I've been going back to structure theory and boning up on the technology.  I used to not worry too much about the harness/shaft thing, but, I really hope that we can start beating the drum to get the correct usage out there.  A harness is a group of shafts that work together for a "particular function" and, since clarity of language is the basis of good communication, it would be great if we could get everybody on the same page about this.

Just a thought for the day as I drag my nose out of my current reading of Dorothy Burnham.

 

Nancy c

Comments

Sara von Tresckow

You're correct in trying to clear up the terminology.

I have my drawloom in the shop and it is really difficult to explain to new weavers that it is a double harness loom - a ground harness and a pattern harness and each thread goes through a heddle on each.

It seems to really confuse them and even when explained as gently as humanly possible, they resent that it somehow challenges their Chandler vocabulary.

debmcclintock

It is so not just Chandler, during the 80's and 90's it was perpetuated by many folks writing in the US.  All we can do is explain patiently and not let our head rotate with green stuff coming out of our mouth to make it a pleasant learning experience rather than a scary moment of correction...

celtinbirks

In the 1950's in the US, this particular part of a loom was also called a "frame".

Sara von Tresckow

Heddle frame is actually an older, but very acceptable term for a shaft - heald is also a substitute.

kerstinfroberg

is what we call it in Sweden - maybe easier to understand than "harness"?

In older lit I have seen "leaf" (pl "leaves") (British source, don't remember which) and "wing" (Bronson, Am. source).

- tried to post this earlier, but as it hasn't shown 2 hrs later, I'm trying again...

Kade1301

seems to be an older (?) British term for heddle - at least that's how Collingwoold uses it in "Techniques of Rug Weaving": "String healds are best as every kind of warp can easily be threaded through the eyes." (page 53).

Sarah D

Yes indeed, heald is an older version of heddle in GB. For those who may have been tracing their family history, 'Reed and Heald Maker' and  'Heald Knitter' (which, confusingly, has nothing to do with knitting, as such) were occupations that would crop up in the census in days long gone.

WeaverDave (not verified)

I've always wondered about those terms.  So, I want to make sure I understand this.  If I have a 4 shaft, 6 treaddle Jack Loom, and I have attached shafts 1 and 3 to treaddle 5, that treaddle 5 acts to "harness" shafts 1 and 3 in unison.  Is that the way it works?

 

 

Su Butler

Dave - your treadle is attached to shafts 1 and 3, simple as that. As Sara pointed on, on a double harness loom, a single thread will enter a heddle on a shaft in BOTH harnesses, but on most American looms a thread enters a heddle on a shaft that is housed on a single harness. A "harness" is a set of shafts. Most looms in the U.s. are single harness, multi-shaft looms. Each individual frame that holds the heddles is called a shaft. The larger element on a loom that housees the shafts is called a harness. I learned to weave in the early 1970's and the term harness was widely used in place of shaft. Sometime in the 1980's there was a call to begin to use the terminology more accurately, but you have a generation or two of weavers and multiple written resources using the terminology incorrectly. It takes a long time to reverse that. When I teach I use the term shaft, but will occasionally call it a harness if I see that the students are confused by the temrinology. I do try to alert them to the difference and encourage them to use the terminology correctly.

WeaverDave (not verified)

  I understand.  But I think I'll just refrain from using the term, "harness". 

debmcclintock

and here's a nice article on the CNCH website that goes thru the history of the drawloom with some drawings. 

We had a conversation about this subject in Weavo last year and I tried to use the link used there which was a really well written article by on a medival CW group site but that link is broken...sigh...

Kade1301

Coming back to the original post: "A harness is a group of shafts that work together for a "particular function" - what exactly is the source for this statement? Or, more precisely, when did the usage change?

For Atwater writes harness (here, for example: http://www.cs.arizona.edu/patterns/weaving/articles/tw_4_4-06.pdf - pity there's no publication year, but from the font I'd say pre-70s), Mary E. Black uses harness throughout her Key to Weaving, and Fannin writes in Handloom Weaving Technology that in GB all the frames together are called the harness and "each frame separately 'the shaft'. Most often in the U.S. the term 'harness' refers to individual frames as well as to all harness frames together."

Now, for somebody who learnt English as foreign languages and knows about hood and bonnet, boot and trunk, "harness" and "shaft" could be just further proof that England and America are two countries separated by a common language...

