I am just curious.

Do most of us weave what we do because we want to explore techniques, or because we want to "say something" with our work? Sally


Comments

Lauries (not verified)

I would say I weave what I Ido to explore techniques and to "say something" with my work. I like to make things that are functional. I also weave just because after all this time I still get a thrill when I take something off the loom. I still look at what I wove and think wow I did that.

Mary C (not verified)

Since I've only been weaving for a couple of years I would have to say that exploring techniques is at the top of my reasons right now BUT when I have a request for a piece of my work it is enjoyable to create something for someone in hopes that we both will be satisfied with what comes off of my loom.  So far so good:) 

 

 

jeannine (not verified)

hi Sally ,this is a question  that i had to think about for a while.At first i was a selfthought weaver .just had fun weaving small items on small looms.Then I wanted to discover more and took weavingclasses .We explored a lot of techniques and there one could see that different weavers had a different approach to the same techniques: using different yarns ,different size ,different colours .In tapestry weaving you need good technic skills for good result .but with the image you can perhaps tell something.If I want to weave a practical item then it is important to explore the techniques for the best result;

I  like to learn about acient weaving, beautiful weaving made with so little recources proves the ingeniouity of people;

now  I learned about Saori-weaving or freestyle if you like. it is basicly plaine weave but  you can weave what you want  just led by the inspiration off the moment. at demonstrations the most asked questions is:'what is it going to be'.People do not understand if you say i dont know. I weave most of the time just because i like it . to make something from scratch,the pleasure to create ,to explore my own and inner creativity.

you surely started a good discussion here. there is also another question :"do we want to say something "or "does our weaving says something about us?"

these are only a few reflections on your questions .I am also curious about the reaction of more weavers.

with kind regards

jeannine

claudia (not verified)

I am totally technique driven. I love exploring a new technique in different types of yarn, vary the colors, warp faced, weft-faced.  I prefer to have a product in mind, I'm not much of a sampler but I love watching how the piece develops.

Currently I have a transparency on my rigid heddle loom and I have truly enjoyed exploring different yarns for the inlay to see how they look.  I can't wait to finish and wet finish it to see what looks best with the warp and weft I chose.  I have been trying to put 4-6" between inlay designs and am wondering how that worked out in the completed piece.  I treated this project with a bit less thought and planning.  I have turned the inlay design in every direction possible and used several different sizes of yarn, doubled and single strand. It's been great to explore like this.

In the end, I might have a scarf and I might just have a very long sample.  It will look nice hung from the ceiling of the studio.

Good questions, Sally, thanks.

Claudia

Thumper70 (not verified)

I'm so new to weaving (only a year or so) that I'm probably more interested in technique at the moment - trying to explore all the possibilities and how they fit together. I suspect that in time - after I'm more aware of, and confident with various techniques - I'll shift towards "saying" something with my projects.

neat question to ponder though.

A

bolivian warmi

I love Jeannine's thought-what does our weaving say about us? and I am still pondering it!

I'll get back to you when I have a clear answer.

Laverne

tommye scanlin

I posted information about this exhibit to the site in a different place but want to note it in this thread, too.  I also responded on WeaveTech list about this.

Anne Wilson, Chicago based artist, has an exhibit at Knoxville Museum of Art that takes the question of "technique" vs. "saying something" to a different place.  She has presented the production of weaving as concept and activity in an extremely thought-provoking way.  If you're in the Southeastern United States and can visit the museum to see the exhibit during the next three months, I highly recommend it.

 http://www.knoxart.org/exhibitions/annewilson/index.html

We who will be reading and posting to Weavolution will, as handweavers, for the most part not need to weave.  That puts the reasons we choose to weave on a different level... in fact, many different levels.  As one learns the process often technique is at the forefront.  Then with skills in hand, some will want to use the mastered techniques in a way to express ideas, images, concepts that put the process to work in ways other than use of the method.  I think asking the questions why and for what reasons? are quite important.  And I think each one of us will find that whenever we consider that question for ourselves, the answers will change over time and situation.  And that's OK!

