I'm working on a shawl and on on my 2nd attempt. I'm trying to weave the "Budget Bamboo Shawl" in the Sept-Oct 2009 issue of Handwoven. The shawl is Atwater-Bronson lace (a weave structure I've used with tencel before with no problems). Instead of using the bamboo crochet threat, I'm using 8/2 tencel. The directions call for 15 epi but I'm using 20 for the tencel. Both attempts have resulted in warp threads on both sides fraying and breaking. I've repaired broken warps so many times I've lost count. I've been paying attention to my draw-in and I don't have extra heddles causing yarns to space out too far. There is about 3/4 inch draw-in on each side so there is a bit of friction on the warps every time I beat the weft in - but again, I've never had this be a cause for repeated breakage. Should I have a closer sett - maybe 24 epi, or Is this a case where I just need to bite the bullet and buy a temple? Any ideas? Thanks!

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

3/4 inch draw in on each side of a shawl is simply excessive. You can't really say you are paying attention other than on noting how much it is. More than 1/4" on each side is enough to break or abrade warp threads.

Yes, you'll need to make or buy - and use a temple.

And pelase note that the temple is also there to make sure that each dent in your reed beats perpendicular to the weft - with that severe draw in will have the threads in the center distorted on an angle each time you beat lessening the effect of the reed.

ReedGuy

Yes, make a temple or have one made. There is very little material cost, but you have to use well dried straight grained wood or the "fork" can curve in opposite directions. I recommend a drill press for the holes to line up straight. You can't drill free hand. If you know of a wood worker or carpenter he can whip one up in no time.

 

 

From Edward Worst's book, you can find the plans.

http://archive.org/details/footpowerloomwea00worsrich

 

Cynthia Kidder

I meant that I made sure I always had enough yarn in the shed to accomodate the interaction of warp and weft. Occasionally, I had to open the shed and pull the weft and little tighter as I had loops at the selvedge. Your comment that "You can't really say you are paying attention other than on noting how much it is" is inaccurate. You might have asked for more particulars before passing judgement. I am looking for helpful input - not sarcastic assumptions. If anyone else can address this, I'd be most appreciative. One thing I'd really like to know is, is it just the nature of lace weaves, because of the openess of the weave, to draw in more? Could this be part of what's causing my problem? If I rewarp with more than 20 epi, will that help stabilize the fabric and keep it from drawing in so much? Thanks!

ReedGuy

Tension has a lot to do with it. Your shuttle may be abrasing the warp if the shed isn't open enough. This may occur when the fall line gets too close to the reed before you advance the warp a few inches again or from draw-in of the weaved piece from too much weft tension. To help against draw in a temple is needed. Each type of yarn and it's weight also has a temperament to it's own. Some is more elastic than others.

Joanne Hall

I use a temple on every warp, except tapestry and sometimes on a warp faced weave.  The reason is that the quality of the end product is what is important.  Not only will the selvages not break, but you will be able to control the beat, getting more wefts per inch if you need it.  And using the temple means that you do not have to beat as hard, which in the end will be better for your arms and shoulders.

Peter Collingwood used to answer temple questions and he noted that temples have been used for many centuries, citing a stain glass window in a church in Europe where a temple is in use on a loom and the church was built in the 12th century.

Joanne

PS  The sett you use should be based on how you want the fabric to look, not on whether or not you use a temple.

mneligh

For each weft throw, do you make sure there's either a bow or an angle or curves to the weft so that there is enough slack for the weft to bend around the warp but not so much that there are loops sticking out?

When holding the shuttle at the edges, make sure you don't tug the last row too tight.  

Temples can help, but your weft tension also needs to be correct.

Loosely spun yarns also fray easily, and plant fibers that lack crimp or other cohesiveness tend to pill and fray more than other types of fibers.

Cynthia Kidder

my yarn is at an angle in the shed before I beat it in. Given all the problems I've been having with this project, I've been especially careful about this. In fact, with this project, sometimes I've been too careful and left too much slack and had to reopen the shed to get rid of the loop at the selvedge. I'm using tencel and I've used it with Atwater-Bronson lace before and never, ever had these problems.

sally orgren

There was a bad batch of Iris several years ago, for awhile it wasn't available. How old is your tencel?

debmcclintock

Cynthia, you can try a simple balsa wood pin temple.  You can cut the balsa stick a bit wider than your warp width and use the pins.  Here's a link to how I use my balsa temple

They are based on Southeast Asian temples and work well.

Cynthia Kidder

I'm using is taupe and I purchased it 1 year ago.

