My wife and I have just completed a five month, very patient and careful construction of a 60" , 8-shaft countermarche loom. It looks great, but our stomachs fell---along with the shafts---when we pulled the jack-locking pin.  For our first tie-up we are using only four shafts and six treadles. Following the suggestions of Joanne Hall, we have tied in an extra treadle to all the long lams on the four shafts we are using, but we were only able to get a balance by adding 7-8 lbs to the forward part of that treadle, the tenth or farthest outside one. We tried adding weight to the lams, but it did no seem as effective as to the treadles.  Although the tie-up is balanced, the addtional weight makes the treadling more difficult and we wondered if this is an unusually high corrective weight. Any and all comments and suggestions welcome.

Maurice

Comments

celtinbirks

Do you have Joann's book "Tying Up the Countermarch Loom"?  It helped me SO much.

kerstinfroberg

If the sheds are ok, the "falling" of the shafts are of no importance. When weaving, the actual sheds are the only thing that is important - when just looking at the loom, if the fallen shafts are troubling you, just put in the pin(s).

BTW - you *do* have a warp in place, yes? W/o a warp, anything can happen!

PS: with "ok sheds" I mean "shed floors". The upper layer(s) are also of no importance (when actually weaving), as long as the shed is big enough to let the shuttle pass.

Maurice

Thanks, Kerstin. Yes there is a warp. The sheds are OK with the added weight on the extra treadle. Otherwise, not.

Maurice

 

Joanne Hall

Hi Maurise,

A common mistake in making a loom is to use a hardwood for the shaft bars.  The shafts need to be light weight.  The shafts do not need sides, which only adds more weight.  Upper lamms also need to be light weight.  Tell us how much your shafts weigh.  With the heddles one shaft should only weigh 1 to 1.5 lbs.  The upper lamms would weigh only about about  6 oz.

Photos would be helpful.

Joanne

Maurice

Guilty on all counts: the shafts, made of ash, weigh about 5 lbs each with 50 heddles and two steel heddle bars. The ends are metal, similar to those in the Harrisville loom used by Jason Collingwood. The short lams are also of ash and weigh about 1 pound each. I don't know if we would be able to use a lighter shaft and still be able to mount a shaft-switching device, so we may have to live with the extra treadling effort...I had once thought of using aluminum for the shaft bars, but couldn't find a suitable stock at a decent price; maybe I'll look again.

Thanks,

Maurice

 

Joanne Hall

make some prototype light weight shafts and upper lamms.  You could try it with just two shafts, maybe making the shaft bars out of a couple of thin dowels.  The shaft bars can hold the heddles without having sides on the ends.  If you have metal heddles, tie some string heddles just to try this.  The lamms can be  about 1/2 inch by 3/4 inch and only as long as needed to tie up the treadles.  Then see how this makes a difference.  Your lower lamms are probably just fine.

Joanne

Maurice

Thanks, Joanne; we will certainly try your recommendations as soon as the current warp is off the loom....How does the Harrisville rug loom (Collingwood loom) balance?  It is made almost entirely of hard maple, has metal shaft ends and metal headle bars. Can't say with certainty, but it appears that the lams and shaft bars are maple as well. I've only seen one, have never used one, but I've looked at photos and video excerpts. None of them appear to show any compensating weighting, not even tie-ups to the extra treadle(s). What's the secret?

Maurice

Maurice

 

Maurice

 

Joanne Hall

need to heavy enough to balance the weight of the shafts and upper lamms.  Maybe their lower lamms are heavy.  I would need to look more closely at the Harrisville loom to answer your question.  Maybe the shaft bars and metal heddle bars are very thin. 

When you treadle, shafts which are heavy and not balancing, then instead of tipping the balance to treadle, like on a teeter totter with equal weight on each end, you are actually lifting the weight of the shafts.  That makes the treadling harder.  And when shafts fall, they make the treadles rise up higher when at rest.  Then you have to lift your foot higher to treadle.