Tommye Scanlin

 

Mary C (not verified)

Well put  Tommye!

I have a book "sumi-e A Meditation In Ink" by Paul Siudzinski and he talks about art and meditation, pretty interesting:)   He suggests a simple breathing meditation before beginning and letting the inner self take over.

Enjoy your weaving,

jeannine (not verified)

i am not able to go and visit this exhibit but I found all the online info very good .I love the pictures  and read all the weavers words .I could find a lot of my own vision there. thank you for the link.

You are quite right "the answers will change over time and situation."

sally orgren

 Okay, I *really* like this comment by Jeannine:

"Do we want to say something, or does our weaving say something about us?"

I think in the process of acquiring the technical skills to weaving proficiency, our projects tend to say a lot about us. But when you get to that point where you have a pretty full tool belt, the "Ah Ha" moments start to kick in.

willow weaves (not verified)

I think- I weave to WEAVE.  It says something about ME- My need for a Zen state which is supported by the order of warp and weft, and the colors/fibers/textures that make my mind and spirit SING. 

After a few decades of weaving whatever I could weave - with our without standard tools, I have realized that weaving is the ultimate Refuge for me.  But this Refuge isn't a solitary prison, it is an OPENING into my own imagination, creativity, a release from the rules, and a connection to the cosmos.  On the loom, it's not who wants what, in what size or color, it's who I am today.  I am completely self directed when I weave.

The Dine say, Weave in Beauty.  I do. 

Ellen (not verified)

Thank you willow weaver. You have put into words exactly how I feel about weaving!

dteaj (not verified)

Where is the separation really?

I see materials and they speak to me in certain ways. They tell me what techniques to investigate/try. Experimenting with the techniques causes certain of them to speak and inform the materials. And so it goes, when the process is going "right".

Then there's when it isn't going "right" and frustration is the main product. :-) Or when nothing is coming and the work is mundane. (From my perspective, that is. I'm not saying that any of it is that amazing or anything.)

Debbie

willow weaves (not verified)

You know - people talk about process and product orientation.  I guess in some cases, I weave for a product.  of course!  but I don't feel married to it.

Then on the process side, it is stimulating to unlock the puzzle of HOW to do it.  the math that appears in my brain is self sustaining. 

Ultimately tho, it's neither the product or process. It's the action, involvement in creating "something from nothing". the release of the primal woman that keeps me weaving. 

Just Weaving.

willow weaves (not verified)

Ahh. frustration!

to me, just being able to weave is AMAZING.

In all the years I've been weaving,  I have never felt that I am an outstanding Weaver.  But then I'm not terribly worried about how it comes out.  NO that's not true. I want it to be "respectable", by my own standards.    BUT if it has a surprise in the end, well, this fabric must have a different use, how can I use it?  Sew nasty selvedges into a seam, fold it, Bead it, add something, make it work.  If all else fails, throw it in the washer and see how many potholders it makes  hahaha 

Truly, handmade is all an experiment.

But frustration?  This is supposed to be FUN ,Relaxing, an outlet.  If it's not, one has to walk away for a while - or find something else to do that IS fun.  We modern weavers don't have to do it to keep our families clothed and blanketed, so this activity is optional. 

When I teach new weavers, I always tell them, if you're crying and cussing, you need to look into WHY you are forcing yourself down this path.  Is this a competition?  No.  Is this a challenge someone has put on you?  if yes, what is the emotional investment that keeps you at the loom?  If it's a challenge one has put on one's self, then, cussing and crying gets us nowhere.  It's time then - to stop and think. have a cup of tea, find a way around, under or through that obstacle. Troubleshooting successfully puts one back on a track of serenity.  OMMMMM.  :)

Ellen (not verified)

It happens a few times that somebody asks me to weave something for them, or that I decide that I want to weave a particular thing for at particular purpose or person.

But most of the time I have a yarn I fell in love with, and start from there mulling over what would be nice to weave with that.

