I am thinking about buying a serger, (There is a good sale on a singer Pro Finish).   I have never used one, but have heard folks talk about them.     What sort of woven items could you use them on to finish an edge that you do not want fringe on?  Do many use them?  Were the experiences positive?   Any advise on what to get?

 

Thanks

Comments

Claudia Segal (not verified)

I am in the same boat, Tom.  I have been considering buying one for a while.  I assume it comes in handy when finishing cut edges on handwovens being used for clothing.  I remember reading somewhere that the project I was considering was a jacket where you cut the handwoven fabric and serged the edges of the piece before constructing the jacket.

I believe it could come in handy when making rugs and serging the edges at the beginning and end.

Claudia

braider96

Try before you buy if possible. It is usually better to buy from a local dealer than a box store. They will teach you how to use the machine. You might consider trading services with a sewer, cloth for serger access. A decent serger will cost at least $500. If you rarely use you may want to put your money into fiber. If you sew alot it is probably worth it. Check on-line reviews of the machine before you buy. Consumer Reports probably has a recent review of entry level sergers.

SunriseLodgeFi… (not verified)

I recently bought a serger for hemming my hand woven napkins with a nice rolled edge.  I bought from a store (and got a little over 50% off because of a sale!!!) and got lessons there.  Once the machine was home, I was able to plow through the stash of fabric for napkins quite quickly.  

The only problem.....I had to change the thread color for the next set.  Well.....that was the end of rolled hems for me. :)  I've heard that it takes quite some time to get familiar with sergers and they'll be your worst enemy before they become your best friend.  

All in all I was happy with getting the serger and know that I can work it.......it's just that tension thing I've got to get used to.  This is, again, why it's very important to make sure you have someone to ask questions or a store that doesn't mind you bringing it back for help when needed.

Best wishes!

Shannon:):):)

tomrsey (not verified)

I have been searching online, and visiting stores.  I bought the Singer, but am goint to return it.  I haven't opened the box yet.  Reviews on that one are very mixed and many appear at both ends of the scale.   Confusing.   I also payed attention to the comments so generously offered, and decided to go to a sewing store near here.  They sell Brother brand, and reviews there have been more consistently favorable.   She showed me two models, and quite frankly, the second model had enough features to make the $200 difference in price worth it.   The other factor that helped in the decision, was that she offered free unlimited classes whenever I needed them.    Classes can be expensive, and, having never used a serger, (and only minimal skills on a regular sewing machine) I think I will be ahead of the game, by making good use of the classes. 

 

It is a bit scarey, and a big investment, but I  really want to be able to make garments with yardage that I weave, and this seems to be a necessary tool for that goal. 

 

Thanks again for all the comments and suggestions.

B P (not verified)

I have a Babylock Evolve serger that works really well. It came with really clear instructions, and I also purchased a separate work book that is also a great help.

Beth

braider96

I don't think you will regret your decision. Sewing machines/sergers are very frustrating if poorly made especially with tension. I have a suggestion. When trying out your serger, practice on similar weight scrap cloth in a light color. Then write on the cloth with a sharpie indicating your settings. This can serve as a reference for future sewing. If you have scraps of handwovens to test, you can attach a label with that information. Buying all those thread cones in matching colors can be costly. To start with, you may want a taupe and a grey. Those colors "go with" most cloth. Most chain fabric stores regularly put thread on sale so that would be a great time to stock up.

