I wanted to see how many weavers are using ACRYLIC yarns?   I do like the ACRYLIC because you can wash the finished piece and it doesn't shrink. Especially good feature when I make scarves for my nieces. Washable is good.   I like cotton a lot. I have a lot of wool, angora (rabbit), mohair, and other fibers to work with. But they are not quite wash and wear.   I think I will let my ACRYLIC yarns out of the closet and put them to work more often.   The brightest colors always seem to come in ACRYLIC. You can always find good buys on ACRYLIC yarn in the yarn store and at the thrift store.   Tell us about your ACRYLIC yarn adventures.   Have a good day!

Comments

mneligh

I am basically a natural fiber snob, but I am also a spinner, and I have a son who is in his 20's.  When he was in his teens (college), I got into spinning nylon-based synthetics (the faux cashmere, faux angora, etc) for things that he could use at school and not ruin, after having been given some faux cashmere at a spinner gift exchange.  I do several spinning demos per year, and when compared to about a dozen natural fibers, found people almost universally preferred the handspun synthetics to the handspun natural fibers including alpaca, merino, ingeo, bamboo, soysilk, and cotton.  Consequently, I decided there might be a place for them although we all should ask the sustainability question whenever we buy fiber in any form.

Recently, someone gave me 18 skeins of very soft fuzzy 2-ply novelty acrylic in 8 colors.  I made it into a krokbragd (3' x 4.8') rug.  It is not crisp, but as intended forms a gradient through the different colors that the fuzzy blur unifies.  It's a very pleasing rug to look at, a pure luxury to touch.  I would never have gotten the yarn myself,  but I'm very happy they gave it to me.

r1mein54 (not verified)

Franco, my multicolored sampler that you responded to in the last couple of days [ subject line Outer Limits] I did with "gifted" acrylic knitting yarn.

ReedGuy

I just did a tartan sample last weekend in acrylic knitting yarn. It weaved fine, but I like the feel of wool much better. Yup, I like wool. ;D Wool in my area is just as cheap as acrylic. I can see some folks not wanting to mess with wool because of the extra care. Almost reminds me of folks buying cob corn all husked and packaged, so all they have to do is open the package and drop it into boiling water. No husking required. :D :D

Weavejoyforall

I have woven just one real piece so far lots of samples though.  All have been acrylic yarns some with cotton warp...but Now I went out and bought lots of acrylic since its so inexpensive and holds up so well to washing, for kids scarfs a MUST.   I have put myself fully into scarf weaving for this comming Christmas for the whole family.  I have 20 scarfs to weave by Dec of 2013. most of them for youngsters. The colors seclection in acrylic is mind blowing. I love Caron simply soft , simply because it is just that if woven in a nice and lose it as soft as any expensive natural yarn and washs and wares like a dream for a long long time.   I have had one acrylic scarf for years and still looks great after many many washings! Count me in as an acrylic weaver !!!

Weavejoyforall

I have woven just one real piece so far lots of samples though.  All have been acrylic yarns some with cotton warp...but Now I went out and bought lots of acrylic since its so inexpensive and holds up so well to washing, for kids scarfs a MUST.   I have put myself fully into scarf weaving for this comming Christmas for the whole family.  I have 20 scarfs to weave by Dec of 2013. most of them for youngsters. The colors seclection in acrylic is mind blowing. I love Caron simply soft , simply because it is just that if woven in a nice and lose it as soft as any expensive natural yarn and washs and wares like a dream for a long long time.   I have had one acrylic scarf for years and still looks great after many many washings! Count me in as an acrylic weaver !!!

