Hi,  I am completely new to this group and to floor loom weaving.  A friend is selling her weaving studio, and has a Macomber loom with 8 harnesses, a 48 weaving width, reeds of 6,8,10 and 16 dent/inch varying in widths from 36-48 inches wide.  Plus all the necessary accessories.  It looks very intimidating.  Is this a suitable loom for a complete beginner?  Any assistance would be appreciatedl.  Thank you,  Mary

Comments

tommye scanlin

The loom will serve you well and you'll grow into it as you delve into the depths that weaving can give you, if you want it! Tommye

Michael White

As far as this being to much loom for a beginning weaver, no. A little more complex yes. But once you learn the basics of weaving you can weave on any size loom. The price of a new 8H 48" loom is  $3322 with one reed. Is $2500 a good price, that is for you to decide. But I would ask the seller to thrown in weaving instructions as well if they are able to teach. Look the loom over and see how much rust there is on the heddle frames, lamms and the reeds. And come up with how long and how much it would  take to clean up this loom if it needs it and adjust the price. Never pay the asking price always offer a lower price and go from there.

Michael

maryweave1

Thank you very much for your comments.  The loom is nearly rust free and the wood recently oiled.  This loom is actually too big for my house and I would put it on loan at a museum in Lochapoka AL (near Auburn University).  We are starting a fiber guild there and using the museum as our headquarters.  We currently have a Dorothy that we let school children use as part of tours on how to spin cotton/wool into yarn, then weave it into cloth, sew it into clothes and use the scraps to quilt.  We have a Frannie that works well (apparently), but want another loom so we can have weaving classes of at least 2 people.  There are about 5 people "active" in the guild so far, we are just starting out so your comments are invaluable.   

Dena (not verified)

Mary-I've got a different opinion about it.  It might be a great loom for you down the line (and I totally adore Macombers), but $2500 seems like a lot when you're not sure yet what you ultimately want in a loom, especially when it doesn't fit in your house.  Yes, you can grow into this loom, but if you figure out that you really just love weaving scarves in plain weave and you have no where to put the loom, you may end up wishing you had gotten a smaller loom.  I love my macombers, but I don't enjoy weaving narrow pieces on a really wide loom.  For that price, you can really pick and choose from used (or new) looms.  I would encourage you to take your time, figure out what it is you really want and then decide on what loom to get.

CubeDweller

I agree with Dena, and Tommye, and Michael. How's that for being diplomatic?

When I took my first weaving class there was a Macomber lurking in the classroom, or dare I say it, "looming"? - sorry.  It was a monster (60"? 48"? 1,000"?). I stayed clear of it, as did the more experienced weavers. I clung to a non-threatening Schacht and we became fast friends. But I was in awe of it - the Macomber.

So if this is going into a classroom setting, it may be a way to identify the fearlesss (foolish?), but it may not get much use. Ours certainly languished. But it was a beast, not a "petite" 48" model - I don't think.

It seems for $2,500 you could find a couple of Schachts, maybe three, or four, if you're lucky. And beginners will latch onto them , as I did, and will be very happy weaving scarves, samples, and perhaps placemats and runners. And you can do much more with them, especially if you grab an 8 shaft model.

maryweave1

I guess I just don't know enough about weaving--I have a triangle loom that I like, but it is a totally different procedure.  Another friend is selling a frannie for $700 including accessories that is almost new.  Either of these 2 looms seemed like a good starting place for a beginner, though they both seem intimidating.  Neither of these sellers has the health or time to teach me how to use them, so its the manual and teach myself.

loomroomcat (not verified)

I live in Michigan and buy and sell alot of used looms. I personally would not pay that much for that loom.  You can find a really nice used loom for $600-1000.  If you pay top dollar, and do not continue weaving you will be hard pressed to get your money out of the loom.  You can always buy something for less and trade up when you fall madly in love with weaving.