CraftinSusan

I bought my first serger back in 1990. Since then I have used a number of different brands and models. I also teach serging and sewing. One thing I do is to use the serger to finish the cut ends of fabric (store-bought and handwoven) before I wash it to prevent raveling. The serger is great to use on seams to prevent the fabric from raveling but also the serger adds a professional finish to the item. I have used a lot of different fabrics in my sergers through out the years. Sergers work on all fabric including wovens as well as knits. All sergers are NOT created equal. Some are so hard to thread correctly that you will be frustrated and won't use the serger. There are some Baby Lock models like the Enlighten and the Evolve that are very easy to thread. We just push a button and whoosh! The upper and lower loopers are instantly threaded (these are usually the hard-to-thread ones. Some sergers have accessory feet so we can expand what the serger can do. The best, and fastest, way to learn to use any serger is through lessons and classes. Please check out your local sewing machine dealers to see what classes and support are offered by the dealer. Yes, you will pay more for the serger but in the long run it will be worth it because you will actually use the serger. Please sit down at the different machines with some fabric to see how you like the machine. Is it easy to thread? Are you comfortable with the machine? My latest serger (purchased 4 years ago) is a Baby Lock Imagine Wave (now called the Enlighten). This is a fabulous machine. It is easy to thread and use. There are a number of accessory feet for it allowing me to make my own piping and to even serge zippers in. There is even a blind hem foot as well as a gathering foot. Now sergers won't take the place of a sewing machine but there are a lot of things I can do faster with better results using a serger rather than one of my sewing machines. The secret is to get a serger you are comfortable with.

passapman (not verified)

There are only a few companies in the world that manufacture sergers. They are made to spec and branded. Juki, Janome, Jaguar, Toyota, and Brother are the only manufacturers of home sergers I can think of. Consew is an industrial brand that, to my knowledge, does not cross into the domestic arena. More $$$ equals easier use, higher quality, more versatility.

Ask yourself "What will I use?" If you do not need a coverstitch, don't buy it. Ditto for five thread. You can buy a very, very good serger for $499.00 that will do 2,3, and 4 thread serging, rolled hems and flatlocking. When sergers first entered the domestic market they used industrial needles. Consumers demanded that they use houshold needles. Now the trend is reversing because household machine needles break more easily under the stress of high speed serging. Feet are now available for blind hemming, pintucking, binding and a host of functions once thought impossible for sergers to perform.

A serger can be used to make passamenteri trims, decorate edges with thick thread in the loopers. The potential of the serger has hardly been tapped. But you can always upgrade if you want more later. I have had excellent service from my Elna 4DE. It is about 20 years old. Elna has consistently been rated high in qulity and user friendliness. The new Husqvarna Viking 'H' series serger is very nice. I have sewn on it. If I needed a serger I would by it at $499.00

Another source is All Brands. They sell Brother sergers, including the model sold on HSN. Great price, money back guarantee. DVD included.

Look for generic serger classes in your area, too. You might be able to try several models to help you decide.

