I've been looking into buying a lot of Tencel for some production weaving. I just found out that there are actually two types of Tencel. They are "Tencel" and "Tencel A100." For example Camilla Valley sells A100. Webs sells Tencel (at least they don't mention the A100 designation). Is there a big difference for handweavers? I found an explanation between the two, but it's too technical for me to understand:

http://www.elainegross.com/images/Tencel.pdf

The above link is an online pdf brochure, the explanation between the two Tencels is on page 5.

 

Comments

Sarah D

I say this with absolutely no authority whatsover :-) Just based on the literature you've provided, it seems likely that the tencel we weavers know is the A100 variety. The basics seem to be that the A100 mimics the long filament fibres - it's smoother (thus more lustrous) and takes dyes better. The regular tencel mimics some of the shorter fibre materials - the talk (and images) of the rougher edges, and the suede-style finishes, denims etc. A bit like the differences between filament silk and spun silk give 2 different styles of yarn. Or the manner of spinning 'woollen-spun' versus 'worsted-spun' - worsted is smooth, strong & lustrous, the other has shorter fibres and a more 'woolly' finish. 

The other thing that I'd take notice of is that the A100 is least detrimentral to our environment. But yes, I'd be fairly certain that even Webs would be A100.

.....and I've just realised I've got a cone of Tencel in the cuboard. Just looked  - I bought it in NZ, produced there by Qualityarns, and that is labelled A100 

Su Butler

HI WEavin Steven.....Tencel (which is just a trademarked name for the product called Lyocell), when it first made its debut, used to fibrulate - that means that after weaving and wet finishing, the surface of the cloth became kind of "sandwashed" or fuzzy. When Tencel A100 appeared on the market, weavers took to it quickly because the fibrulation had been controlled and it was so much easier to work with. Tencel is simply another form of Rayon but Tencel is a form that has been maniuplated in manufacture to be stronger when wet than regular rayon is when wet. It has a higher wet tenacity that regular rayon. There are a LOT of claims of environmental responsibility in the manufacture of Tencel and other regenerated cellulose fibers, but be aware that the process still dumps toxic chemicals into the water supply. Perhaps not as much as the "old" rayon, but some nonetheless. I would suspect that most Tencel sold to handweavers today is the A100 variety, as that is probably what is used in the textile trade. I have not seen a cone of fibrulating Tencel for quite some time now - doesn't mean it isn't out there, I just have not run across it. Since Tencel is an extruded fiber, it can be processed as a continuous filament or cut and processed much like cotton. I think most of it is processed like cotton. Hope that helps a little.....

laurafry

In my experience with Tencel A100, even though the fibrillation is better controlled, it still creates an enormous amount of dust when used as warp.  My preference now is to use bamoo or 'ordinary' rayon as warp and Tencel as the weft to cut down on the generation of dust.

cheers,

Laura

Weavin Steven

Su, here I was thinking I was being all politically and environmentally correct by using Tencel. Apparently not though. I saw a video not too long ago which touted the green benefits of Tencel:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W_oq6I_7Khg

I just went back and viewed the video again and realized that Duh! It was created by the company that makes Tencel, and in that regard the video will be favorable. 

Any ideas on what type of yarn would be the most environmentally sound, but which still has a nice feel similar to Tencel? As Laura mentioned, she used Rayon or Bamboo. I've used Rayon but found it to be rather flimsy as warp. I've not used Bamboo however but have heard that projects using all Bamboo are heavy. Silk is too expensive. And while probably green, it's out of my price range.

Sara von Tresckow

Just FYI - except in rare cases where bamboo yarn has been processed from the stems of th plant similar to linen, textiles made of bamboo processed like rayon must be labelled rayon made from bamboo. In other words, whichever you use you have pretty much the same impact.

