, and it's path will become longer as it goes over and under the warp. IWeavers compensate for this somewhat by throwing the shuttle in such a way that the weft either "bubbles" or lies at an angle to the fell, but there is not usually enough extra weft here for all of the take-up required, especially on wider pieces. The extra has to come from somewhere, and there is only two possibilities:

  1. it can come from the shuttle, drawing off a bit of extra weft from the bobbin as the pick is beaten in.  But this can only happen if the shed is still open during beating

  2. it can come from the other selvedge, and cause draw-in as the weft is pulled tight. This is what happens if the shed is already closed during beating.

During the workshop, she had everyone try beating on the open shed and then changing sheds when the beater was all the way forward. Immediately, most people's seveldges became more even and had less draw-in. An added benefit was that for sticky warps (wool, and very closely set warps) changing the shed and then moving the beater clears the shed nicely.

 

Lodi_Weaver (not verified)

 I should record myself weaving so I can watch what I'm actually doing.  I just have a rhythm and a way of doin it and I guess I don't really pay attention.

 

This makes sense though.

Lodi_Weaver (not verified)

 I should record myself weaving so I can watch what I'm actually doing.  I just have a rhythm and a way of doin it and I guess I don't really pay attention.

 

This makes sense though.