Joanne

Maurice

We have pretty much disassembled the shafts and lamms from the loom and have backed off the warp to the back beam. This has allowed us to weigh all the individual parts: long and short lamms, shaft bars,  etc. Rather than remake all these in a soft wood, we are first going to try drilling out a large portion of the short lamms and shaft bars. The are made from ash, a very stong wood which, I think would support a large number of holes and still be functional. We will probably do the same with the metal shaft ends. I've also ordered a hanging spring scale to see exactly what forces are work here. We will get in balance!

Maurice/Deborah

 

 

ReedGuy

If you have a thickness planer you can slim down those upper lamms and shaft bars. Mine are a heavier wood than yours (hard maple) and my shafts and string heddles, upper lamms combined are under 2 lbs and the lower lamms are 5 oz heavier or so. I have trimmed mine down since my first posting of my loom project this past winter. But my parts where never near as heavy as you've stated on yours. They don't need to be because your not really pulling much weight as long as the loom parts involved aren't made too thick. You could take those shaft bars down to 3/8" thick. Work with quartered material. Now with that being said being quartered does not mean the wood won't have fits and might be drying some because of removal of outside wood. Further drying may cause a bowed piece to straigten out in a  few days. It's just that with quartered, the thickness dimension (tangential) will move more (percentage wise about double) than the width (across rings). Some species there is not much difference (Pacific yew, eastern red cedar, birch, eastern hop-hornbeam)

Joanne Hall

are usually only used for jack looms to hold metal heddles, both for added weight that jack loom shafts need.  Do you really need the metal bars?  Maybe the wooden shaft bars can be less tall as well as thinner and you can put the heddles around the wood, like on a traditional counterbalance or countermarch loom.

Joanne

Maurice

We would like to retain the wire heddles  as we think that they will work better with the shaft-switching device we have built to weave weft-faced rugs. We are working on using 1/16" wire rope under tension (somewhere around F below middle C---wire heddles are about 2.5 ounces/100) instead of a heddle bar. If that is successful we will be able to use wooden ends weighing less than the metal ones. We have started reducing the dimensions of the shaft bars and have substituted a much less heavy wood for the short lamms. This should about halve the weight of the original shafts.

We had the opportunity last weekend to see a Harrisville rug loom. The shafts on it had metal end pieces and a metal heddle bar which appeared to be heavier than those found on most jack looms. The short lamms were about half the size (and weight) of the long ones, but I was unable to determine the type of wood used for them or for the shaft bars. All the lamms are packed tightly together, as Peter Collinwood, with whom the loom was developed, wanted all the lamms on one level. The shaft bars were about 1-3/8" deep by 3/8" thick. The owner told me that she has never had to make any balancing adjustments, not even so much as tying in the long lamms to the spare treadles.

Thanks for your help. We may not have followed all your suggestions, but neophytes that we are, they have always stimulated new thought pathways.

Maurice

 

 

Maurice

Thanks for the suggestions; we have already reduced the wooden members of the shafts. Not quarter-sawn, but there is no apparent distortion. See also my post this morning to Joanne Hall.

Maurice

Joanne Hall

It sounds like you are solving the problem.  Did you compare your treadles to the Harrisville treadles.  On thing that Toika does for this problem is to have heavy treadles.

Joanne

Maurice

I did indeed compare the treadles and they appeared very alike. It's good to know that weighting the treadles has been adopted by some. It's really the most convenient place to add weight.

Maurice

 

ReedGuy

Always one another way to get to the same destination. ;)

Maurice

Thanks, folks. We followed the several strands of advice above, plus a few other inovations and now have a working 68" countermarch loom. We've spent the last three weeks remaking the shafts and short lamms (of poplar, a very light wood), remade the shaft ends of aluminum instead of steel, used strips of white ash for the heddle bars instead of steel, changed the shaft/long lamm lever ratio on the jacks. and added some small weight evenly to the long lamms. When we pulled the locking pin, nothing budged. We thought at first that perhaps something was stuck, but the following reponse of the treadles was smooth and definite. Tune-up tomorrow.

Maurice and Deborah

 

Submitted by Maurice on