I'd like to know which one, and what you like and don't like about it.  Is it easy to thread, do you need a tool?

It's time for me to get one, and I"m not sure which one to get.

Thanks, Jerri in NJ

Comments

yarnfloozie (not verified)

 I have the LeClerc handshuttle and an AVL fly shuttle. The LeClerc threading is easy--one just pretty much drops the thread in. I need a crochet hook for the AVL.

tien (not verified)

I've owned five kinds of end-delivery (end-feed) shuttles: Leclerc, Bluster Bay (mini and full size), Schacht, and AVL.  My two preferred shuttles are the Schacht and the Bluster Bay shuttles.  The AVL feels too heavy for me, but I have a narrow loom; it might be better for people who have wider looms, as a heavy shuttle travels through a wide warp better than a light one.  The Leclerc works, but feels a little clumsy to me.

The Bluster Bay shuttles feel by FAR the nicest in the hand.  My only reservation about them is the way they are threaded: they use hooks, so getting the yarn in is pretty fussy (to me anyway).  They would not be my first choice if changing colors (and hence pirns) frequently.  The upside is that you do not need any special tools to use them, and it's easy to get repeatable tension - just thread the yarn the same way through the hooks and you'll get the right tension.  The downside is that the tension is not as adjustable as the disc-style tension you get in the other shuttles.  If you are weaving with very fine yarn, this may be an issue.

The Schacht and all other end-delivery shuttles that I'm aware of use a pair of discs to tension the yarn.  This is adjusted with a small Allen wrench; DO NOT LOSE THE WRENCH.  (Ask me how I know!)  The good news is that you only need to adjust when you are changing the diameter of the yarn, and that it is very quick and easy to snap in a new pirn and lay in the yarn.  The Schacht shuttles are my choice when I am changing colors frequently or using a yarn that is likely to foul up on the hooks (springy metallic yarn, or boucle, for example).

Between the Bluster Bay regular size and the Bluster Bay mini, it depends mostly on the size of your shed.  I have an AVL Workshop Dobby Loom, which is a small loom with a small shed.  The mini goes through the shed more easily than the full-size shuttle, so I prefer to work with it.  But if you have a loom with a bigger shed, the regular size should be just fine.

I would consider the Schacht the most versatile of the shuttles, but if you don't weave with exotic yarns or with lots of color changes, the Bluster Bay are nicer than the Schacht.

Hope that helps,

Tien

Jerri S

thanks for the feedback.!  Leaning toward the Bluster Bay Mini, but I will be asking friends who have EFS if I can look, hold, thread. I know the ultimate test is weaving with it. tho. Right now, I'm mostly using my Baby Wolf loom, so thinking BB mini.

I actually have a flying shuttle beater for my Leclerc, might be time to actually put it on the loom and try it out.

Frances G. (not verified)

I have found the tension on the Schacht end-feed shuttle very difficult to adjust - so i don't adjust it. Lucky that I use mostly 2/10 cotton. I've invested so much money in  two of them, plus the pirns, that I stick with them, but were I starting over, I would take a look at the Bluster Bay system.

Jerri S

Ahhh, looks like the BB is the choice in my small sampling so far :) Have a friend who is offering to let me borrow a full size BB to try it out...Thanks

BlueShadow1 (not verified)

 I have and like the Schacht EFS...and I have lost the little allen wrench - luckily, they do have them at my hardware store (thank goodness!) I bought three just in case (smile!)

ruthmacgregor (not verified)

Just out of curiosity, what size allen wrench does the Schacht EFS need?

Ruth (who desperately needs to tidy the shuttle-storage area of this room, because things disappear there and never come to light again)

Karen (not verified)

I much prefer the Schacht.  I had a Bluster Bay, and I did not like the hooks - couldn't remember from pirn to pirn how many hooks I used for the correct tension.  With the Schacht I set the tension once for a many pirn project.  I also like that is lower in height, so fits in a smaller shedd.  The Bluster Bays are much prettier, though.

 

sally orgren

No one has weighed in on the AVL, which as Jerri knows, is my EF shuttle of choice. But, I am quick to note I prefer what I think is the older AVL model, which has the embedded Honex tension box, and does NOT require a crochet hook to thread. It drives me nuts if I have to go dig up a tool to use a tool, especially for something I might do fairly frequently, like reload a shuttle.

With the older AVL model, you just lay the thread between the two "paddles" and along the guide-slot. (Way easier than threading a sewing machine!) The is no need to have a small crochet hook on hand to thread the yarn through coils or pull it out through a loop in the side of the shuttle.