Weavejoyforall

I have woven just one real piece so far lots of samples though.  All have been acrylic yarns some with cotton warp...but Now I went out and bought lots of acrylic since its so inexpensive and holds up so well to washing, for kids scarfs a MUST.   I have put myself fully into scarf weaving for this comming Christmas for the whole family.  I have 20 scarfs to weave by Dec of 2013. most of them for youngsters. The colors seclection in acrylic is mind blowing. I love Caron simply soft , simply because it is just that if woven in a nice and lose it as soft as any expensive natural yarn and washs and wares like a dream for a long long time.   I have had one acrylic scarf for years and still looks great after many many washings! Count me in as an acrylic weaver !!!

marmaladefiend

Hello! This is a really interesting thread, and thanks to everyone for sharing.  I think about fiber types a lot, so it is wonderful to hear other people's views.

While I agree that acrylic has some really interesting and unique patterns, colors, and textures and can be used to make really beautiful things, I never use it. In fact, I recently donated all my acrylic to one of my room mate's therapy patients because it was much more useful to her than sitting in my closet :)

I don't use acryclic because I don't think it is manfactured in a way that is responsible. Petroleum and plastics are things I'm trying to get away from in my life. Naturally it isn't possible to be completely free of those things, but when I have the option I do what I can. Weaving is one of those places. Since it is a luxury when I can find time to weave, I like to make the best of that time, and I feel like it's okay to spend a little extra in order to reach that goal. There are so many ways to experiment with natural fibers that I don't think I am going to run out of options any time soon (especially because I am pretty new to this!)

Also, most of my friends who are having babies now don't want acrylics and polyester blends in the items that their babies use. So, I find that planning for the shrinkage of cotton is a better option in a baby blanket than using something that doesn't shrink.

Thanks all!

SallyE (not verified)

I don't use acrylic either.   I don't like the feel of it and I don't like how it's made.   It seems that if you are going to go to all the trouble to hand weave something, then it's worth it to use a really nice fiber - cotton, linen wool or silk.  Silk is by far my favorite, but it's expensive.

I might try tencil at some point, and I have some nice bamboo that I bought at a de-stashing sale, but haven't tried that yet. 

warpology

The guild I belong to in NC hadd a winter challenge to weave blankets for Linus which give blankets to needy  children. The main requirement is that they be washable. I didn't want the stretchy quality in my warp so it is mercerized cotton and the weft is Red Heart Acrylic baby yarn. It is one ply yarn one ply a shiny material I sampled it and liked the effect. It was resonably priced. They were woven on a 24 shaft AVL and have the words Baby boy oh boy baby boy woven on the diagonal. 

I'm a spinner also and process my own fleeces but I feel Acrylic has a place  whether it is in weaving or knitting. Tencel  uses some chemicals to be produced, White cotton uses a lot of chemicals to be produced. It would be nice to be a purist but life is too short and I haven't got that much money!

ReedGuy

Local wool I get is cheaper than acrylic, unless I get Softspun. Plus the wool is spun here. Softspun is ok for the kids for scarves, it hasn't got the lanolin all taken out, so it's softer and not as scratchy. And the Softspun is the better grade, and about $2.50 more a skein. Alpaca is of course more espensive. But in all, I like natural fibre like cotton and wool the best. Never yet explored linen or rayon. I like the idea of trying a wood product because rayon is also made here locally. The funny part of that though is that product is shipped from here to India. Although I have used acrylic, I am no fan of it.

JacRoyce

Hulloooo

I prefer the feel of natural fibers, and dislike the idea of supporting the petrochemical industries in any way, but often can't resist the fabulous colors and quirkiness of certain acrylic yarns. Plus, it is an option for the wool-sensitive folks.

BUT: Never use acrylic for babies. The way acrylic burns and melts and keeps on burning puts the baby at serious risk of harm. Everything I make for babies is either cotton or alpaca. Alpaca is best (and most expensive, of course) because it is naturally flame/burn retardant. And, cotton just keeps getting softer as you wash it. 

When I make a cotton baby blanket, I make it bigger than I want and then wash and dry it. And colors! Great colors!