Broderie (not verified)

tencel does have a habit of easily abrading. I have used fishline, or beadalon line for an extra "floating selvedge" to help the problem I had with some scarves doing that. You can easily slide that out after it's off the loom. But it does sound like you have too much draw in. I have only been weaving about a year and a half, but have tried a lot of things so far & have not had that much draw in, & I have done lace. Before each shuttle throw, try making sure there is weft 'loose' before you pass shuttle, so that the weft isn't having to roll off the bobbin so much. Also, I have found times when I didn't wind the bobbin as well, and that will also cause issues. Check are the bobbins rotating easily, could be a lot of things going on. Maybe you're simply trying to pull the weft too "snug". Try changing some of the things you are doing. Different things work for different people.

Dawn McCarthy

A temple will definitely help.  Have you tried adding a floating selvedge or doubling your last ends?  Tencel does have a tendency to abrade and it is not a tightly twisted yarn.  Sometimes I add a fake selvedge thread to either side but do not treat it as a floating selvedge (I do not include it as part of the weaving).  I find it takes the friction away from the actual warp ends.  Find a balance of less tension, more generous angle of weft and perhaps a "buffer" floating selvedge.  You may just have a bum run of tencel!  Baby it and I hope some advice from everyone gets you through the warp.  Good luck!

Dawn

http://bloominloom.wordpress.com

 

 

Cynthia Kidder

do you mean less warp tension while I'm weaving?  I have about a 45 degree angle of weft in the shed.  Should there be more?  I will definitely try the buffer floating selvedges.  Thanks.

Dawn McCarthy

Sounds like you have tried reducing tension on the warp already and a generous weft angle.  Are you using a different reed (sorry if I am repeating questions from previous responses) check the reed is clear of any pitting.  Advance the warp frequently, are you using old wire heddles, are they free of any rust?  Did you warp front to back?  These factors might contribute to the wear and tear on the yarn.  Do you have a similar color yarn/grist that you can use for the "selvedge" ends.  Post pics and let us know your progress.  

Dawn

 

Dena (not verified)

I've done a lot of weaving with tencel (many hundreds of scarves) and it's taken me a long time to figure out how to make it behave. The best tip I got (after years of asking people) is that tencel doesn't respond well to high tension. Not on your weft threads, but on your warp. It breaks the internal structure of the yarn and it loses it's elasticity. This leads to your finished fabric (or mine anyway) not having a fabulous drape and holding any wrinkles. Do you put high tension on your warp? If so, it's possible that the tencel is compromised and the broken threads are a result of that. I once had someone suggest that I should spray my selvedge threads with water since tencel is stronger when wet. Too much work for me, but it could help you get through this warp. I typically have draw in of around 3/4" per side on my scarves and it doesn't lead to broken edge threads, so I don't believe that a temple is necessary or that it's definitely going to solve the problem. I did finally work it out and I'm proud to say that I've woven twenty tencel scarves in the two weeks without one broken thread!

Cynthia Kidder

I have had my warp under high tension.  I'll try working with less warp tension and I'll keep a spray bottle of water handy to dampen the selvedge yarns.  Thanks for the tip!

Cynthia Kidder

I have a 4 shaft table top loom which has been converted to a floor loom.  I'm having problems keeping the loom in square.  I had to remove my most recent project because sometimes when I advanced the warp the beater bar was no longer in line with the fell. I've removed the project from the loom because I was having too many issues with this.

Does anyone know how to easily realign a loom into square?

Thank you

Cynthia Kidder

Cynthia Kidder

I have a 4 shaft table top loom which has been converted to a floor loom.  I'm having problems keeping the loom in square.  I had to remove my most recent project because sometimes when I advanced the warp the beater bar was no longer in line with the fell. I've removed the project from the loom because I was having too many issues with this.

Does anyone know how to easily realign a loom into square?

Thank you

Cynthia Kidder

CelticCats

Instead of a temple you could try using a cloths pin pinned to the selvage, attach a weight, place a long stick between you back and front beams on both sides and then drape the weights over the sticks to pull the fabric out to the width in the reed. I saw this done somewhere but sorry I can't remember where. I thought it was a great idea. I am a new weaver and did a lot of research on the internet. Was also very lucky I had bought a used Julia by glimakra and found Joanne at glimakrausa.com. She recommended a temple and they really are lifesavers. Was looking at the fireside setup($300) and the disadvantage I see to them is that you have to advance fabric a lot instead of moving the temple. Also looks like the fireside temple sits very close to the breast beam and not sure I would get a good beat. Decided to stay with temples. Just wish I would stop poking myself. Good luck and hope you find a good solution.

sequel (not verified)

Is your loom out of square, or do you have a continuous apron string tying the warp or cloth stick to the beam.  A continuous string that loops over the bar that you tie on to can shift while weaving or advancing the warp.  You can also check to see if your beater is square as well. 

Check your loom for square by measuring the distance on a diagonal in both directions.  If the diagonal measurement is the same or close to it then your loom is square and your problems lie elsewhere.

pammersw

Is it the loom out of square, or the weaving?  Be sure to have even tension on the warp and at selvages, and pull the beater evenly rather than from one side. This will keep your weaving even.

Submitted by Cynthia Kidder on