Hi Everyone,

This is my first post, and I hope I posted in the right forum!

I'm a very beginner weaver and I have an opportunity to buy my first floor loom.  (I've only ever used a Dorothy 15" and a Woolhouse 16" table looms prior.)

The 3 looms being offered are a 36", 4 shaft/6 treddle LeClerc Nilus or Artisat, both used, but being sold on Craigslist.  The Artisat does not come with a bench or any other accessories.  The Nilus does have a bench, but nothing else.  The 3rd loom is a Harrisville 36", 4 shaft/4 treddle, with a bench, a raddle, and some lease sticks.  That one is being sold through my weaving teacher so I know that all the parts are there and that its fully functional.  All 3 of them are roughly the same price.

My concern about the Harrisville loom is that is only a 4 shaft/4 treddle.  It looks like it was made in the early 80's, and to upgrade it to a 6 treddle would cost $240+, which would be a concern.  How necessary would it be that I would want to convert this loom, now or eventually?

I'm mainly looking to do light weight weaving, maybe the occasional rag rug, so I don't need anything heavy duty, but I would like something I can grow on.  Space is also at a premium, so I would prefer the smaller of any of the looms.

Which would you choose? 

 

 

Comments

Badfaerie (not verified)

I have a HD  36" 4/6 and one of my friends has an artistat. Both are great looms, you can't go wrong with either. The third person in our little group has a HD 22" 4/4.

Only haveing 4 treadles means that you just have to press more than one treadles at once. The only time this gets tricky is when you are doing a double weave or like 3/1 twill, but even then they are close enough to easily press 2 treadles with one foot.

That being said, I think the conversion kit is well worth it as an upgrade when you can because it makes more complicated treadlings easier. I get lost doing overshot with a direct tie up. The conversion also makes it easier to adjust how your harnesses hang, you don't have to do it with the treadle cords.

That being said I would sit down and treadle all of the looms. The HD with the floating shafts has a much different feel than the LeClerc's do. I think the floating shaft/pulley system makes the treadles seem easier/lighter than you typical jack loom, but I know 2 people that can't stand it. So it's subjective and you should get the loom that makes your heart flutter when you sit at it.

Margery (not verified)

First benches are expensive new - if one comes with the loom - great! If you really like the loom and it does not come with a bench - get the loom - you can use something else to sit on. Just make sure it is the correct height. I suggest either one of the Leclerc's. They are heavier and will handle an occasional heavier weave over the Harrisville.

celtinbirks

I think that you would be sorry eventually if you got the one with only 4 treadles.

Linda Ratliff

Personally, I'd go with the Harrisville (I'll admit to some bias--I have a Harrisville 22/8 and I love it).  For the roughly the same price you get a bench and some other accessories--that'll help balance out the additional cost of more harnesses.  You also know the source, and you know it's in good shape.  Trouble shooting a loom is no joke if you're still new to weaving.  Also, you don't have to buy the extra harnesses right away--the amount of patterns you can do on a four harness is positively astounding.

Still, I would make sure you can have some sort of test on the different looms first.  Most manufacturers will be pretty similar within their own lines, but variations from manufacturer to manufacturer can really make it or break it.  I know when I was shopping for looms, I fell in love with Schacht's Baby Wolf--until I saw it in person and realized that not even the height extender would keep my knees from bumping when I hit the treadles.

 

rosearbor (not verified)

All good comments, so far, but the most important being- try them out if you can!  The Harrisville through your teacher should be no problem, but I would make an effort to test out the others.  I've woven on Nilus in workshops, and one was lovely, the other was a nightmare and we could never figure out why.

I have a HD 22/8, and I love it, but it's lightweight compared to the Leclerc.  No rugs on the HD, but I made my rag rugs on a Leclerc.  So *what* you want to weave should enter into the equation too.  Both HD and Leclerc are still in business and can offer support as well as parts, which is a very good thing!  I've replaced most of the parts on my HD, upgrading the cables and chains, and I love this loom because it is so simple and everything is very accessible.  For me, the lightweight treadling was very important- my back issues made me give up my Schacht, which became too difficult to treadle. Another reason to try them out if you can.

sequel (not verified)

But not the Artisat... the Nilus is heavier and far more stable that the Harrisville.  In addition, you won't have to fool with the shafts falling off of the cables.  On the Harrisville looms, if you overtighten the warp, the shafts will ride on the warp instead of hanging down under their own weight, which allows the cables to become unhooked and the shafts falls.

If you are looking at used LeClerc looms, check to see if they have those little plastic pegs on the castle, between the shafts.  If some have broken off you will need to replace them.  Not hard or pricey, but just so you'll know...

