Please help me make a decision!

I really want to buy a nice loom and I've made some choices but now I'm stuck - so help please. 

I have narrowed it down to the Louet Jane 70cms or the Louet David. The David is twice as much as the Jane so I'm not sure about the extra value. Also, if I go for the David should I get the 70 or 90? Its not much good asking me what I have woven as I'm fairly new, but I've just sold a big camera collection so this is my one shot at buying the right equipment. So... do I go for the biggest David I can get? The smaller David, or the bigger Jane? 

Anyone got both? 

One of my questions is that I have big feet and the David looks to have small treddles. I've played with them both in a shop but of course I fell in love with everything there!

Comments

coastalgal (not verified)

What do you want to weave? I know that's a big question. If your desire is mostly scarves, hand towels, small works fine. If you want blankets, curtains, afghans, wider is nice although, you could specialize in double weave!! As a relatively new weaver there are so many choices to make. After owning and selling 15 years later a 56" Fireside 8H, I missed the options of that big loom. Recently I purchased a Louet Hollandia 4h, 50-something inches that is expandable to 8h. My desire is to weave blankets & afghans of my handspun and also have my sweet 22" studio Noorwood loom for handtowels.........If you're choosing only one loom, get one with the most possibilities it can provide.......and Louet is a fine loom choice. 

Foot size-wise, ease of treadling is important and even with a wide foot, the spring loading mechanism on the Louet makes treadling a breeze. If you can try weaving a small project on one of the shop looms to see how your 'feet fit' as well as feel, it would be worth doing. Like taking a car for more than just around the block test drive. 

Just one person's opinion. will be interesting to see what others have to say. 

elaine in chilly OR

Claudia Segal (not verified)

Since this is what you believe to be your one chance, i would go for the most loom I could buy. You can weave smaller things on a larger loom but unless you are really good at double weave, you cannot weave larger things on a small loom. Also, I would not spend my money on a table loom. The Jane is nice but you will be able to find one used. Table looms are very limiting. You do not have the depth in a table loom to get a good shed or to weave complex projects. It gets tiresome to pull levers when using your feet on the treadles is so much more efficient. This is just my opinion. I have been weaving for 10 years and switched from jack to countermarch looms 4 years ago. Claudia

laurafry

I have been weaving since 1975. Finding a loom that 'fits' is very important. Trying several different makes and models if you can will let you know better than anyone else's opinion if that loom is good for you. When sitting at the loom your hips should be higher than your knees and your elbows should be higher than the breast beam. You might like to read the article I wrote for Weavezine a few years ago about posture and position at the loom. Don't remember the title off hand but if you search my name you should get a list. Cheers Laura Fry

Smudge

Sadly I can only try the Louet David - which is also the only floor loom I can afford. I'm fairly average size so that shouldn't be a problem.

I actually have dupytrens contracture (early stages) so I'm not sure about the table loom ergonomically. But then I struggle with the vast cost of the floor loom. And then I discovered I can get the 90cms David for £60 more than the 70cms - so what to do!!!!!

fairhavenweaver (not verified)

Sounds like you are in the UK? Is there a source for used looms you can look into? Lots of people find they have to downsize and they are happy to sell their looms at fair prices, far below the cost of a new one. I've bought several looms, all of them used.

That said, I, too, strongly recommend a floor loom over a table loom. I have the Jane and love it but use it only for workshops. As Claudia says, treadles are more efficient and less tiring. I would also go for the 90 cm. You can even squeeze a baby blanket out of that!

Virginia

Kade1301

I second the suggestion to look for a used loom - check out The Loom Exchange. And the Guilds of Weavers, Spinners and Dyers - the best thing is to find weaver friends who let you try their looms (and ideally maybe even want to get rid of one of theirs - it's how I got my Glimakra Ideal). And I don't know whether they have boards with 'for sale' ads in fibre shops (like the Handweaver's Studio in London) but if one is within reasonable distance you might want to check it out.

I don't think you can really damage a well-made loom during normal use, so for me a used loom is a safer bet than a used car - just don't buy a heap a wood, metal and string from the back of a garage...

AND I'm not sure whether "now I'm buying the perfect loom to fulfill all my needs" is the way to think. Unless you have some weaving experience you can't really know what you want to weave, and without a loom you won't get that experience. A good small loom should keep most of its value (especially if already bought used) and can be sold later to buy another one, better adapted to your needs or desires.

Happy loom-hunting!

 

Spara

I am new to weaving, but I agree if you can get a used loom the savings is huge. I bought used. I was able to afford a 4 harness, 6 threadle floor loom in very nice condition. It came with a warping board and several shuttles. Plus 2 books. I could not have afforded all this new. For what I paid for it I feel if I ever want something different I will be able to get my money back to put toward another one. 

Good luck to you!

sally orgren

if width were the only thing you were considering.

In America, the (used) smaller floor looms hold their value best. The wider the loom, (over 45") the less likely one will get back what one paid. When I buy a loom, I consider if I were to sell it in a few years time, could I get back what I paid? (Spara and I think alike!) Very few looms increase in value over time. That is why a lot of folks recommend buying used, so you can figure out what kind of weaver you are, and then determine which is the right loom for you. No one wants to be buying and selling looms all the time — we'd rather be spending our time weaving!

You don't say how many shafts for that price (unless I missed it). I would get 8 if you can. Unfortunately, there is also a lot of other "stuff" that you'll need to go with a loom, so don't forget to budget for that. (Shuttles, bobbin winder, extra bobbins, a warping board, possibly a ball winder and/or swift, etc.)

 

Smudge

Thank you for all of this. I have Agnes up to do a weekly weaving course which will help me make some choices. Unfortunately the second hand loom market in the UK isn't like the USA - it's hard to get really good floor looms. I suspect that I will go for the Louet David 90cms and buy a new one (I've never seen one second hand here and Lombok only come up every 3 or 4 months.) I have started saving but won't be buying before I start the course - I have realised I need some teaching whatever I buy!!
Submitted by Smudge on