Someone told me these shuttles were designed so you could interchange tension boxes for different yarns, but I have not been able to confirm that, and it doesn't make sense to me, I am not sure why one would need to do that? I'd rather buy a second shuttle if I need to use two different weights—which is what I did.

The AVL comes with an allen wrench too, to tighten the tension between the two paddles. I don't have a problem with this "added tool" as I only adjust tension rarely. I keep one shuttle for "fine" threads, and one for "thick" threads. 

When looking for an EFS, I was concerned about 1) ease of threading 2) the height of the shuttle, 3) the nose of the shuttle, (how blunt or pointed and if too blunt, would that lead to skips in a narrow shed?) and  4) the feel of it in my hand (not too heavy).

I just finished two projects this month using my EFS, one was 5/2 cotton weft thrown at 45", the other was 12/2 linen weft thrown at 20" wide. Wider is definitely the best use of an EFS. My current warp is 9" and without thinking I wound the EFS pirn. Such a narrow warp doesn't really get the full benefit, because the shuttle itself is longer than the warp. You can't have too much extra weft left hanging after the shuttle throw, or you defeat the purpose of the drag on the weft when you go to make your next throw!

The finest I have used in them so far is 20/2 pearl cotton, to excellent results. The thickest is Henry's Attic Monte Cristo II. (also a slightly-nubby yarn.)

The other benefit is a pirn holds a LOT of weft. For the 28" long linen towels I just wove, one pirn held the weft for more than 1 towel, and the sett/ppi was something in the range of 24-38. I usually keep a dozen + pirns available. 

Su Butler

I much prefer the Crossley shuttle, marketed by AVL, becuase of its ease of threading, adjustment and the heavy weight of the shuttle itself.  Remember the law of intertia....a body in motion stays in motion......with a heavier shuttle, a quick flick of the wrist sends it all the way across the web with very little effort.....a lighter shuttle has to be thrown harder, imho, and often strays off the path due to its lighter weight. 

The Crossley shuttle is very easy to adjust to almost any size yarn - I weave with yarns as heavy as rayone chenille or 10/2  and as fine as 220/2 silk....all can be accommodated in my shuttles.  I like the Honex tensioning dev ice far more than trying to fine the perfect tension by directing the yarn through various pathways to create tension.

Unfortunately, Crossley is now out of business and the perfect shuttles are no longer being manufactured.  I am always on the lookout for these shuttles, so if you have one you don't wish to use and wish to sell it at a reasonsable price, please contact me!

Su :-)

JoAnnaWeaves (not verified)

I would like to point out one thing that I learned only after purchasing a Bluster Bay Mini. If you look on the Bluster Bay website they make each shuttle in several types of wood. The difference being in weight and appearance.

I purchased mine from Halcyon Yarn and did not get to choose what wood it was made out of. They just send you one. That's fine if you're not really concerned about the weight. But I believe it's the same price from the Bluster Bay site AND you can choose which wood you want. They have a list on the website of approximately how heavy the different woods are. I have a walnut one (which I believe is in the mid range weight) and I would really prefer something a bit heavier. I'm used to my LeClerc boat shuttles which are the same length but are made out of maple or cherry (I believe) and are a bit heavier.

I also have had problems with the yarn coming out of the tension hooks. That was on narrower warps though so perhaps if I was weaving something wide it would not be an issue...It could also be the yarns I use. (I often use rayon/viscose, tencel, silk, etc. Slippery yarns)

Also, the nose of the shuttle is a bit blunt. If you're catching ends, this could be an issue. I tend to use the nose of the shuttle to flip the end up onto the shuttle.

I have not tried other EFSs so I don't really have much to compare it with.
I hope this information was helpful. :)

JoAnna

Jerri S

Yes, yes,all very helpful! Thank you all for taking time to answer. It really sound like it would be worth borrowing and trying as many different ones as I can before I commit.

Except the Crossley, because if I fall in love with that one, the search for it will have me crying and begging ;) 

Just out of curiosity, is there a way to tell the Crossley/AVL from a non-Crossley when used shuttles come available?

 

Leslie M (not verified)

I use the Schacht EFS for fine smooth threads and BB for heavier textured threads.  As several have said , a heavier shuttle would work better on a wide warp, but with some carpal tunnel problems the lighter Schacht works better for me.  Also I don't seem to get tired as fast.  On the BB the kind of wood definately makes a difference in weight (I have a red oak closed bottom, very heavy for me). They do have an open bottom shuttle which I like.  The hooks seem to handle some texture better (not loops though).