As far as the bench goes, you can make something work from a shower chair, a potty chair conversion or a musician's bench which will fit you.  I've found few benches that are the right height for me.

twoquinns

I have the opportunity to buy a 22/8 Harrisville that for some reason only has 4 harnesses and 6 treadles.  Harrisville tells me I can retrofit it to be an 8 harness, but a friend tells me she looked into that and was told by someone at Harrisville that the treadles would be quite close together and that it's easy to step on the wrong one.  Any thoughts from those of you who own or have owned one?

sally orgren

;-)

Seriously, for some people, the 8 shaft Baby Wolf's treadles are too close, but that is a much beloved loom and weaves very well. I am a size 8 wide and weave stocking footed when on that loom. Can anyone report what the clearance is between treadles on that loom?

Does Harrisville have a return policy if you are not happy with the conversion kit? Do you think you could sell the conversion kit (for what you will have paid) to someone else, if it is not satisfactory and there is no return policy?

Can Harrrisville tell you the distance between treadles, and can you compare that to something you have access to? (On my 24" wide, 4 shaft loom with 6 treadles + brake, the treadles are 1.5-2" apart. Each treadle is 1.5" wide.) This is a very comfortable loom to treadle at my shoe size.

If you can get that information from Harrisville, you could line up some similar sized boards at a matching increment on the floor, run your feet over them and see what you think... (or just try it while at the hardware store)...I can hear the loud speaker at Home Depot now, "Customer in aisle 9, dancing on the loose timber! ;-)

ken

I bought my Leclerc Artisant used 5 months ago on craigs list. It is my first loom and its about 37 years old. having to clean it ,replace parts,etc. etc. I learned alot about my loom. Like Sally, I weave in my socks or barefeet so I can feel the treadles. The Artisant  treadles are close together,but after weaving on it I got a feel for them,just like any other loom. Jack looms like the Artisant require a little more effort in treadling when you have multiple tie-ups. If your doing single tie up raising the shafts are very easy in my  humble opinion. With regard to the number of treadles, in my own mind I like having 6 treadles with my 4 shaft....gives me more to work with;and as stated above you'll be surprised by what you can do with 4 shafts.

Honeyfinn

I have an HD that came with 4 treadles and I upgraded right away and never regreted it! Recently I have been looking at other looms to "upgrade" and decided that I really like my HD. I sold my Leclerc Fanny because it was too heavy to treadle in comparison and I like the rising sheds. I have made small rugs on the HD, and while the loom handled it fine, it did seem a bit stretch for the lightweight loom. It is awesome for creating my wool yardage though! Getting the accessories is a real plus...as is getting the loom from someone who can advise you as you begin this journey. 

ricatlga

I also have 36" 4 shaft Artisat loom.  I peddle in socks or barefoot because I can't get my shoes on one peddle at a time.  Great in summer, chilly in winter.  Yes, I've noticed treadling multiple tie-ups can be difficult.  In fact on my latest project (simple 2-1 twill) I abandoned for direct tie-up and just use both feet.  My only other floor loom experience was years ago at John C. Campbell with my first class.  I used a Macomber and really liked it.  Maybe I'll be able to afford an 8 shaft Mac at some point.

I have a piano bench with a pad on it.  The advantage was it was free.  Many churches abandon old pianos (your grandmother's style uprights) and that was where this one came from.  If the height is not right you can get anyone good with a saw to lower to the optimal height for you.  I need to get out Mr. Knisely's DVD again to calculate if I have mine set correctly.

Joanne Hall

When you have a choice of looms, here are some things to compare.  And it will be easy for the seller to give you this information:

Warp and cloth beams

Compare the measurement of the circumference of the beams.  The bigger the beam the better the tension will be.  Also, a laminated beam will be stronger than a beam made with one piece of wood.

Loom depth

The deeper the loom, the easier the treadling will be.

Breast beam height

The taller the breast beam height, the more comfortable you will be. 

Beater

If the beater is adjustable in height that is an advantage.  It is also helpful if the reed is adjustable side to side to center a warp, or so that a longer reed can be used.

It is also helpful if the breast beam is easily removable for more comfort threading the heddles.

Joanne

 

dmdpanda

I'd be curious to know which of these people would recommend for someone of petite height? I'm 5'0" and am just starting to do my research. I forgot to sit down at one I recently saw. How should it fit ergonomically? Where should my shoulders, elbows align with the beam? How much clearance is recommended between knees and loom? Thanks.

sequel (not verified)

The Baby Wolf is a small loom.  Not appropriate for tall (5'7" and over) although some of those may like it, I see too many students hunched over them.  You should be able to sit comfortably on your chair or bench so that your hips are higher than your knees and your elbows clear the breast beam.  If you have long legs, you'll want to be sure you don't run your knees into the cloth beam.  If you sit too low you will be treadling with your ankles instead of your upper legs (quadriceps).  The quads are nice big strong muscles, unlike ankles which are small, delicate joints.

Submitted by Ellp on