 

Weavejoyforall

There is really no comparing to be done.  I would of course love to weave with all natural yarns... here it would cost me to much for me to weave at all if I tryed to use all natural materials... we have no local stores for inexpencive natural yarns...  Walmart is my closest source for yarn..YES we do have several yarn shops but the yarns are Way Out of my price range and I do mean Way Out of my price range I can get the acrylic of less then 4.00(3.49) for 6oz scain (Caron simply soft)  which is just berely thin enough to use for warp without to much fraying in my little brio looms narrow heddle.

JacRoyce

If the main reason you use acrylic is because it's the only thing you can get locally—or, at least, the only reasonably-priced fiber—try buying online. WEBS at yarn.com, Paradise Fibers, The Woolery, etc. Even if you only buy what they have on Sale, you'll do well. Also, don't overlook thrift stores. 

mrdubyah (not verified)

I use acrylic for baby blankets and clothes because its so easy to wash.  Unfortunately, it's also made of oil and therefore highly flammable unless treated with  fire retardants, most of which are carcinogenic.  A few researchers are begining to study the impacts of man-made yarns on human physiology.  See http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15421400490479190 for example.  Results indicate that clothing made of man-made fiber may have effects on motor unit activity and/or immune system response in the wearers.  Man-made fibers have changed the world, but not all the changes are improvements. 

JacRoyce

mrdubyah,

I read the abstract and downloaded the article so that I could learn more. I'm also going to link to it whenever possible. Just say no to petrochemical-based yarn!

fifthoffive (not verified)

Very early in my weaving experience I used acrylic yarn with wool yarn in a plain weave doublewidth blanket.  My daughter brought me some wool yarn she wanted woven into a blanket.  There wasn't enough to make the size blanket she wanted, so I went to the local yarn store to buy some additional yarn.  What I found turned out to be acrylic.  I didn't even consider the shrinkage differential between wool and acrylic.  I think it came out great.

Rules are useful... until they're not.  I'm constantly amazed at how weaving projects don't necessarily behave as I expect them to.

The multi-color shiny yarn is acrylic, the solid color yarn is wool.

 

janenedriscoll

Thanks for posting this.  I came across this thread a while ago and have been thinking about how to reply.  I take inspiration from the folks promoting mindful eating, where they encourage folks to think about where their food comes from while they are eating.  They ecourage you to look at the colors and beauty in the food, enjoy how it smells and tastes while you eat.  Visualizing the food as it comes from the plant or animal most likely will encourage one to eat more sustainably, which is better for our bodies as well as the planet.  I think the same can be said for the fibers we weave with. 

I wonder if we really want to wrap our babies or ourselves in fibers made from petroleum products?  Think for a moment about the source of acrylic yarns versus the souce of renewable plant or animal fibers. 

I have made wonderful, totally washable and machine dryable baby blankets out of Brown Sheeps's Cotton Fleece, sometimes, but not always, adding perle cotton to the warp.  I have one little friend who has loved her blanket for 10 years already.  The blanket has taken on features of the Velveteen Rabbit, and goes with her everywhere.  Each spring she brings it to my house and we celebrate her Special Blanket with a fancy tea!

You don't need to use plastic fibers to make heirloom baby blankets.

Happy Weaving,

Janene

ReedGuy

I don't know if it would be heirloom anyway. I've seen what kids can do with a blanket and just wait until they play tug of war with the family dog with it. :D

Back in my grandmother's younger years there was no going down to the fabric shop to get yards of cloth. I don't even know if there were much for looms. But she used to make sheets and such from the White Clover flour bags, which were cotton. She kept some of those in an old trunk as  the years went buy. And my uncle lived at home all his life so he hung onto them to. He passed away last Nov and now mom has them and he told her not to toss them out. Now who in my generation and for what purpose would anyone want those old flour bag sheets? A many Hudson Bay wool blankets made a few winter coats as well.

momaine

  I just finished these baby blankets out of a very soft acrylic baby yarn.  Very happy with the finish & the drape. 

mardonmac

I am a beginning weaver who has not had a lot of time to experiment or take lessons as I am also a speech language pathologist & have been busy with "work"....ove the kids, hate the paperwork!  LOL!!!