  As far as the size goes, I've always gone for the large  (8"pirn) size just because I figured then I don't have to wind as many pirns as often.

  Hope this helps!

  Leslie

Su Butler

I **think** AVL still has a stock of Crossley shuttles...the price has increased to what I consider ridiculous, but then it is a seller's market......when I bought mine they were around $50.00 each....I think the price now runs nearer $150.00 each....you can explore the AVL website and see for yourself....I do not know if anyone at AVL will answer the question you posed about knowing the difference......my experiences with getting information from them have very unsatisfactory.

Su

sally orgren

Okay, I am not sure if I have an AVL Crossley or not, so thought to take a photo of my fave and not-so-fave AVL EFS side-by-side. (Do I have one?)

I think it would be GREAT if others could post similar photos of their Schacht , Buster Bay, and LeClerc, (any others?) so we can all compare. 

BTW, when I dug the not-so-fave one out of my loom bench, I was reminded of what bugged me about it! I had to use a fairly fine crochet hook twice — first to bring the thread between the 2 sets of paddles (under that bar), and then I had to poke it in the hole in the side of the shuttle, to grab the thread at 90 degrees and pull it out. So I had to try and poke the weft down into the hole from the top (where you can see the edge of the white plastic tube) while trying to grab it from the side with the hook. Arghhhhhh!

Scroll down for top, side, and bottom views.

 

 

 

laurafry

The not-so-fav shuttle is a god-send for thick or heavily textured yarns.  I don't like using that style very much either, but if I'm using, for instance, rayon chenille, it's a lot less frustrating to use that shuttle than to keep having the weft pop out of the shuttle.  :}  So there are times....

Cheers,

Laura

sally orgren

Laura,

Well, my "not-so-fave" hasn't left the studio completely, and I have yet to put it up for sale...it's just residing in my "not-so-handy" place for now. (And it was a gift from the hubby—thankfully, he isn't on Weavolution!)

BTW, I *have* used the Honex successfully for Walmart-purchased Caron knitting yarn (800 ypp), Henry's Attic Monte Cristo (1,100 ypp, slightly slubby), and a variety of Webs rayon chenille (1,300 ypp was the biggest grist).

I was really surprised that they all went through the device with no problems! I was thinking the slightly slubby Monte Cristo would give it "burps," and I was worried that the chenille might get stripped. But no worries. I have never had a problem with any of the threads "popping" out of the Honex tension device. (Okay. Should I have worries now?  ; - )

As I have three AVL EFSs total, I keep one of the Honex ones tuned for these thicker yarns (blanket projects), and the other for 10/2 to 20/2 (predominately my yarn size of choice). I haven't tried any finer than that yet, I just assumed of course—they would work well with the fine stuff! However, I was unsure of the thicker stuff...and of course, if one gets much thicker than 800 ypp, it might be time for a rag or ski shuttle instead of an EFS!

P.S. To his credit, my hubby is an *excellent* pirn-winder!

 

Su Butler

Just FYI - Crossely used several different tensioning mechanisms in their shuttles.  I know of three in particular, (there may be more), but do not know which ones, other than the Honex, were used on the shuttles sold under the AVL brand name. 

I prefer the Honex mechanism.....Laura, I have never had rayon chenille pop out of it!  The tensioning can be fine tuned so well on that particular mechansim that a few quarter turns and the chenille stays put.  The tensioning device must be positioned for a yarn the size of the CORE yarn, not for fatter yarns when weaving with novelty yarns. 

Su

laurafry

Hi Su,

Guess I just never got the shuttle set right.  :)  I'm not exactly a patient person!  :^) 

Fortunately I rarely weave with rayon chenille in my fly shuttles now.  My next warp will be rayon chenille, but only narrow for scarves so it will be back to my trusty Leclerc boat shuttles - my preference when hand throwing.  :)

Cheers,

Laura

sally orgren

Okay! I just saw photos of the other brands of EFS, and now I have QUESTIONS!

First, I was impressed by the Schacht. I don't know how they compare in price (to the AVL with the Honex), but they look like they are just as easy to thread, have a lower profile, pointier tip, less metal and wood = lighter weight. (Everything Leslie M posted!)

Second, on the Buster Bay mini, I was wondering — how do you thread through the hook system?

