I'm a new weaver but a long-time thread crocheter so I have lots of (cotton) crochet thread, mostly #10 but some #20.  I'm wondering how it would work as weaving thread.  Has anyone tried it and how does it compare to the cotton weaving threads?

Comments

pammersw

I'm fairly new, too, but weavers use perle cotton. Is this,  that, or the smaller stuff like a fairly stiff thread? (Sort of like a buttonhole thread?) I'd think it would weave fine but might be a little stiff at first. It would probably soften a little when washed.

Raine59

I'm not talking about perle cotton, but regular cotton crochet thread (like Aunt Lydia's for example), often referred to as bedspread weight thread.

laurafry

Crochet cotton will produce a fairly stiff textile, generally speaking. If that stiffness suitable for the purpose go ahead. You might want to weave a sample first to check you like the results and if not, make some adjustments. Cheers Kaura

sally orgren

I used some donated Aunt Lydia's crochet cotton for a baby blanket and wasn't so happy with the feel of the results. Also, after just one washing, it was pilling a bit. Weaving yarns tend to be spun differently than knitting (and I assume crochet yarns), so that may account for the difference in the hand of the textile. Next time, I might consider using that yarn for runners or rugs.

Here's a link to that project if you want to see what it looked like and how it turned out:

http://www.weavolution.com/project/sally-orgren/charity-baby-blanket

ReedGuy

It's fine for a thicker runner or cover for a bedside stand. No so great for a blanket or scarf or towel, a little stiff. Made heavy runners, worked there just fine. Made some dish towels, a little heavy there, but does a very good job drying. I use them dish towels every day. Most people like finer cloth for dish towels, some even kick on 8/2 non merc cotton there. #10 crochet merc cotton has the same sett as 8/2 in my experience. I have used it in warp cord weave with heavier cotton padding and worked well there. Just something you have to sample and experiment with. That crochet cotton is the most expensive way to buy yarn to unless you find no label lots in Mardens.

Karen6

I have used it for place mats and similar projects that do not need to be soft.  The yarn is satisfactory for that.  It is modestly priced and has several color choices.  It is widely available and you don't have to wait for it to come in the mail.  What drives me crazy about it is trying to wind a warp or wind a bobbin off the ball.  It's very hard to do smoothly.  If you don't put it in a container with a top, the ball flies around.  Even in a container, it is subject to sudden jerks and changes in tension.  But use it for practice projects, and it will motivate you to save up for good yarn!

Karen

Swampweaver

I am working with a group of back strap weavers from Myamar who use cotton crochet thread for their warp. They say it is similar to the warp they are accustomed to from Thailand. They produce firm, beautiful runners and mats with it on their looms made from reclaimed wood and pvc pipe... I am looking for a reasonably priced substitute for them. 8/2 cotton is what I have in mind.

Swampweaver

Should mention they also use it for weft. They set the warp about 24 epi.

ReedGuy

I've used it at 24 epi myself. The diameter is close to 8/2. The crochet is 10/3 and mercerized. And it is readily availabe but limited color choices. Walmart only carries, white, natural, dark red, pastal green, delft blue, and light pink. All I ever see and not large quanties except for white and natural on larger skeins. It is more expensive to buy these small balls than to get good 8/2 from a weaver's supply place. Around here it's $9 for 3 - 350 yard balls. Mardens has bags of 3 - 300 yard balls a little cheaper, again not large color selection but they do have a lot of it. Mardens is a discount/salvage store in Maine.

What Walmart did when they first came to town was carry the local wool milled here. There was another place that had carried it, but Walmart out priced them so they quit. Then promptly after that Walmart stopped carrying the wool. I get mine from a local dealer, that is cheaper than anyone and you can buy all the mill wools there. The other places you only get one choice, Heritage, that's it and very small quantities.

A small yarn store tried to make a go last year, but that was doomed to fail from day one. They were never in the store and their hours were odd.

Swampweaver

ReedGuy , here in the Southeast, we grow cotton, and lots of it. But the majority of textile mills have been put out of business. US grown cotton now goes overseas and comes back to us as overpriced thread at Walmart. Your experience of they moving into a community, displacing local small businesses, then raising prices and lowering selection is a common business practice for them here in GA. When the SuperCenter came to my small town, we had three fabric stores. There was a long tradition in our community of children wearing beautiful handmade clothing, lovingly sewed by mothers and grandmothers. Walmart sold fabric $1 a yard and sewing notions. Within three years all local stores had closed, and one year later Walmart discontinued selling fabric and used the floor space for more ready to wear coming from China. Now the nearest fabric supply is 50 miles away. Women no longer sew for their families like they once did, and buy clothes at Walmart....our local sewing machine repair store also burned to the ground in a mysterious fire and has not been rebuilt :( The limited colors of the Crochet thread available to these weavers does make for some peculiar textiles to say the least! Makes them hard to sell and limits the weavers' abilities to produce traditional patterns, which are in demand now. Will check out the sources you mention, and look for other weaving supply sources for 8/2 cotton. That is not something I have personally used, but have seen it on line. Sorry for the rant!

Raine59

I started hand dyeing crochet thread several years ago as I liked to make doilies and couldn't always find the colors I want.  I ended up with so much I started selling it on Ebay.  Anyway, Walmart (at least where I live in central Texas) sells Red Heart Classic size 10 in the large balls at 1000 yards for $3.77 plus tax. That's the reason I posted this question to begin with, because crochet thread is so much cheaper than weaving thread.  But as I am just getting into weaving, I have bought some 8/2 unmercerized and some 10/2 and 5/2 perle cotton, all in white, and plan to dye it myself.   I haven't tried the crochet thread yet but plan to soon. I will see  how it compares to some of the cotton weaving threads.

ReedGuy

I think you'll find that you will be quite limited by what you can weave with crochet cotton. It will not have the hand of good weaving cotton. You can find large cones of weaving yarn online a lot cheaper than what Walmart sells. If you buy small 1/3 - 1/2 lb spools then no, they will be pricey.

I for one never buy clothes at Walmart. 'Dickies' work cloths for instance are now all made off shore and they do not fit a Canadian man. Thier sizes are small and less room than equivilent size Canadian made. I have had this conversation with a lot of fellows and we all buy 'Big Bills', made in Canada.

Submitted by Raine59 on