From then on through all the processes of deciding on techniques to doing the maths to making the warp etc etc till the final wash and dry and steam or sewing or whatever needs doing to finish it, I enjoy every step of the way. I just feel totally absorbed, in harmony.

Oh, I can't explain it, but you probably know what I mean.

willow weaves (not verified)

Oh yeah, Ellen, I do know what ya mean.  if you want a peek at my inner insanity, take a look at the only project I've posted in here, Magic Warp.. it's still in progress.  It all started with two lonely little skeins of white Silky Wool from a clearance bin and an idea...  !

BTW, There is a similar article re the original question thread on Syne Mitchell's site, Weavezine. 

Now THERE is a new thread - do we weave because we are excited by the materials???  The answer MUST be YES.  So many to choose from, and not just from the retail world.

Mary C (not verified)

Today I found myself tying together my "thrums" to use up because I experimented with some or them on the end of my last warp.  (Can't throw any materials out)Now

I can't wait to proceed with my new project and see what I make.  After reading your posts I think there is someone out there who possibly understands my weaving fun:)

 

willow weaves (not verified)

OHHHH!!!!   Thrums are SUCH FUN.  Talk about Free Fiber!!  It's all "Waste" so we don't have to worry about the investment of hard earned dollars.

Mary, post your thrum-derings :)  so we can see what happens!

dteaj (not verified)

To me, frustration isn't necessarily a bad thing and it doesn't mean cussing and crying. It means stretching ones wings, finding challenges, trying things out. In my particular case, it usually means that my idea of what the materials, weave structure or weaving tools can accomplish is not accurate or my skill level is not up to the job. It is a time for learning, perhaps for simplifying before moving forward. OK, maybe there's a cup of tea in there too! There is a balance, of course. Too much frustration and one walks away instead of learning.

Personally, I really care about getting a result I like. Maybe not the result I first intended, but nice by my own standards. This year, that's meant I've done a lot more sampling than weaving for an end result. Hopefully, it will pay off soon. If not, another lesson learned...

tien (not verified)

To me, all craft is a dialogue between the maker and the material.  The maker's skill can shape the conversation, but it must be a dialogue - without understanding and listening to how the material behaves and what it "wants", the maker can easily come up with an impossible vision, leading to frustration.

I wrote an essay about that dialogue, and about "clinging" (to your original vision) as the source of frustration - it's on my website, here: http://www.tienchiu.com/2009/05/clinging/

Here is an excerpt, which seems apropos:

------

When I was traveling through Southeast Asia, I spent ten days at a silent meditation retreat in Thailand, learning about Buddhism through daily lectures while practicing meditation 8+ hours/day, and keeping silence 24 hours a day.  It was very, very difficult, but I came out of it having learned a lot. 

One of the things they taught us is that clinging lies at the core of suffering.  Clinging, or attaching to a specific result, causes pain when the result doesn’t happen.  The degree of pain, of course, is related to the degree of clinging.  The tighter you cling to a desire, the more pain you feel when the desire does not happen.

In crafts, one of the things I learned early on, through much pain, is that while it is important to have a vision, falling in love with a specific vision is a sure formula for frustration.  Because, even for a master, it is nearly impossible to implement in real materials the Grand Vision, exactly as conceived.  The wood turns out to have a knot, you can’t find the right yarn, the clay shrinks in firing.  The closer you cling to what you wanted, the greater the frustration.

This is one of the reasons I approach creation as a wandering journey, which starts with a fairly vague vision/destination, passes through a great deal of “I wonder what happens if?” and “Maybe I’ll try…” terrain, and finally wanders out to an end product, which hopefully satisfies me when I sit back and behold the finished piece.  I do have goals, but I try to make them as broad as possible, and concentrate on the journey, rather than the end result.  So I avoid frustration, because rather than to force a specific result, I work with the medium, flow with it, adapt around flaws and surprise discoveries.  The end result is rarely exactly as I envisioned it, but it generally pleases me, and it satisfies my desire to learn, and to create.  And by flowing around the problem, and changing the goal, I avoid frustration.

