I'm curious about which wood is best for a loom....maple vs. cherry vs. walnut.  I have my aesthetic preferences (walnut), but I wonder if there are other structural considerations I should keep in mind.  Any thoughts? I'm lookng at various used looms, and thought I should investigate a bit before getting my heart set.

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

 1. Walnut gets  brittle with age - it will eventually splinter, the reason that Brittany walnut knitting needles are no longer made

2. Cherry will also get brittle, but more slowly

3. Maple is strongest and least expensive and has the best physical properties for making a smooth strong functional loom.

 

EvaHall

 My first loom was homemade out of fir and more than 100 years old.  It was steady and simple and just perfect for weaving rag rugs. 

claudia (not verified)

It looks very sturdy and I like that it was put together with wedges like the Glimakra looms are now.  Do you still have and use this loom? 

Claudia

sequel (not verified)

I'd go with the rock maple... have you ever tried to drill a hole in an old Hammett?

As far as walnut goes, I have an old Herald loom that is stained dark walnut, and we call it the Black Beast.  If only the previous owners had ordered the plain ash finish!

 

 

Rodrigo (not verified)

Thanks for your input....I didn't know about the splitting issues with cherry and walnut. 

Eva, what a great, solid-looking loom.  How did you come across it? It looks like it would have stories to tell.

Joanne Hall

Yes, it would be nice to hear more about it.  I especially like the unique curved bench which is built into the loom frame.

Joanne

EvaHall

 No Claudia, I sold my old loom when I found a good deal with a Glimåkra ideal and wanted 8 shafts and CM in stead of 4 shafts without both CM and CB. The old one was fine for a beginner. I bought it with 20 meters of warp for rag rugs, and even though rag rugs was not what I had in mind for my weaving I started and found almost endles possibilities. So for some years I made rugs and rugs. I made 2 or 3 rugs with one dressing of the loom, and then I made a new one for the next. That way I always had my head full of new plans for the next rugs.  

EvaHall

A colleague of mine had this old loom in her home for 15 years. It was made by her great grandfather and I am sure that she hadintentions to use it. She told me that some friends had dressed it for her while she cooked dinner for them and after that she wove 15 cms and never more. She decided that cutting rags for rugs was not her thing. Later I have come to think that her friends might have given her the wrong kind of help when they dressed the loom for her without involving her in the process.

The local museum was interested in having the loom, but Liv, my colleague, wanted it to be used, so when she was moving to a new home, and had realised that her grown up daughters were not interested in weaving,  she wanted it to come to nice people who would weave on it. In short - she sold it to me. 

When I got my Glimåkra ideal I announced the old loom for sale, and for days there was no response. My husband and I began thinking of how we could keep the old loom, because we both found it a nice thing to just have in a room.  The room would have been totally crammed with two big looms in it ( apart from the piano, the guest bed, the large computer table, the music collection and of course my weaving stash). 

In the end one person showed interest and I could tell Liv that her old loom had come to a nice woman who would start weaving rag rugs. That woman lives in an old house, built in the tradition of northern Norway. She and her husband har just finished the renovation of that house, and the loom would fit perfectly into its new surroundings.

Liv was very satisfied with this solution.

 

Michael White

Any close grain wood like, walnut, maple, cherry and most dense soft woods (fir, yellow pine  etc) will make a great loom. ALL WOODS with out the proper care will dry out and split. A friend of mine is the buyer of antique furniture for the State Dept, and in their collection are pieces in mahogany, walnut, cherry, etc that are as beautiful and functional as the day they were made 3-400 years ago.  A well cared for (cleaned, oiled, not exposed to the elements) loom of cabinet grade wood, should last several lifetimes. 

Michael,

Joanne Hall

Hi Rodrigo,

These messages have given you some information about types of wood.  In your search for a used loom, you may well learn that other features may be more important, such as workmanship, design for function, loom size and type.  If you continue your search and your study, the choice of wood will probably go further down your list of preferences. 

I had a friend some time ago who purchased a loom because it was walnut.  Nothing else mattered.  Every time she pressed on a treadle, she had to push at least one shaft down before she could throw the shuttle.  But it did not matter to her that the loom did not work.  It was made of WALNUT!!!!! and she was in love with it.

Joanne

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on