Broderie (not verified)

Tencel aka Lyocel, bamboo & rayon: all cellulose based fibres. The fabric industry has for a few years now had to list as Rayon from Bamboo, could no longer list as product made from bamboo. How the yarn industry has managed to avoid this I don't know. The manufacturers are going to continue to make the product, we might as well enjoy it.

laurafry

All of the regenerated cellulose yarns are dense, which means they will have a heavier feel than for example silk.

The difference with Tencel is that it is produced with an enzyme in a closed loop system rather than using chemicals to break the cellulose down into a viscose solution.

All fibres have some sort of detrimental impact on the environment.  The best defense is to become as informed as possible - weed out the pro *and* anti-rhetoric.  Study the fibre characteristics and choose fibres appropriate for the intended purpose.

My personal sticking point is peteroleum based yarns.  I try very hard to not use them in my weaving or in my clothing (although they are very hard to avoid entirely!)

PS - would there be any interest in my doing the A Good Yarn seminar via Weavolution?  This is a lecture that utilizes a Power Point presentation for the visuals and addresses fibre and yarn characteristics and how you can enhance/modify those by how you spin the yarn and weave the cloth....

(I know some of you in Weaveo-land have taken this seminar - perhaps you could say whether or not you found it helpful?)

cheers,

Laura

Slipstream (not verified)

this question may be rhetorical but I think that we need to asks ourselves just what is the objective of 'Green" as we perceive it. I agree wholeheartedly with Laura when it comes to petroleum based fibers and I avoid them completely in my weaving although I do like Aramid fiber tires! And yes aramids are synthetic and aromatic polyamides.  However aramid tires last longer and so there is less rubber (also synthetic) in landfills and so to some extent it is being green as well as bing safe and getting a good ride.  

I personally prefer animal fiber and i believe that sheep, goats, llamas, alpacas etc can be raised in an environmentally friendly way.  Cotton, linen and of course hemp can also be raised and processed in an environmentaly friendly manner.  When one talks about tencel or bamboo or that ilk it is a cellulose-based fiber which requires quite a bit of processing and therefore energy consumption. One also has to consider what happens to the fiber after it's useful life is over, does one just throw it out.  There is an awful lot of discussion regarding the term "Green" and much of it is hype with very little fact so I believe that one needs to look at the the whole life of the fabric and its purpose during that life to determine if you are being "Green."  I would even consider putting on a wool sweater in the winter  to avoid having to turn on the petroleum generated heat a "Green" activity.  I keep my home quite a bit cooler than most, I believe, and donning a sweater is much better on the environment than adjusting the thermostat and lasts over a much longer period of time than it takes to process the fiber!

Just my opinion and I know no one asked! Regards, Charles

kerstinfroberg

Another issue with regenerated cellulose: transport! A couple of the obsolete Swedish pulp mills have recently switched to make (for the want of the correct word) raw material for viscose yarn. That means, in Sweden they make ultra-clean (white) pulp, press and dry into thick sheets, and they do it with ever evolving technique. BUT: it appears the only plants for processing this into yarn are in China... which means transport to China, and back again. Apparently there are just two (or was it one?) viscose yarn producer in Europe (incidentally Lentzing (sp?) that "invented" the Lyocell process)

Weavin Steven

I agree with the comments about animal fiber. I used to raise alpacas and use it quite a bit in my weaving. However it can only be taken so far. For finer weave fabrics I'm looking for something else. I can get very fine alpaca but there are very few mills in this country that produce it well enough and traveling to Peru to buy finer cones, while nice, is not very green nor cost effective. 

Margery (not verified)

Most of my warps are hand dyed tencel or bamboo.  The 10/2 tencel produces a light fabric that takes the dye well and can be washed and dried easily.  It hangs well on the body and can be worn in warmer climates.  The bamboo I am using is heavier - 6/2.  It is heavier when woven using twills and of course lighter when I use plain weave.  I hand dye bamboo warps too and skeins for the weft.  Some times I weave with tencel for a lighter fabric.  Customers say the fabric feels like silk, is less expensive and can be washed and dried.  

Submitted by Weavin Steven on