1) Are the hooks connected all the way around so you have to aim the weft through the center of each hook, or is there an opening along the bottom of each hook that you can slip the weft up into? 

2) Do you thread the first hook directly from the tip of the pirn, and then in what order? in a circle? zig-zag back and forth? 

3) How does the weft thread come out of the shuttle? In the photo I viewed, I couldn't tell, but it didn't look like there was a hole in the side of the shuttle for the weft to emerge. Does it just feed off the top of the shuttle after emerging from one of hooks?

Now it makes sense with the BB you can tie on a new weft to an old, and not have to rethread all those hooks, even if a larger grist yarn. If there is no hole in the side of the BB shuttle for the weft to emerge, then that removes the size-limit for the grist that the Schacht and the AVL may impose with their tensioning systems.

I think my biggest surprise as a newbie weaver was discovering that I needed more than one kind of shuttle, and more than 5 plastic LeClerc bobbins! ; - )

 

knittervention (not verified)

I've got three types of EFS - Schacht, Bluster Bay and Crossley.  The Bluster Bay EFS are by far the prettiest - the woods they use are simply gorgeous.  That said, I much prefer the way the yarn feeds off of the Schacht.  I also like that the pirn can be "lifted" out of the shuttle without cutting the thread to the project (not possible with BB).  Lastly, I always forget which hooks I wound around, so when changing pirns with the BB I never seem to quite get the tension the same pirn to pirn. 

As for the Crossleys, I lucked into two brand new ones a year ago from another weaver's stash, and have yet to use them.  They seem a bit heavy to me, and large for my 24" loom.  After reading through this discussion though, I think I'll drag 'em out and give them a try!

Heather

Bonnie Datta (not verified)

I've never owned an EFS, but I'm wondering whether pulling the yarn off the end of the pirn -- thus changing the twist in the yarn -- is a problem?

Sara von Tresckow

If the pirn is wound correctly, there is no difference in the finished fabric. While learning to wind pirns, jerky unloading is the biggest problem.

I've never gotten any EFS as I have many looms and many shuttles - all side delivery - and each type of shuttle requires its pirn or quill - so for simple economics I keep it that way. With a good EFS costing 1.5 to 2 times the price of a well made side delivery shuttle, it is worth considering. My favorite shuttles are the weighted damask shuttles from Folke Samuelsson in Sweden - I use them on the drawloom and have also used them on class work using theTC-1 - wonderful in both cases and every other loom type in between.

Learning two ways to wind filler packages, multiple winding devices, etc. keep my equipment park consistent with one type of shuttle.  

laurafry

If the yarn is wound onto the pirn consistently, it winds off consistently.  The problem comes when the yarn is wound off the tube in different directions with some yarn packages having had more twist applied, some having twist subtracted.

Cheers,

Laura

Leslie M (not verified)

The hooks on the BB are "L" hooks so it's easy to just slip the weft under the hook.  Tension on the yarn keeps it in place.  Coming from the pirn there is a "circle" that the weft goes through as a guide and then through the L hooks and there is an opening on the side for the weft to come out.  I don't have any trouble threading them, but another friend (Jenny B) does because she says she doesn't have finger nails!  I do like them for heavier (8/2 and heavier) and for textured yarns.  Not so much for finer yarns.  And, of course, as several have said they are pretty.  Sometimes it's just nice to use a tool that is pretty (as long as it works well and does the job!)

suzyhok (not verified)

I love my two EFSes.  I am not sure what kind they are as I bought them about 25 years ago and I don't have them with me here at the lake but when I get back to Savannah in the Fall I'll post a photo and maybe someone can help me identify them.

In order to avoid the problem of threading (admittedly much harder on the EFS with the tensioning and paddles than the one without.) Both shuttles look like Sally's darker one. I leave a leader (about 10" of yarn) that is threaded from the end of the pirn I'm using so that the next pirn will be easier to start.  All you have to do is tie the leader of the old pirn yarn to the beginning of the new pirn's yarn.  If I lose the end... and have to thread... I use my reed & heddle threading hook.

Hope this helps...

Suzy

 

sally orgren

Suzy,

Using a leader on the pirn...That's so simple it's brilliant!

(I am going around for the rest of the day with a big "duh!" post-it note on my forehead.)

 

suzyhok (not verified)

Hi Sally...

Glad to be some help!  As a spinner the idea was a natural.  I don't like threading through the orifice on the spinning wheel either!

:-) Suzy

Submitted by Jerri S on