I wonder if any one can help me with this weaving draft.  It is from "Eight Shafts A Place to Begin" - I have a long piece of fabric all threaded up and ready to be woven and having started I find that there are skips of 7 ends in the pattern which is just no use.  I am doing version no. 4.107.  I am not good with weaving software so I wonder if anyone has any ideas for a tie up that would give a reasonable pattern with a maximum of 3 skips.  Thanks so much in advance for any help you are able to give.  I am attempting to attach a photo of the draft.

Comments

laurafry

You say floats of seven are too long. Just out of curiosity, how long are they in terms of inchs or millimetres? What yarn are you using? If wool, can it be culled for stability? Epi? Changing the tie up to reduce the length of the floats might dramatically change the look of the weave What about one of the other options since you already have the loom threaded? Cheers Laura

SallyE (not verified)

With that threading, you are never going to get to 3 skips.   If you achieve that with the weft threads, you will have more than 3 in skips in the warp.  Why?   Because you have threaded 8-8-8 in some places and any 1-1-1 in others.

Now, you could maybe come up with a treddling, but it will look like a muddy mess and you won't see any real pattern.   Any tie up that will do what you want will destroy the pattern. 

I don't know how wide your warp is, but if you really can't have more than a float of 3, you need a different threading.   Sorry. . . .

(Actually, that set up has a max float of 11.)

The weaving software isn't that difficult to use and would have prevented this problem for you.   Erica - Maybe we need a class on that??

 

tisserande (not verified)

Thank you Laura and Sally for your replies.  I have also reached the conclusion that it is impossible.  It is 16/2 silk sett at 24 epi with 786 ends !!!  None of the other alternatives would be any better because, as you say, Sally, there are 3 on 1, and 2 on 2 etc - well at least I have learned something.  So, I am now going to unthread it all and rethread with something totally different.  Thanks again for taking the time to answer me, Gill.

sally orgren

the total float length is less than 1/3 of an inch.

So it might be okay. Did you sample first, (including finishing!) which draws the fabric up a bit in warp and width. Silk doesn't shrink, but would be susceptible to take-up when removed from tension. That may reduce the float distance even further when finished. What do you think?

The "rule" isn't "no more than 3 floats" but rather how long is the length of those floats given the fiber and sett?

1/4" an inch is my benchmark, not 3 threads. And it also depends on what the fabric is to be used for. Is the fabric going to be lined or backed for a garment? Will it be for light use, like a scarf? (These were some of the details I think Laura Fry was trying to extract when she asked her initial questions.)

Another thought, did you sample your sett? I can't easily find that size of silk and recommended sett with a quick search, but usually with a twill-based pattern, your sett should be tighter than for plain weave. What happens if you reduce your sett to 26 or 28 epi? Your float length certainly will decrease. Will it change the hand of the fabric, or will the silk be just as drapey as at 24? It's far easier to rethread a reed than the heddles.

Be sure to remember to replace your lease sticks if you removed them before you started weaving. I know you won't get a 1:1 cross because your warp is threaded 1-1-1 in places, but it will help A LOT in keeping track of most of those nearly 800 ends when rethreading.

All is not lost! Good luck, and let us know how you decided to proceed.

laurafry

Yes, Sally, that was the info I was 'fishing' for.  ;)  A scarf needn't be as 'sturdy' as a cloth for clothing, so a 7 thread float might be ok.  Silk is slippery, so increasing the epi/ppi might be a good thing anyway, which will, as pointed out, reduce the length of the floats.

This sort of situation is why more experienced weavers tend to answer questions with 'it depends' and then advise to 'sample'!  But for a newer weaver, re-threading to something else might be a good idea.

A weave structure with as many floats as shown in the draft should probably be set more closely than a 2:2 twill in any event.  Even more so when the yarn is as slippery as silk is being used.

If there is sufficient warp, a small sample including wet finishing will give a great deal of information.  If the warp isn't long enough, then changing the tie-up, density and/or the threading now is probably good strategy....

Sorry I can't be of more help than that.  Good luck with your project.  I'm sure it will be lovely whatever you decide to do.  :)

cheers,

Laura

jj50 (not verified)

I also got an 11 thread weft float. I reduced it to 7 by moving the middle "8" to shaft "1" and the middle "1" to shaft "8". You get a small point rather than a rounded curve, but it still looks nice.

SallyE (not verified)

I know all of this is probably disappointing, but think of what you are learning!  We've all been there!

And do try using some software.   Most of the programs can be downloaded for free.   The only thing you can't do is print a draft, but if you do a "ctrl - Alt - prt sc"  (control - alt - print screen) you can paste it into a word file and print the screen shot.   (This is on a PC)

 

sally orgren

That allows you to highlight just what you want to capture and saves to your desktop. Then you can open and print. And you can paste into Weavo threads, too!

;-)

sally orgren

Consider taking any classes she is offering! You will likely become a better weaver just by osmosis...

tisserande (not verified)

I regularly use this silk so I know it's properties - I am weaving a baby wrap which is why I don't want skips and I have reconciled myself to re-threading with a draft I am familiar with!! I guess the answer is in future to try out a new draft on a smaller piece of weaving first.

With thanks, Gill.

laurafry

Oh I can see why you don't want long floats!  :)  Good idea to re-thread.

cheers,

Laura

Sara von Tresckow

Just FYI - undulating twills do usually contain longer floats than straight or pointed drafts, because there are repeats and odd sequences involved in creating the rounded forms.

Some time ago, I found that it is easier and avoids disappointments if the threading is the straight draw and the treadling/tieup form the undulations. That way, if the floats are unattractive, you still have a nice straight twill threaded and can begin doing a different tieup/treadling without rethreading your loom.

The pattern illustrated here has a very original threading sequence which cannot easily be adapted to any other draft, but the treadling sequence used as threading has more possibilities.

mrdubyah (not verified)

One of the nice things about undulating twills is they don't need to be "squared".  That means you could possibly add tabby picks between the pattern picks to create a stable ground cloth under the floats as you would in an overshot pattern.  The undulations will become elongated, but that might result in an interesting effect.  Maybe you could sample it a bit to see what might work.

tisserande (not verified)

That makes sense to me and I will certainly bear that in mind next time I want to try a "new to me" draft.

tisserande (not verified)

Thanks for your suggeston - that would certainly make the fabric more stable (though it is actually quite stable as the sett is reasonably close) but the main issue is having long floats which little fingers could get caught in!

As this is a commission, and I have many more to do, I have decided to cut my losses and re-thread.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on