------

Tien

Michael White

Not too long ago a mother and daughter contacted Cheryl (my wife) about taking weaving lessons. The mother had a harrisville 22" loom and had taken weaving lessons years ago. They shown up with the loom in pieces. Great, as Cheryl talked to them I worked on putting this loom together. Jump forward. They both now had 22 inch looms to play with, the daughter with a loom from Cheryl and the mother with  her loom now fully assembled. Cheryl had to go out on a LP gas emergency (Sales & Service Manager 22 years). I was showing the daughter how to pick up warp threads to go thought the heddles, when I went to help the mother, she told be she knew how to do it. I watched and saw that she was crossing threads. I said, try it this way, and was told, "I am doing just fine". I was now helping the daughter lay in the weft, the mother was now trying to untangle her warp, which was all crossed in the heddles and reed. They left to go home, the daughter with a weft started and the mother with a mess. The next week they came back, the daughter with a nice twill sampler scarf and the mother with out her loom. I ask the mother now it was going, she told Cheryl & I that she hadn't had time to work on it. They left Cheryl's loom and we have not heard from them since. I hope the daughter was able to clean up her mothers warp and is still weaving, she was really excited about it. We have a guild meeting Sunday, they have been inivited I hope they come. My point is, the mother had a loom for years and I guess the "crying & cussing" of weaving was too much of a challenge for her. Maybe the daughter will come back when she is old enough to drive. 

Chery works full time to have the money to weave. I guess weaving is in her blood. Her great grand father was a silk weaver in England. For a wedding gift (33 years ago) I gave her, her first real loom. A table top loom. Over the years we have added and sold a number of looms www.handweaver.us/My%20Looms.htm and well over a ton of yarn. Last night she was working on picking out linen for weft for overshot cotlin dish towels when she said, "you know it is going to take me over a 150 years to weave all this yarn." She does not design her own drafts, her point is there are so many drafts out there I could never weave all of them. I weave just to say I can, I make parts for looms, right now I have two doz. rag shuttles ready to go out the door to a loom company in Michigan. I think I have ran my mouth long enough. U'll stay warm and I hope you do not loss power in this big winter storm moving across the country.

Michael

  

willow weaves (not verified)

Tien, that was BEAUTIFULLY expressed...!

willow weaves (not verified)

Hi Michael, I THOUGHT that was you!  the looms you make are fabulous!  I want one!!  :) I'm still working on my big ol'  "Odd" Sabina .

The Mom in your story - I have watched many people in classes, turn down the teaching.. Pride?  I don't know or understand...  a lot of cussing and crying happens because we are so tied up in our own internal chaos that we don't access the order and rythm of weaving ( and warping!).  I hope the Mom finds her balance and gets it straightened out.  This could be a case of "learn from your children".   

When I teach, the thing I seem to repeat more than anything else is: "Allow yourself to Be a Beginner".  LET yourself hold a crayon instead of a fine pen. Erase! (unweave) Free yourself from big expectations , just for this one little project.  It is so hard, in this result-driven society, to let ourselves make mistakes, and explore.  We all seem to expect perfection from even the most experimental attempt.   If we can allow ourselves to just relax- let it flow, allow ourselves to be a kindergartner again.. There are benefits to releasing that little child inside who is full of wonder and awe, with no fear of failure.

Michael, I hope the same for you - keep the lights burning, the heat on, and take advantage of having a snow day!! :) if you get it!!

Ellen (not verified)

Thrums! I do that, too.

I had saved some thrums from a beautiful silk shawl. They were just too lovely to throw away. And then I had a finished warp with different setts and just laid them in. I am keeping the piece, thinking that one day I might use it as an effect on something I sew. Or else I'll just keep it for its sheer beauty. Have a look here if you want.

www.weavolution.com/node/6174

Yes I went to have a look at your wonderful yarn yesterday. Yummy!!!

Ellen

Submitted by sally orgren on