The free 2010 Smithsonian Folklife Festival runs through Monday July 5th in DC.  This year, the Mexico program features a family of Zapotec weavers from Teotitlan del  Valle in Oaxaca (Familia Vicente Contreras).  They brought a walking loom and spinning wheel, are giving carding, spinning and weaving demonstrations, plus  talks on natural dyes (cochineal and indigo).  On Sunday the 4th at 3:00 there will be a talk on "design and meaning in weaving". 

Earlier this week, someone in the audience asked about people coming to learn weaving techniques. Senor Joel Vicente responded that the weavers tended to guard their traditions jealously.  He did say weavers might be more open with  someone who spends a lot of time in Teotitlan and is a regular buyer who obviously appreciates their art.  Someone else asked "what if an outsider marries into a weaving family" to which he responded something like " well, perhaps... if they are going to live in Teotitlan."

My other favorite moment was watching Senor Vicente casually use the spinning wheel's spindle to also fill reed bobbins.  You can see the same thing on this YouTube video of another Teotitlan weaver, Federico Chavez Sosa.

The techniques seemed to be a combination of slit weave tapestry, something similar to the Navajo turned warp ( but with each color area worked in both sheds, making a complete turn before picking up the next weft), and the slow buildup of curvilinear elements.

 

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

 Those spinning wheels do even more - you spin a cop full and then you can remove the drive band and wind the skein on the drive wheel.

Naturally winding bobbins is a snap.

And the wide, flat bench provides sitting room or a horizontal surface when not in use.

weaver-dyer (not verified)

I also visited the Smithsonian Folklife Festival on the National Mall and heard a discussion with Joel and his family.  I also took some photos of Joel, his loom, his weavings, and some of the equipment used by Joel and his wife and daughter. Joel's loom is in the Rio Grande style with 2 counterbalanced shafts and two treadles.  The reed and temple (stretcher) are made of bamboo.   In addition, I took some photos of embroidery and beadwork as well as some of the "costumes" worn by the participants.  You are welcome to take a look at the photos http://www.flickr.com/photos/51820844@N04/?saved=1

Janet

 

debmcclintock

 thank you for posting photos, one of the sad things of moving home to Texas is the Folklife Festival is now sorta hard to just drive over to....I love that festival and how they spotlight different cultures.  Deb Mc

 

sally orgren

Wish I could have seen this, and thanks for the great photo post, Janet! D.C. is just not on the immediate agenda with work deadlines and travel for conferences coming up, so these posts are much appreciated.

Why is it that Zapotec weaving is not considered as valued as Diné (Navajo) weaving in America?

I noticed when I visit CO or AZ, galleries are quick to point out the difference in origin, and the Zapotec weaving is often priced for much less, although the design might be more complicated than a similar-sized Diné piece. Is that true in other parts of the world? For instance, in Mexico, would Zapotec weaving fetch a higher price than a Diné piece of similar size and design?

I have woven a small piece on a Navajo loom under the instruction of Pearl Sunrise, and I have walked a Rio Grande loom. Although the mechanics for creating the shed are a bit different with each, the time-consuming part of the process  (placing multiple wefts in complicated designs in a tapestry-technique) seems pretty similar to me, especially the complexity of what is being carried in the weaver's head regarding the pattern, and the technical proficiency and experience needed to have the final design look like what the weaver intends.

So why the vast difference in value? Is this a marketing tactic, or is there a real basis for the difference that I am overlooking?

Just curious if anyone else has some insight on this. Thanks!

Sally

Sara von Tresckow

I'd suppose that which work is more valuable depends a great deal on whose territory the gallery stands on.

MaryMartha

 As I understand it, many Zapotec weavers now deliberately copy Navajo designs and their products are sometimes even marketed as "Navajo" rugs.  This, plus speeded up production and the substitution of cheaper materials (cotton warps and chemical dyes)  have contributed to the devaluation of  Zapotec weaving.   This is an old story.  Indigenous weaving traditions give way to copying because it sells.  Weavers have always responded to commercial forces.  The market for slow, expensive authentic materials and techniques is small compared to the market to take home something exotic and cheap. 

The Vicente Contreras family are among those trying to restore this dying tradition with handspun, natural-dyed wool and authentic traditional or original designs.  Unfortunately, the market is crowded with cheaper production that drives prices down.  This was very much in evidence at the folklife festival marketplace.

