My question is very specific, but since there are so many knowledgeable people on this website, maybe someone will know the answer; I am currently studying Crackle weave, and my understanding is that it is a quite stable structure since the maximum float is 3 threads. But in Carol Strickler's "8 Shaft Patterns" book, on P. 135, example # 491, when I do the drawdown, I come up with some floats as long as 9 threads. Additionally, she says this draft can be woven without tabby shots between the pattern shots---which seems to me like it would make the structure even more unstable. Am I making an error in my drawdown, or does the "max of 3 thread floats" apply only to a 4-shaft Crackle (rather than 8 shafts)---or am I simply misunderstanding, and Crackle in fact does have longer floats? Thanks so much!

Deborah

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

 Try doing the draft over. Looking at the book there should not be any float longer than 3 threads if tied and treadled as written.

Su Butler

HI Deborah......are you using the tie up intended for the pattern you want?  There is a second tie up on the page which should be used for pattern #491.  If you use that tie-up you will end up with a 3 thread float in the weft and a 5 thread warp float.   Crackle is composed of 4 end blocks of 3 end point twill with incidental threads between blocks to keep the twill order of the threading intact. (each block contains one three end twill and one incidental thread).   Like any twill, when the threading and/or treadling order is changed to a point configuration, the floats become longer.  The transitional thread, often called an "accidental" thread, that comes between the twill blocks is critical to maintaining float length and twill weave structure.  There would be no need to use a tabby with this particular pattern.  If you want to weave tabby, you would tie up shafts 1-3-5-7 and 2-4-6-8.  You *can* weave this pattern with a tabby, but if you do, you would probably want to use a very, very thin yarn for the tabby to preserve the crackle patterning.  If you do weave with a tabby, you will not have a float longer than 3 thraeds in either direction.

Have fun - Crackle is fun to weave and creates patterning unique to itself.....

Su :-)

Deborah Heyman (not verified)

Hi Sara and Su

Thank you so much for your responses and for taking the time to look at the book. But I still can't figure out what I am doing wrong. I am using the second tie-up on P. 135, indicating it is for pattern # 491, and I gave it another try on my drawdown. I'm not sure I can explain this clearly without a diagram, but here goes;

If I were to treadle the draft as written, I would first use treadle # 8, which is harnesses 2,3, 7, and 8

The threading (reading from right to left) is;

                                                     6 7 8 7 6  5 6 7 6 5  4 5 6 5 4  3 4 5 4 3  2 3 4 3 2 1 2 3 2 1

                                                        X  X X           X                            X           X X X     X X    X X X     

I have put an X below each raised warp thread. See how there is a long space along the area of the 4, 5, 6 harnesses?---won't that cause a long weft float?  

Su Butler

HI Deborah......so you know you are not going crazy, one side of the cloth as drafted in the book does indeed have a 9 thread float.  It is my opinion that the tie up is written incorrectly for that draft.  Usually in crackle, because it is made up of 4 thread units of a 3 thread point twill and an incidental thread, the tie up is usually written as a 2/1/1/1/1/2.  For this weave as printed in the book it is written as a 2/3/2/1 tie up.  Because there are three threads in a row that rise, the weft is allowed to float over an entire unit, including it's incidental thread, and that is what is causing your 9 thread float. 

Below are two drafts....the first one is the draft from the book, showing both the front and back of the cloth.

SB crackle incorrect

Next is the same draft, but this time with the tie up written correctly for crackle:

SB crackle proper tie up

In the second draft there is not float longer than 3 threads, as is the rule in crackle weaving. 

Hope that helps....

Su :-)

 

 

 

Deborah Heyman (not verified)

Hi Su

Thank you SOOO much! (glad to know I wasn't imagining it.). I spent some time last night looking through the Crackle drafts at handweaving.net to try to get a better understanding of the weave structure. I noticed that the 8-shaft drafts that had shorter floats had longer twill runs-----and one draft that had a very short twill run had longer floats. So I felt I was on to something--and your explanation also makes sense to me. Thank you also for taking the time to put the draft in your response---wonderful for clarifying! (Its so hard to tell by the photos of the cloth in the book on that particular draft).

Deborah

Su Butler

HI Deborah.....you are quite welcome....glad it helped.  Just as a BTW - I believe the cloth in the book has a 9 htread float, but it is hard to see without magnification......depending on the size of the yarns used to weave it, a 9 thread float could be acceptable....but if weaving with a yarn that requires a sett of even 24 epi, a 9 thread float is just toooooo long!   At 54 epi, a 9 thread float would be only 1/6", so it could work. 

