Which type of beater do you prefer and why: overhead or underslung?

I have only used an underslung beater and I will have the opportunity to get an overhead beater.

 

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

The overhead beater allows for easier beating when very light and airy fabrics are desired. The underslun beater wants to drop down on the fell line and doing things like mohair scarves with quarter inch spaces beween wefts is more difficult than simply squeezing with the overhead beater.

For a really firm beat, both are about the same.

Del (not verified)

I've worked with both ( nd have an under-mount plus 3 over-hung and the moment.) GET THE OVER-HUNG!!! You'll love it. MUCH easier on your back and shoulders. The only negative I've found in 30 yrs. is that the over-hung structure takes up more space.

Years ago, Constance LaLena wrote an article for  Handwoven magazine diuscussing "choosing a loom". In it she noted that over-hung beaters were easier to use, easier on the weaver's body and easier to controll the beat.

 

sandra.eberhar…

The above comments are true, but one thing to note is that an overhead beater with short swords will give you a shallow arc, and a very small "Sweet spot".  Many modern looms are farther from the fell to the floor than from the fell to the top of the castle, and would work better with an underslung beater than with an overhead.  If it's easy to move the beater closer or farther from you (notches in the gallows ends), you get the effect of longer swords.  An overhead beater with short swords and no adjustment closer and further will have to have the warp advanced very often.

Joanne Hall

The overhead beater lets you see your last weft when you beat it in.  The lower beater sometimes covers it from your site.

And the overhead beater can be advanced as you weave, so you don't have to advance your warp as frequently.

Plus, it can be very heavy to give a good beat, but since it is hanging, you don't have to lift that weight.  So it is easier to get a tight beat.

Joanne

softlyspun

I have an Ashford 8 shaft table loom which I love.  The overhead beater works well and I have no complaints with this loom.  However, the bungee cords have now worn out their welcome and need to be replaced, can anyone tell me what they use or do I need to contact Ashford for replacements?  Thank you.

Sara von Tresckow

Ashford sells the bungees as replacement parts - I see that we have them in stock at $2.00 (I think ea. but am not at the shop) - an email to our web site would get them ordered for you.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on