Woodburner

*spinning head smiley*

So, if the most complicated loom I'm ever going to use or talk about is a Swedish type 4-10 shaft counterbalance loom, I don't actually need to know what a harness is?

Joanne Hall

Yes, it was in the early and mid 20th century that American weavers used the name harness. 

It was when we started using more shafts, using drawlooms and started communicating in a larger weaving world that we needed to correct our word to shaft.  Even in the 60s When Harriet Tidball published her book, she stated that we needed to correct the word to shaft.  Handwoven changed to shaft about 25, maybe more years ago. 

Joanne

PS  I know this because I was there then.  I started weaving in the 60s.

Cheryl'B

Oh my......just getting into the weaving world trying to learn all of these new terms and how they apply and now I read this thread.....ugggg <grabs head to stop the spinning>

Awesome info on this site.....thanks to all of you who post and contribute!

endorph

head spin a bit more one can go to the OED (Oxford English Dictionary) and look up their deifnintions of harness and shaft in relation to weaving. And then run into to terms like leaf and leashes in relation to shafts. . . .and on and on and on. And shaft is also an obsolete term used to describe woollen fabric made on the loom as in 4 shaft cloth or ten shaft cloth. . .

laurafry

4 shaft cloth just means it was woven on four shafts, etc.  Only terminology that means something to another weaver.  :)

cheers,

Laura

debmcclintock

Don't forget marketers, textile collectors and museum textile conservators have a totally different perspective from a weaver. Take a moment to learn the background and culture the person is operating in and you'll learn many phrases which describe the same cloth & how it was made.

laurafry

Yes, unfortunately marketers come up with some doozies!  :(

And then there is translation from other languages by people who probably don't know current weaving terminology...all sorts of levels of confusion.

cheers,

Laura

endorph

learning the craft specific terminology a fascinating subject and then trying to trace the etymology of the words whcih sometimes opens up some great insights into the history and development of the craft - I often find terminology to be like dialects - we are sort of all speaking the same language (not literally obviously) but it is colored by our location. That's why forums such as this are so helpful and informative. And fun - did I mention fun?

ammann58 (not verified)

for the very enjoyable discussion here. I have found it a learning experience and one that I will endeavor to include in any teaching I will do in the future. Communication can be confusing if we do not maintain the terminology. This is not just true for weaving or any other technical field.

I picture in my mind Paul Lynde singing, "Kids, who can understand anything they say?"

I am glad to get the terms clear.

 

Sara von Tresckow

The distinction between harness and shaft is not only in English - the German refers to Harnisch or Geschirr and Schaft. The Harnisch and Geschirr terms are also applicable to the harness used to hitch a beast of burden to a wagon - a complex collection of pieces, just like the harness on the loom. The shafts are the pieces.

Also, the harness is still used in mill weaving - when we visited Sweden a few years ago, Klassbols mill (makes damask for the Royal Family) had entire harnesses hanging on the wall - harness consisting of reed, shaft frames with heddles and the drop wires, all with a dummy warp that could be tied onto a new warp when that harness was placed in one of their mechanized, computer driven dobby looms.(Stored pattern and allowed a new fabric without threading all the heddles and reed again.)

I have seen the same thing here in Wisconsin with an old barn loom - had no room for it - but it came with at least 3 harnesses consisting of a real reed and shaft frames threaded with that same dummy warp and labelled with the number of threads, and with a small piece woven to show what pattern it produced. Saw the same process in a German handweaving studio in 2009 - the harness is a pattern storage device worth knowing about. This is not just silly play on words.

kerstinfroberg

Like Sara, I have seen harnesses in smaller Swedish mills. However, I don't know what they are called in Swedish.

BUT: "harnesk" in Swedish (at least in handweaving circumstances) refer to a a single-draw draw attachment (as opposed to a "shaft-draw" attachment, er, "harness").

Some pictures of a "harnesk-rustning": here (nothing "drawn"), and here (some patterns drawn, weaver in place)

Woodburner

I am interested in double harness after all! But I don't understand how threads can go through two heddles, and not interfere with the other harness when opening sheds.

Can anyone point me in the direction of info on how they work please?

laurafry

One set of heddles has 'long eyes'.  It's a bit of a mind twister but it does work.  Look for resources on damask or other draw loom techniques.

cheers,

Laura

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on