I have been weaving for about 3 years now. I don't know how to spin and I've been thinking about learning. My husband and I (after we graduate college) will be moving to a 60 acre farm that we'll share with his parents. His mother already has a herd(?) of dairy goats and I was considering eventually getting angoras (or a cross-breed) so that I could have my own fiber source to spin yarn. Now my husband thinks that spinning doesn't really make much sense in the long run. It takes more time, we'd be paying for feed for the goats, etc. (on a side note, if it's a short haired goat and you collect enough hair, can you spin that?)

Let me just ask this: Is it more economical to spin your own yarn? Is it worth the time? Even if I don't end up going the whole nine yards and buying goats or sheep, is it worth it? Or is it just my fiber-nerd soul longing for another fiber-ly craft?
Just wanted some other weavers/spinners thoughts. :)
JoAnna

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

 Spinning is fun. Spinning is time consuming. Spinning, in light of the time involved is not more economical than purchasing yarn but can yield yarn that is quite distinctive. Raising your own fiber source is very labor intensive. We once had a herd of dairy sheep for fiber and as the basis of our business. Weaving had to go on the back burner.

Now, without sheep, weaving is the base of our business and spinning is an adjunct.

Doing both weaving and spinning while raising fiber animals is pretty much an overly tall order. 

Try spinning now and see how you like it - drop spindles can be made easily, the student spindles out there cost less than $10 and there are good books for under $15. If you fall in love, get the animals. If you remain lukewarm toward it, feeding livestock will get old very quickly.

Little Meadows (not verified)

Running a farm, spinning and weaving makes for a very full life, sometimes overly full!  I have fiber sheep and dairy goats so if you'd like to send a PM I'd be happy to tell you about my experiences- good & bad.  But I'll say here that I can weave a lot or I can spin a lot but I can't do both and weaving pays better. Liese

tien (not verified)

Spinning is not financially worthwhile, UNLESS you find you really enjoy the process.  Even then, it's very very difficult to make any money at it.

I'm not saying don't learn to spin - I find it pretty relaxing myself, and used to spin a lot before taking up weaving - but don't expect to do it for financial reasons.  The main reasons I'd spin are (1) enjoyment of the process and (2) the ability to make yarns you can't purchase.  There are mills that will spin your fiber into yarn for you in small lots, and that's where I would go if I had fiber animals.  But YMMV - you may have more free time for spinning than I do.

Tien

Thumper70 (not verified)

I'm not sure about the economics of it - but I spin and have found that it is very rewarding.

I enjoy the knowledge that what I weave is done with most, or all of my home spun wool, silk or linen.

It does take time - but I look at it this way - how much "empty" time do I have in a day? When watching the news, or a movie for example I can be spinning away and before I know it have a decent amount of yarn/string to work with.

The other benefit I've found is that you get the material you want - the way you want it - and sometimes that's hard to do with store bought yarn/string.

Caroline (not verified)

From a simply economic standpoint, you are better off financially using yarn made by someone else. If you are time poor, it will only become worse as you struggle to make the yarn for your projects.

But...................

from a creative point of view, there is nothing quite like the feeling of having made something out of almost nothing! I spindle, and I'm about as prolific on my spindles as I am on a wheel, because I can use all those odd moments when waiting for an appointment, or for something or someone, to spin a metre here, a metre there. And before I know it I have a  ball or two waiting to be plied. Spinning keeps me centered, so weaving flows naturally from that, but I do not rely on my handspun for all my weaving yarn.

Before the Industrial Revolution, it was reckoned that a good weaver required 5 or more spinners to keep him supplied with weaving yarn, plus the other workers who scoured, picked and combed the fleece, or prepared the flax for spinning, the dyers, and any other ancillary workers involved in the process of making cloth.

One person cannot manage all this and still be prolific in their output.

But if you  weave for the sheer enjoyment that the creative process brings, then spinning mayl enhance your experience and pleasure.