CraftinSusan

passapman, your information is mostly true but I should point out the Baby Lock sergers are a combination of Juki parts and Baby Lock special patents. I don't know where Brother gets it's serger parts but I doubt that they make their own pieces. Same with Janome, Bernina, Viking, Singer, Elna. To save on research costs, most companies cooperate with each other to share those development costs. The same holding company that owns Pfaff bought Singer and then a few years ago bought Viking. That is why the Viking Diamond embroidery machine is so similar to the Pfaff Creative Vision embroidery machine which was out over 5 years before the Viking Diamond. My second serger was an Elna Pro5DC (bought in 1992). It was so much easier to thread than the Singer serger I first bought. I taught serging at a Viking dealer and am familar with all of their current models. Not much changed in threading of the almost 20 year old Elna and the current Vikings. When I first heard of Jet Air Threading that Baby Lock developed, I couldn't believe how easy it was to thread. And I could thread in any order rather than the specific threading sequence other sergers have to do or they will not run right. My local Baby Lock dealer is thinking about adding Bernina machines but she has stated that she would not be selling any Bernina sergers as the Baby Lock sergers are better made. These are her words, not mine. We joke that she has been serging longer than I have while I have been machine embroidering longer than her. I also disagree on new sergers using special industrial needles. As far as I know, Baby Lock, Viking, Bernina, Elna, Singer current models designed for the home sewer all use Universal needles. The Baby Lock Evolve which is a combination serger and coverstitch machine does use special needles for the coverstitch side but NOT for the serger side. Brother is an interesting company. They made 2 lines of sergers and also of sewing/embroidery machines. The first line is of excellent quality and these are the ones carried by Brother dealers. The other line is of poorer quality and the warranty is not honored by Brother dealers. Instead these machines have to be mailed back to the Brother factory at the owner's expense. Yes, these machines cost less than the other line but most of the time are not worth the cost of repairing. I would be very cautious about getting any Brother machine from places other than a true Brother dealer. I noticed that Janome seems to be doing the same thing at least for sewing machines. My local Hancocks has some Janome models that the local Janome dealer refuses to carry. People have been underestimating what sergers can do for decades. For example, I serged in zippers, serged quilts and made an heirloom lace blouse all on my Singer serger that I had from 1990 to 1992. I didn't have any special feet for it. I have old serger books showing techniques that people are just 'discovering' now. These books are still as valid now as they were 20 years ago. What has changed is the model numbers. I bought my Singer serger in 1990 from JoAnn Fabrics who offered no support or classes. I experimented with that serger and found help at my local sewing guild. When I bought my Elna Pro5DC in 1992 I bought it from a dealer in another town. I still took all the classes and lessons they had. I learned so much quickly that way. With the Vikings and Bernina sergers I had to wing it with the manual but that was OK because what I learned with one serger pretty much applied to the others. When I bought the Baby Lock Imagine Wave, I again took lessons and free serger club that came with the purchase. Sometimes I learned nothing (but got a free pattern). Other times I was in seventh heaven at finding something else a serger could do. I don't buy wired ribbon anymore. I serge my own and this will match the rest of the decor. If you haven't noticed, I LOVE my sergers! LOL

tomrsey (not verified)

Well, I have switched again.  I did find a Bernina dealer nearby, and went with that rather than the Brother.  It is more expensive, but hopefully worth it in th elong run.  Lessons are provided.   Here we go........

tomrsey (not verified)

S. Swarinski, Thanks for all your input.  I looked for a source for the Baby Lock, but there was none near enough to be convenient for the follow up lessons.        Appreciate the time you took to help out.

 

Thanks to all who offered their thoughts.   I think I followed a bit of advise from everyone that responded.  

sally orgren

I have taken several workshops with "sewing-with-handwovens-guru" Daryl Lancaster over the years, and one of the things that stayed with me was her advice about the use of sergers with handwovens. I have no doubt she owns one and knows how to use it. But her main point was if you are spending all this time to make a custom garment with your handwoven cloth (and charging appropriately), why would you then apply a cheap commercial (serged) finish?

She also warned that many handwovens may need a wider-than-average seam allowance. (Don't want it to unravel to the seam.) So you need to keep that in mind when planning garments and using a serger.

Another piece of advice she gives is to take your handwovens to the store and test the machine you intend to buy on the weight of handwoven fabric you will be sewing frequently. Having taken her workshops with other students who owned expensive machines (different models and makers), I got to see first-hand the pitfalls of some of these models.

I understand the desire to knock out garments at the lowest cost and looking for ways to do that efficiently. I would highly recommend taking one of her workshops if you get a chance. The information transcends any particular project. I use much of what I learned for projects that involve sewing items with many layers like slippers, satchels, and backpacks. And I use the knowledge I gained to sew them in ways that are engineered beyond the given pattern, so they won't fall apart after a few uses.

If you are entering a garment into a juried competition, again I would urge caution using the serger in any obvious location. (Especially since Daryl or one of her students might be the juror!)

Sally

FYI, I'm just a fellow weaver. I don't jury shows and I don't receive any financial compensation for recommending a Daryl class ;-)

kerstinfroberg

this is just an anecdote: once I contacted a coop gallery (to perhaps participate). I was told that a serger was a *must*, as it made the pieces look "professional".