I have a stash of "good yarns", but decided to go to W**Mart* a year & a half ago to look at "inexpensive" alternatives....I bought a BUNCH of Lion Heart Acrylics & am experimenting doing placemats & scaves for friends, before I use the "good stuff" for really nice gifts!  Meanwhile, I am getting compliments from a friend who was an Art History major on my choices of colors, textures, other fibers (e.g., jute., hemp, etc).

I will let you all know how my Jute/acrylic/waxed hemp combination placemats work out...a gift for a friend whom I see from "time to time".....They LOOK cool, but will they last????

francorios (not verified)

Welcome to the group! Thanks for the post!
Have a good day!

trkeyfrm

i was looking for more warp material... liked the colors, and the price.... and have been using acrylic ever since.   between that and the well washed t-shirts, polos, denim and what not... nothing has shrunk yet.

quepasoJackie

This is my first post, and I'm a fairly new weaver.

I love wool the best for the feel and the look, but I'm still learning so I like acrylic because I can afford to learn.  When I get better, I will use tencel and wool more. 

This is an all-acrylic throw which I just took off my 8-shaft loom (white and black are Caron Simply soft) and the Green is Joann's new Heartland heather yarn. I'm pretty impressed with this, and it is pretty fabuloulously acrylic!

Jackie in Texas

JacRoyce

I don't wish to be cranky at anyone in particular, nor am I trying to insert shame into this discussion—I just want folks to THINK and to CHOOSE.

You all know by now that acrylic fiber is petroleum-based—remember the Gulf oil spill or the more recent pipeline disaster in the heartland?—and manufactured in ways that cause further damage to the planet. Do you really want to give those corporations any more of your money? And what's the point of making a baby blanket out of a material that represents the ongoing destruction of that baby's environment? Or any other clothing, accessories, throws, or pillows that can be used as an accelerant for a fire? Oh yeah, and the fiber causes physiological damage to the wearer and to the weaver...

Pretty? Sure. So what? Cheap? Not truly, especially in the long run.

sequel (not verified)

If you are going undermine this thread with negative opinions, please cite your original sources so that we can learn from them.

mrdubyah (not verified)

Let's distinguish between facts and opinions.  In my opinion, polyester yarns are fun to work with, inexpensive, and (with the right brand of yarn) make very lovely fabrics.  I find them quite useful for some purposes.  However, the facts clearly indicate that clothes made of polyester and other man-made fibers have adverse health effects on humans.  I've cited one source to document this fact above.  Here's another source: http://www.biotecharticles.com/Toxicology-Article/Toxic-Fibers-and-Fabr…. There are plenty more sources available to anyone willing to do a little research.  In short, I don't have a negative opinion of polyester, but I do avoid using it for clothing that will be worn over bare skin and advise others to do so as well.

 

endorph

acrylic yarns over the years for many, many projects - as well as synthetic / natural blends. It is a personal choice and sometimes it depends on the project at hand and what will work the best. I fully realize that it is a petroleum based material - so are many of the other products used in everyday life nit the least of which is the gasoline burned in my car and most of the plastics found in common household and workplace environments. We can't escape petroleum based products in life unless you want to completely isolate yourself and go off the grid in so many ways. I respect those weavers, knitters, etc. who do not want to use acrylics but please - while you are stating facts about how bad it is for the environment lets not ignore the fact that many of the natural fibers you want us to use instead are also processed with chemicals and dyes that are bad for the environment and the people handling them. When I have the choice of a natural fiber over man made, I usually will go for the natural, but sometimes acrylic will work better or is more available for the task at hand. Each to their own - if you like it great, if you don't, great - I am seeing some very nice and beautiful projects on this page - lets celebrate the creativity and skill of the people who have shared those projects with us.

JacRoyce

Hullooo

Thanks again to Mr. Dubya for listing (again) the links to the scientific information about the dangers of using polyester fiber. Facts. 