Another factor seems to be access to markets.  Before 911, Joel said, they relied on tourist coming to Teotitlan to buy their wares.  After 911, the tourism dropped off sharply and has never quite recovered.  This puts the weavers more at the mercy of traders. The traders insist on what sells back home, including copies of Navajo designs.  The weavers, of course, reinterpret the requested designs according to their own traditions.

What is really interesting is that some recognizably  Zapotec design elements seem to be making their way into Navajo weaving.  Maybe the Navajo weavers have seen a Zapotec spin put on Navajo designs so often that they are coming to think of these as part of their own  tradition.  One example is the substitution of the stepped Zapotec Grecas for the smooth-edged Navajo water symbol, or the use of  radiating lines around a star or squash blossom design.  In Zapotec rugs, the "Van Buren butterflies" often have distinctive small ovals at both ends. 

sally orgren

Mary, 

Thank you very much, your thoughtful comments are very helpful and bring up some factors I hadn't considered, like the warps and fiber content. As to commercial dyes, we can find Diné rugs woven with commercially-dyed yarn as readily as natural dyes in any of the galleries and trading posts out west, so in my mind, that isn't as much of a factor.

Also, in the Joe Ben Wheat book published in 2004, I think he pointed out the cross-pollination over the border between Spanish and Native American weaving that goes way back, although not often recognized. (You mentioned that too, and I thought that was fascinating-would love to learn more about this!) 

The story of the traders influencing the product is indeed an old and repeated one. I had an interesting interaction with Bruce Burnham many years ago at the Sedgewick Gallery in Philadelphia, where he provided the weavings for the exhibit "Eyedazzlers: The Two Century Romance of Navajo Weaving and Germantown Yarn."

Bruce is a 4th generation trader from Sanders, Arizona. He told me after awhile the "mothers" wanted to teach him to weave. His wife (a Diné) told him that he should listen, so he humored them and tired it, but soon got tired of it and set it aside. On a regular basis, the weavers would come to the post and ask to see his progress. He realized that in their tradition, they had risked a lot to teach him to weave (If he left the warp unfinished, his teachers risked their lives becoming unraveled, too.) He made up his mind to finish the piece, and he told me he realized at that point he did not have a right to dictate what they should weave.

He proceeded to tell me he keeps that original weaving at the post as a reminder. What he didn't know is that I travel a lot. So a few years later, I stopped by the post, unannounced. This is not a tourist post, this is a trading post for the locals. And Bruce immediately remembered me, and he took me back into his rug room and showed me that original weaving he made. It would win no prizes, but really made the complete story come alive to me. That whole experience led me to take a Navajo weaving class at Convergence in 2004, and sparked an interest to continue to learn more about this kind of weaving with renewed respect.

Ironically, the experience led us acquire both types of rugs (Navajo and Zapotec) over the next few years. I guess the more I learn about the history and weaving techniques involved, the more I wonder if the Zapotec rugs should be valued more than they are. So I am glad to learn they were featured recently in such a prominent place. (And I am scheduled to take the Rio Grande class at Convergence this summer, so hope to learn much more!)

Sally

P.S. It was a nice surprise to learn Bruce will be hosting the rug auction at Convergence on Saturday afternoon.

Sara von Tresckow

 We're friends with a Zapotec weaver here in the Midwest. The "trader" look at what is "collectible" doesn't enter our conversations. This weaver, and his family, make what they make. This gentleman does contemporary designs from his wife's line of work, has done oriental carpet motifs in tapestry, and sells what comes out of his hands. I personally can only afford the rugs his Dad makes - his original compositions are way out of our price category. We're currently fixing the drive head on his spinning wheel - love that wheel even more since I found out is is a skeiner, bobbin winder and spinning wheel with picnic bench built in.

All this overanalysis of what constitutes "real" ethnic work disappears when one sits down, designs something for the loom, and executes it. Obviously, any handwork tradition will be offered to outsiders and tourists in the best light possible and with all manner of "this is unique to...". Purpose of this is to sell for a better price. As with anything, it is up to us as potential customers to decide what something is worth to us.

And yes, I have had the privilege of taking a class with this weaver - resulting in one tiny student piece and a lot of appreciation for the work in that studio.

Submitted by MaryMartha on