Greetings to all!

I am currently experiencing a bit of troubleshooting with an overshot pattern and am hoping for some feedback from more experienced weavers!

It seems that I set up (warping, threading, tie ups, etc.) correctly, as when I weave I can see that the pattern shows up. The "problem" I am having is that it just doesn't look that great. As you can see from the photos I have uploaded, the design is really only visible if I am standing away from my loom and looking at it from an angle. Up close it kind of just looks like a mess of white and red and the pattern is incredibly "stretched out." I don't think the design is really coming through properly. What am I doing wrong here? Is it my sett? I would appreciate any overshot advice, whether its related to my question or not.

my set up is as follows:

warp: 8/4 cotton, 16 epi on an 8 dent reed (2 ends per dent)

weft: random bulk cotton I have laying around, heavier than 8/4

tabby: 8/4 cotton

pattern: cat track and snail trail II in Davison, page 106

photos below

kindness and gratitude,

 

Anna

 

Comments

Artistry

Hi Anna,

it looks to me that your pattern weft of bulky cotton is too heavy. Your pattern weft needs to be approximately twice the size of your tabby weft( and in this case warp) . To know for sure if your pattern weft is the correct size, the angle of your woven diagonal will be 45 degrees.

so try some less bulky wefts:) good luck!

Cathie

ReedGuy

Sometimes it's not square because there are too many picks per block as well. But I assume your followed the draft as written, so it's likely the weft being too bulky. And scale as in yarn sizes can mean a lot to the looks. Even 8/4 is quite bulky warp for overshot. You will definitely see the pattern further away much better because of the large yarn sizes. It will get a more pixelized look.

Karren K. Brito

 The ground structure under the overshot pattern is balanced plain weave.

Balanced plain weave means that your epi equals your ppi.  You sett of 16 epi, means that you need to have 15-16 pick per inch to get the 45° angle and the design to look like the book draft.  Since it is not possible with your yarns and sett, you are getting a lot less than 15ppi, you design is elongated.  You might try a finer ground weft, 8/2 or even 16/2 cotton, and see if you can get a balanced weave.  

Then once you have a balanced weave, start your overshot pattern.  The pattern weft has to fit in the structure without increasing the ppi of the ground weft and at the same time cover the ground fabric in the solid blocks.  The pattern weft is usually bulkier and softer than the ground weft.  A lot of traditional overshot coverlets and cotton warp and ground weft and wool pattern weft.

Artistry

Hi Anna and All, 

i was browsing through Helen Bress this morning " the Weaving Book"  and came across 8/4 for warp and plain weave weft ( tabby) as one of the possibilities for overshot. ( pg.207)  using the same materials in warp and weft at the correct sett will give balance weave. Of Course, you don't have to use the same materials, as along as you get a balanced plain weave technically. Bress suggests a set of 12-15 epi and pattern warp of , Sporting weight knitting yarn, acrylic, wool.( pg. 207) If it were me, I'd like wool, if it were for a baby a nice soft cotton. Not acrylic! It burns and melts and sticks to the skin!

hope this helps, you've gotten good advice above:)

Cathie

 

Artistry

Also found this in the same book " the sett for Overshot is just a little more open than for a 50/50 Plain Weave. Conventionally, the warp and the tabby weft are the same fine yarns , or the tabby thread is the same color but slightly finer than the warp. ( the pattern weft)...It is usually a soft yarn that will pack in well in the closely woven areas, and fluff out where it floats on the surface. It is because the pattern weft condenses or squashes down in the background area and fluffs out in the pattern area obscuring the Plain Weave area beneath it, that this combination of yarns produces the effect it does. It doesn't seem possible that the heavy pattern weft would allow the warp and tabby to interweave close enough to make a 50/50 Plain Weave , but the softness of the pattern weft does allow this to happen. (Pg 207)

of course, their are many more sources devoted just to Overshot ,which I don't have in my lap this morning, which could say this is completely wrong! Welcome to weaving:)

Cathie

Sara von Tresckow

The 8/4 cotton is not really appropriate for a nice tabby ground weave. The number of plies is a major hindrance because your interlacing a will not pack the same way that single or 2-ply yarns do. The 4-ply yarn is not flexible enough to pack squarely and firmly.

For overshot, 8/2 or finer cotton would be nicer.

MJWallace

The sett of 16 epi is too dense for the warp yarn.  When I weave overshot with a 8/2 cotton warp, I sett it at 18 epi when normally plain weave for 8/2 cotton is 20 epi.  Also depending of the pattern yarn weight, I may go to 16/2 cotton for the tabby. 

I think that at sett of 10 - 12 epi would be more appropriate for 8/4 cotton. Try weaving with a 8/2 cotton tabby if you still can't get the pattern 'square'.

I have seen and handled a overshot runner made with 8/4 cotton and it was lovely.  The 8/4 cotton was a unmercized cotton from Brassard adn not rug warp cotton.

Good luck.

MJWallace

The sett of 16 epi is too dense for the warp yarn.  When I weave overshot with a 8/2 cotton warp, I sett it at 18 epi when normally plain weave for 8/2 cotton is 20 epi.  Also depending of the pattern yarn weight, I may go to 16/2 cotton for the tabby. 

I think that at sett of 10 - 12 epi would be more appropriate for 8/4 cotton. Try weaving with a 8/2 cotton tabby if you still can't get the pattern 'square'.

I have seen and handled a overshot runner made with 8/4 cotton and it was lovely.  The 8/4 cotton was a unmercized cotton from Brassard adn not rug warp cotton.

Good luck.

laurafry

As others have said, use fewer epi and see how that works. 

Cheers

laura

ReedGuy

I have woven with 10/2 cotton and had to go down to 16 epi for an 8 shaft whig rose to square. And I have a loom with some heft to the beater. I'm now weaving overshot with whig rose, pine cone, whig is at a larger scale (probably 4x) and some twill along the warp and weft as stripes and am using 32 epi and 30 ppi. What I have found out is it depends on how long the blocks are weft-wise just as much as it does sett. There is no easy recipie, sampling is in order.

annafusco

Thank you Karren! Seemingly obvious but necessary information for me!

rughooker1

When counting my ppi on overshot, is my tabby part of that count? Everything looks square. I am weaving a dresser scarf, don't want a hot pad when finished!

Joanne Hall

The ground weave should be a balanced weave.  So, if you removed all the pattern wefts, you would have a stable weave that has approx as many wefts per inch as warps per inch.

Joanne

Submitted by annafusco on