Aunt Janet (not verified)

I'm definitely not making a living from handspun yarns, but I do sell some.  I resisted doing that for years because i wanted to use all of my handspun for my own projects.  I love spinning so much that after a while I found myself with a couple of garbage can bags full of handspun with no project in mind.  I'm still learning to weave and make friends with my looms.  I suspect eventually I'll stop selling the yarns and put it all into weaving.

One great compromise  is to use some handspun with commercially prepared yarn.  Maybe use commercial yarn for warp with your handspun in the weft.  You can also use handspun as accent with just a few strands interspersed with the commercial yarn.  I recently threw some very thick and thin slubby yarn into a weaving with mostly smooth yarns.  It was a lovely effect.

Good luck with your farming.

Janet

Alison (not verified)

I won't add any more about the joys of spinning except that I do have a friend who spins professionally and does pretty well (not a living but not chump-change).  I started directly on a wheel and usually carry a drop spindle with me when I travel (every week).

Regarding the animals, short-haired goats generally have hair that is too coarse for spinning.  However, to judge your goats, you need to learn more about spinning and think about the purpose for the yarn.

So follow the advice above or find a good spinner or class locally  to teach you.  With the additional knowledge, you can decide what you want to do next.  At the very least, you'll have learned an interesting , relaxing craft that will teach you lots about various fibers!

Alison

JoAnnaWeaves (not verified)

Thanks for the advice. :) I do weave mainly for the enjoyment of the process and I'm so glad you said that at the end of your post because it reminded me why I love weaving. About a year ago I was seriously considering being a production weaver. Not so much because that's what I wanted to do, but I felt like that's what I was SUPPOSED to do and that this whole thing was worthless if I didn't do something with it.

Now I feel differently. My husband and I sat down and had a conversation about my weaving and he's in full support of whatever I want to do with it, but he said that I shouldn't feel pressure to make money with my weaving. That helped me to feel less stressed about trying to learn everything all at once (teaching myself) and just enjoy weaving. Now I think I will probably sell some of my work, but mostly it's for my enjoyment.

I guess with that in mind, I would probably end up just using handspun yarns for my own use. Which I suppose means it doesn't make much sense to buy goats for fiber. I still may end up with one or two (probably pygoras because they are smaller) but that would, again, be for my own enjoyment. I love helping my mother-in-law with her goats and I think it's very rewarding. I know it seems like a lot of things to be doing, but I expect our farm to encompass most or all of my time. I wouldn't really have it any other way. :)
JoAnna

laurafry

Weaving - and spinning - is far too labour intensive to find oneself doing it out of a sense of guilt or obligation.  You must *love* to do it.  There's no other reason because frankly it's no way to get rich! 

That said, I can't imagine spending my days doing anything else.    I don't like the fact that I don't have a guaranteed income, and every month is a struggle to pay the bills.  I *could* go out and get a 'real' job with a paycheque I could cash and deal with life's expenses, but I learned a long time ago that when I do that I'm miserable down to my very soul.  At least when I'm weaving I'm happy at what I am doing and with what I am doing.

So if you don't have a passion to earn an income at weaving or spinning, then I'd say to not go there.  Just enjoy what you do and if you produce surplus, try to sell that.

If you really want to earn an income at weaving you need to have a whole different mental focus and attitude, and have the time and willingness to work at it really hard, instead of weaving purely for the personal satisfaction and enjoyment of doing it.........

If you want to find out more about being a professional craftsperson, you might find my blog interesting.  http://laurasloom.blogspot.com

Abby Franquemont also has a blog and writes about earning an income.  Abby has just published a book on spindle spinning - am hoping that's what is in the mail - got a parcel card yesterday.

Cheers,

Laura

Little Meadows (not verified)

It seems to me that people who are working at something because they were supposed to go into that work or felt it would pay best or for what ever reason always seem to me to be rather unhappy people looking forward to a future when they can retire.  It's nice that you guys could talk about it.  As for having a fiber flock for spinning pleasure...for the money spent you could sure buy lots and lots of fiber, different kinds of fiber and have none of the responsibilty. Wasn't it in the Efficient forum Laura posted the article link to the $3000 wool? LOL, and that was still underestimating it!  But it sounds like you'll be getting an education on farming pretty soon, if not already.  Liese

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on