Hi, Just curious how many people use a warping square for sectional warping and how your experience with it has been.

Comments

islandweaver (not verified)

Yes. I was wondering if sectional warpers could comment, did they save alot of time or investment without have to make bobbins or purchase more cones. It seens to be a beautiful piece of equipment, just want to know more about investing in the purchase.

ReedGuy

I warp sectionally, but use spools, rack and tension box. I built them all so very little cash layout. A double end bobbin winder saves a lot of time on winding spools.

I'm sure there are users of this device somewhere, but maybe not a lot of them.

islandweaver (not verified)

I' m curious, How do you save time with a double end bobbin winder? Do you wind 2 at a time?

ReedGuy

vs hand winding them. I have wound quite few 4-10 yard warps by manual winder onto spools. :) An electric double end winder is like warp speed. ;)

A double end winder as a point of contact at each end.

mneligh

If it works like an AVL warping wheel, it definitely saves a lot of time.  It looks like it works like a warping wheel.  You don't have to fill spools, chain warp, or rethread a tension box with the wheel.    You just measure the warp by turning the wheel, snip, move the reed to the long arm, and then start cranking the sectional beam.  The tension mechanism is built in.

I used to use the spool rack, electric bobbin winder, yardage counter, etc. mentioned above for most things, then only for warps of more than 15 yards, then almost never. Because I frequently spin my warps, I don't like the waste of warp thread that results from trying to fill the spools to the same level, even using a yardage counter.

ReedGuy

From what I've seen of the wheel from videos your essentally rethreading the comb and winding onto the wheel for each section on the warp beam. You might as well say your winding a huge spool several times. But more than that, passing the yarn through a more complicated path.

If it's different than that procedure let us know. Because otherwise you'll have the same potential for waste if your winding all the warp before it's beamed. I have put a 50" wide warp 4 yards long of 10/2 cotton using 32 spools in an afternoon. That would mean winding that wheel 50 times for 50 - 1"sections with warp vs 32 spools, if I understand the procedure. There is some waste as in yardage left on spools, but very short amounts when done carefully and not running your winder like it's being sent off to the moon. There are physical limitations that effect accuracy of measuring yardage.

mneligh

You don't rethread.  Each time you get one warp thread completed, you hook it around the comb, then a hook, then spin the wheel.  At the end of a section, you move the comb.

For warps of more than 15 yards or so or wide warps, the spool rack - tension box might be faster.  For shorter than that, definitely not, at least for me, especially not if I hand wind the spools. The main reason I switched is the amount of waste with handspun warps, however.

I am guilty of running the winder too fast at times, I confess. I don't seem to be able to slow it down enough, unlike my sewing machine.  I've gone to the hand-crank bobbin winder for bobbins so I can have more control.  I typically am winding 48 - 60 or so spools, so waste becomes a significant issue.  

ReedGuy

I used to hand wind, but no more. Not that I'm in a race, but because of the repetitive motion. I've done enough of the mindless repetition in not only hand spool winding, but in work tasks to suffice for 3 lifetimes. :D

mrdubyah (not verified)

The AVL wheel is a massive time saver.  Each turn winds three yards of warp.  Working off of four cones lets me wind 12 yards of warp at a turn, four ends at a time.  When I have enough ends to fill one bout, I feed the warp directly onto the warp beam through the comb, secure the ends with tape, and move to the next bout.  Goes a lot faster than a warping board and takes a lot less work than a spool rack. 

mrdubyah (not verified)

I suppose you can see it that way, but a giant spool picks up thread way faster than a tiny spool.  

islandweaver (not verified)

Thanks all for your input, this has been so very informative!

mrdubyah (not verified)

To fill a 2" bout with a ~10 yard warp at 24 epi (480 yds) I only need to spin the wheel 36 turns.  (4 threads x 3.3 yds/turn x 36 turns = 475.2 yds.)  That's pretty easy.  With my spool rack I have to put 500 yards on each of 48 spools before I can even fill my first bout!  The spool rack and tensioner are big time savers when the yarn comes already on the spools.  Otherwise the two methods take roughly the same amount of time.  Either one is still considerably faster and easier than using a warping board and lease sticks. 

MMs-and-OOs-Ha…

I have a Warping Square. I bought the electric version. I really like it. The WSq comes with locking casters and an easy system of winding the correct warp length. The counter is very accurate. Tensioning is from a dial, no cords. It comes with a built in cross maker. My goal is to have a perfectly ordered warp with the threading cross = to the raddle cross to avoid twists. Like the Warping Wheel, depending on your yarn and if you have a 1" or 2" sectional beam you might not be able to wind super EPI warps. Overall compared to winding spools for convential sectional warping, it is faster. With any warping method, and I use whatever is appropriate, there is no free lunch.

ReedGuy

I just find that the winding of the wheel is more complicated. It isn't simply winding, you have to thread a comb each time, pass the yarn by a clip, and some dowels, wind, adjust them as you wind, remove the comb, put it somewhere else on the gadget, then beam. With a spool, take a cone and thread the box and counter once, then you just simply place it on the spool and secure by hand for 4 tiny wraps and fill it with the winder. I could easily wind 4 spools (mine are mounted on dowel in the rack in 4's) of 500 yards in less than 10 minutes, no more than 12 mins. Thus 10 x 6 sets of 4 spools is 60 minutes. Thread my box in a short number of minutes. Everthing else is the same process. If I have certain sections that need narrow stripes and others none, that's all planned ahead and you wind the solid color sections first onto the beam then thread the box for sections with the color stripes and wind those on. Weaving is usually about repeats, there's thousands of old drafts in which that is what is done, one color warp, one weft color. When we get more complicated with color in the warp or supplementary warp/weft, then we make the warping/weaving more complicated, and thus slows things.

Mother asks how I do what I do and make pattern in cloth. Jokingly, I tell her I'm a genious. ;)

My latest project required 64 threads to fill a 1" section, 38" weaving width. Plus conventional warping and beaming of a supplementary beam. Only 4 yards each.

I don't tie onto cords in the sectionional, I tie onto a dowel. The dowel is released from the beam and held by cords to weave the last 2 yards. It's never been a problem. When finished weaving, the waste is cut free and no knots to undo.

ReedGuy

MMs-and-OOs, do you know what part of MI they are made. I'm often in northern MI every other year, if it was in that part of the state I may be able to go have a look. :)

Like from Bay City, across to Harrison and north, that range.

MMs-and-OOs-Ha…

I didn't pay much attention to their shipping address, but thsi what their website says, "We are located in Ypsilanti, Michigan which is right next to Ann Arbor and about 20 miles west of Detroit". I have never been to Michigan so I have no idea where this is.

ReedGuy

Ok thanks, I won't be down that far south. :)

mrdubyah (not verified)

I see it as a heirarchy.  Warping board, warping reel, warping wheel (or square) and then spool rack and tensioner, in that order.  The longer and/or the wider my warp, the more likely I am to use the spool rack.  For short warps (<10 yards) on narrow looms (<40") I mostly use the wheel.

mneligh

Since I use both the tension box and spool rack method and the warping wheel method I have to say that for very large (wide and long) warps there comes a point when the spool rack method takes less time than the warping wheel, and the amount of waste becomes insignificant compared to the total length of warp used.  For me, that point comes for yards of at least 16 yards and 48" minimum.  For less than that, I prefer the wheel.  And at that, I probably would use the spool rack method only with commercial yarn warps.

 

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on