SallyE (not verified)

I agree with loomroomcat.   $2500 is too much for that loom.   A few years ago and in a better economy I bought my Macomber for $900.  It is "only" 40 inches wide, but has 8 shafts and 18 treddles.  I LOVE my Macomber.  I find my sholders start to hurt when I weave wider than about 36", so for me the extra width wouldn't be a plus.   But that is just me.

maryweave1

Thank you for the previous 2 posts-in fact ALL of them!.  It seems like the way to go is to start smaller, maybe with a table type loom to see if I like this type of weaving? One that will actually fit in my house.

 

Many thanks

Matt (not verified)

Hi Mary, My opinion is that this is probably too big of a commitment at any price if you haven't done any floor loom weaving. You'll have a better idea of what to get if you can figure out what kinds of things you'll want to weave. Plus if at all possible, weave on a few different kinds of looms and take a class. I've heard of too many weavers (including my dear mother, a top notch quilter) who buy a big loom or a whole studio, even at a great bargain. Then they warp it once and then not finish the project, never touching it again because it's all too much and it turns out they're not that interested in weaving on that scale (or at all). Not to discourage you, just something to think about. Skip to the bottom if you don't want to read all of the following gory details. My story: I was VERY fortunate to have had an 8 week class (2-3 hour sessions) where we took home table looms and did a new warp/project on our own each week, so we conquered the common "fear of warping" (and unwillingness to design our own projects, though I have nothing but respect for good weavers who choose to e.g. do projects straight out of Handwoven). By the end of this process I swore I would never use another table loom or stick shuttle again. On a table loom it just isn't possible to get the same kind of "rhythm" you can get by throwing a shuttle and tromping (?) on treadles (direct tie-up is often slower, but that's a whole 'nother discussion). So after the class I bought a brand new Baby Wolf, which turned out to be too small for me. But it is a "real" floor loom and can fold up small enough to fit into even small apartments, and got plenty of great projects out of it. Later I traded up to a beefier Lilla, and I'm told Mac's are about as beefy as they come. Beefy being a good thing if you are serious about weaving a wide range of things, If you start small, you'll "grow into it" -- you won't be limited if you want to weave something heavy, but can still weave any range of more delicate things. Cliff's notes version: I'd start by ideally borrowing or maybe buying a table loom for a good price to try out shaft weaving and try to take a class or get at least an intro in person. IMHO books are ok starting out, but a poor substitute for the real thing. If things go well and you want more, then go for a solid full size floor loom that won't limit you in the future. Just my $0.02, or maybe more like $100 (I am in Reno after all). --matt In Reno (and missing Boulder!)

mneligh

My first floor loom that I bought was a 48" 20 shaft Macomber.  (I had woven on other looms for years, including 3 semesters of college).  One of my instructors told me it was the loom I needed for what I wanted to do, and 48" was as big as I could afford.

The only thing I regret about it is that it is too small.  I really should have gotten a 60" or bigger loom with the maximum number of shafts.  I love my 48", have no issue weaving narrow pieces on it in spite of my having an 8 shaft Schacht Baby Wolf for demos and workshops.  I can get the warp onto the Mac faster with no back ache.  My knees don't always rub the finished cloth.  I have dragged the Mac from state to state, house to house, until I bought my current farm where it now resides.

Now it becomes difficult to justify buying a third loom.

I cannot comment about the price -- I just know how much an 8 shaft Baby Wolf costs. 

Sorry to disagree with everyone, but this has been my experience.

maryweave1

I don't see where anyone has disagreed that the mac is a good loom.  What I do see, is everyone took classes first then decided what kind of loom to buy or took classes with the loom.  I found an instructor and will try weaving on the old Fannie we have in the museum until I decide what kind of weaving to do.

You have all been of tremendous help here.  Thanks again!  Mary

Penn (not verified)

there's a 48" Macomber, 8H/10T, in NC listed on Homestead Weavers right now:
$950.00 Macomber B4-D 48 Inch 8 harness, ten treadles, lease sticks, string and metal heddles, 3 reeds, homemade flying shuttle, sectional back beam (can be converted back to plain beam), warping board, shuttle and extra items.

That's on the cheap side, but over $2K?  With some rust?  Too much, IMO.

Submitted by maryweave1 on