I did not urge anyone to use other materials that are destructive. As I said, I wish folks to THINK and to CHOOSE. Of course, you're entitled to your own opinions, and to your own decisions about which methods and products you are comfortable with adopting in order to help provide a cleaner, safer planet for the generations who were not involved in changing the climate. You can only do what YOU can do.

My dad always told me that Two Wrongs Don't Make A Right. He was also big on "Everyone's entitled to their own opinion, but no one's entitled to their own facts."

Yes, there's a lot of beautiful work being displayed on this forum. This work would be just as beautiful if it were made with other materials.

Jac

 

mrdubyah (not verified)

Lest you think me an anti-acrylic luddite, here's a lovely log-cabin baby blanket I just finished that is 100% acrylic.  Caron is perfect for baby blankets as it's very soft and very washable.  The recipient mom has been advised to limit long term skin contact and to avoid flames with this blanket.  She loves it and so do I.  

 

Doanart

The blanket is lovely!  The shimmering of the fibers look a lot like perle cotton in your photo!  I personally love working with natural fibers, but I have so much acrylic yarn that has been passed on to me that I will end up making more acrylic weavings. (The image on my thumbnail here is a weaving made with acrylic)

endorph

mrdubyah what a beautiful blanket - I love the shimmer. I'm with you Doanart - I prefer natural fibers but I have to be careful about what dyes were used on them - I too have been gifted large amounts of various acrylic and acrylic blend yarns so they usually get used in mixed fiber warps. I have given a bunch away to friends and charities that want acrylic yarns so. . . .

mrdubyah (not verified)

Thanks for your kind words.  One more point on man-made fibers: combining man-made yarns that won't shrink with wool fibers that will can give you lots of interesting 3d effects in wet finishing.  For example, try putting two or three bands of wool in an otherwise acrylic warp.  When you throw the fabric in hot water the wool will shrink and force the acrylic to pucker up in waves.  This can be fun!

sequel (not verified)

I read the article and do not see any citing of studies, data or links to the data the author used to support her conclusions.  Have you contacted the Center for Disease Control or National Institutes of Health for corroboration?

ReedGuy

You can read all kinds of claims on the internet and believe what ever path you want to follow. If there is no peer review of the 'research' than you can consider it mostly a biased opinion. But there is a lot of stuff made of plastic, that should be made from renewables. Examples: berry boxes, grocery bags, window frames, siding, serving trays, cutting boards, furniture. Take a berry box, a single aspen log turned on a  rotary lathe can make hundreds of berry boxes and there are billions of aspen trees in colder climates growing like weeds. It's actually a very low tech process often done in a back yard shed. Here in New Brunswick we still make aspen berry boxes and any vender selling strawberries and raspberries here use them 100 %. In the store, if there are berries in plastic boxes they are 100 % imported.

mrdubyah (not verified)

Sequel - If you really want to learn more about this topic you can find plenty of scholarly sources yourself.  In addition to the citation above for Malgorzata Zimniewska & Ryszard Kozlowskia above, I recommend you try:

Clement, Anna Maria, and Clement, Brian, Killer Clothes: How Seemingly Innocent Clothing Choices Endanger Your Health . . . And How to Protect Yourself! Hippocrates Publications, 2011

EPA has published extensively on the health risks and carcinogenicity of Acrylonitrile (the major component of acrylic yarns).  See http://www.epa.gov/chemfact/acry-sd.txt for more details.

For information on breast cancer risks of occupational exposure to acrylic fibers see Labreche et.al. http://oem.bmj.com/content/67/4/263.abstract.

There are also sources almost beyond count on the general ecological impact of the petroleum industry which I should not have to cite for you.  Suffice it to say that the largest manufacturer of Acrylonitrile in the world today is BP, and their track record should be obvious. 

None of this is intended to demonize petroleum based yarns.  They can be quite lovely and are certainly fun to work with.  Nearly all modern products have some risks.  The important thing is to be aware of the risks, manage your exposures and make informed choices.  Please do your own research and make up your own mind.

 

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on