(I do not quite agree, myself - just so you know)

Michael White

For hundreds of years people did very fine tailoring out of handwoven cloth with out the aid of machines. Cheryl uses her sewing machine, but still does a lot of hand finishing.

Kerstin, Sally just my thoughts on the subject.

Michael

tien (not verified)

I agree with Daryl: I prefer to use other edge finishes than serging.  It does take longer, but it looks nicer and more professional.  I figure if I'm going to put that much time into a garment, I'd like to make it couture quality inside and out.  But it really depends on what you want to do and how long you put into it.  My garments take months to years to create; given that time investment, couture finishes make sense.  If I were doing a quick project (under 2 weeks), I might be more tempted to use a serger.

Thank you, S Sarwinski, for the wonderful and incredibly informative posts on sergers.  I've saved them for later, I think they'll be handy if and when I decide I need a serger.

CraftinSusan

About 15 years ago I was asked to donate a sewn item for an auction benefiting a summer camp for children with cancer. I made a baby dress and used a serger to construct most of it. Another woman donated a couple of baby dresses she sewed but she didn't use a serger to finish the seams. The dress I made went for almost $30. The dresses she made made went for $2 each. People do check to see how the garments were constructed. Handmade vs homemade

PitkinSuzy

I have an older Baby Lock serger that is still working just great, but it IS the type that is very difficult to thread. I don't use it really often because I use it only to finish the raw edges and cut off warp when I weave 8/2 cotton dish towels. The dish towels end up being very, very durable and some of mine have been in use in my kitchen since 1987 when I first began weaving. I think the serging before hemming with my regular sewing machine really helps keep those hems in place through all the years of constant washing and drying. I think that using 8/2 cotton and doing the plain weave, it would be pretty hard to finish those raw edges without a serger. I am considering buying a Baby Lock Evolution, although I am not sure why I would need 8 threads...I live FAR from any dealers and going to classes isn't going to be a possibility for me.

Barbara Keyser (not verified)

This is a really interesting conversation - here is my 2 cents.  I have sewn by hand & machine for 40+ years - using Singer & now Bernina.  Old singers are the best, but don't have the fancy stiches we all want.  I had wanted a Serger for a long time, but just got around to it recently.  I picked up an old Singer serger on Ebay for <$200 and it works great ! I found a local sewing shop that offered $30 class on beginning serger - the threading is not as hard as people make out & the instructor made up do that part over & over.  I learned why the tension matters & how to trouble shoot issues as I was using an old machine.  I love using it now & DON'T FORGET - you can tie on new thread to change color without undoing whole thing on most models.  Good Luck !!!!!!!!!!

Susanstitches (not verified)

I've got a serger (we call them overlockers) and mine is about 10 years old now.  It doesn't get used very often but when it does it is reliable because I make sure it is cleaned after each use. Mine is fairly basic but it does have differential feed on it which is important when sewing woven or knitted fabrics.

I used to be a Toyota sewing and knitting machine demonstrator and lack of care by the owner between use kills a machine more than anything else.

Tomas Tom

I am a newbie to the serger ,The advanced serger including the Brother 1034D serger help me finish the fabric effciently.And it has some fancy stitches that allow me to do various stitches.In additional,the prize is reasonable ,about 200$.It take me some time to be famaliar with the machine ,I can control the advice easily.But the tension adjustment still trouble me  a little.I think I will resee the instructional vedio for solving the problem.

SallyE (not verified)

I know this is an old thread, but someone mentioned changing thread colors on a serger.  

The easiest way is to cut the threads at the spools, and then tie the new color spools on and pull each through.   The only thread that won't pull through is the one that goes through the needle, so when the knot gets to the needle eye, cut it and rethread the needle.    Presto, you are done!

 

sally orgren

Okay... I have to make a correction about Daryl's use of sergers. She brought in some recently completed garments to our guild meeting and lo and behold, yes, the seams are serged. (Okay, I had to give her a bit of a hard time about that since she is the guru of handsewing and sewing with handwovens. ;-) 

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on