Su :-)

Deborah Heyman (not verified)

I think I am going to use an epi of 18, so I agree. I am going to use your tie-up. In fact, I even like the resulting look of yours better----contrasting tabby areas next to the patterned areas. Your explanation of the tie up (...."because there are 3 threads in a row that rise, the weft is allowed to float over an entire unit") pushed me one step further along in understanding the mathematical relationships between tie-up, threading, treadling. (I understand it when I actually do it in a drawdown, but not well enough to be able to visualize what a combination of those elements will do, just by looking at a draft.). Your answer enabled me to begin work and I'm ready to start winding off my warp!

Deborah

Su Butler

Hope you'll share a pic with us when the work is done Deborah!  Have fun!

Su

Deborah Heyman (not verified)

Hi Su

Just a follow-up.....

In my sampling I tried it with the original tie-up and then with your tie-up, and very much prefered your tie up---not only because of the shorter floats, but also because the pattern showed up much nicer with your version. I completed the weaving---a tencel throw in purple and gold----and am very happy with the result. I am studying Crackle in my weave-structure study group and brought your note to our meeting yesterday---they too found your input interesting. Thank you again!

Joanne Hall

Hi Deborah,

It would be interesting to hear more about your study of crackle.  Most of the old drafts are four shafts and were woven at a time when four shaft looms were common.  But you are weaving with 8 shafts.  Perhaps you are exploring the possibilities of the weave more than the traditional patterns.  It would be nice to hear your comments on the look of the eight shaft compared to the four shaft weave.

Joanne

 

claudia (not verified)

Hey Deborah,

Have you had a chance to take photos and put it with your projects?

Su Butler

HI Deborah....glad you found the info I provided useful......I'd love to see a pic of your finished weaving!  Also, if you are studying crackle, you might consider joining Complex Weavers and joining the Crackle Study group....some really interesting work going on there! 

Hope to see a pic soon!

 

Su

Deborah Heyman (not verified)

Hi Joanne,

I'm so new to Crackle that I don't really have an answer to your question---and that is exactly one of my questions too!---What are the special qualities that Crackle has to offer that other structures don't have? I think for 4-shaft crackle one of the qualities that Crackle has is that you can get 4 blocks from just 4 shafts (unlike some other block weave structures, such as Summer and Winter, M's and O's). But I chose the 8-shaft Crackle simply because I liked the picture in Carol Strickler's "8-shaft Patterns" book and wanted to try it out (and as it turned out, with modifications to the tie-up, thanks to Su's suggestion). I don't know---does anyone else have comments about what they especially like --or don't like---about Crackle, and what the advantages might be to expanding it to an 8-shaft draft?

Bonnie Datta (not verified)

Hi.  I'm also really interested in crackle and would love to hear what others do on more than 4 shafts.  Myself, I've found that the possibilities on just 4 shafts are so intriguing that I've not been too motivated to explore the structure on more than that.  Instead I have concentrated on the number of "blocks" one can achieve on just 4 shafts, and it turns out to be 24.  With a warp threaded in 2 colors (alternating end-and end) these 24 blocks reduce to 12 that are visually distinguishable.  Here is a baby blanket that uses the 12 blocks. Each block is warped with 2 colors (not all blocks have the same colors), and the piece is woven with 2 pattern wefts (red and navy).  I like the effect -- no stripes or plaid, just color blends scattered here and there.

If anyone wants to explore the 24-block version of crackle I have a monograph on the subject on my web page:

http://brdatta.ca/pubs.php

There is also a monograph there that I wrote documenting many treadling systems for 4-block crackle.

The only crackle weaving I've done on 8 shafts has been a double weave.  By having different pairs of colors in the blocks on shafts 1-4 than I have in the blocks on shafts 5-8 I can get a really mixed up, vibrant look.  I have been dreaming of a computer driven loom for doing this as the treadling gets pretty complicated.

Bonnie.

 

Sara von Tresckow

You'd adore the computer assist. Just finished a 20+ yard warp that would have called for 16 shafts and 24 treadles. I have the 16 shafts, but putting in that many treadles just wasn't in the cards.

Plus, when interrupted by customers wanting knitting yarn and other non-weaving supplies, I just sit back down and press the pedal and haven't lost my place. 

Interesting concept - the piece looks cool.

I'm seriously beginning to wonder if this isn't one of those structures that doesn't  "translate" to gazillions of shafts and blocks well.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on