I have just finished weaving a silk wrap which I sett at 56 epi (4 ends per dent in a 14" reed).  I threaded up for Swedish Rosepath as I wanted to use this for the borders, which worked fine but the plain weave section in the main body of the weaving is completely unstable.  I hope you can see this from the attached picture.  It also looks warp faced but I would have thought that 56 epi should have given a firm stable fabric.  Any comments from other weavers experienced in using 60/2 silk would be much appreciated.

Comments

lkautio (not verified)

Trying to count ppi on screen. It looks to me like the top plain weave area is beat at about 40% of the twill ppi (22-23 ppi). The area at the bottom is a little tighter, maybe 50% of the twill (28ish ppi). That would be enough to make it unstable. I suspect you need to beat harder and get at least 40-45 ppi before it is stable. I use a ruler rather than beating to a feel. Hope that helps - I am a big fan of your beautiful work!

Laurie Autio

tisserande (not verified)

Thank you for taking the time to look at my problem piece of weaving! Yes, you are right, the ppi's were about half or less of the sett but as that was how it felt "comfortable" to weave it I assumed I had sett it too closely for a plain weave.  Maybe I shall have to learn to be a bit more physical with my weaving! The previous 60/2 silk wrap I made I sett at 48 epi and that seemed more stable - maybe it was easier to beat the weft down.  I shall try it with a scarf next time - quicker to set up! Many thanks for your kind words, means a lot coming from a weaver of your expertise and experience.

lkautio (not verified)

I'm primarily a lace weaver where one of the things you have to learn early is that all picks do not beat in alike (unlike a regular twill). The more plain weave and the more intersections of warp and weft the harder it is to beat in. Even different lace pattern picks will beat in differently. The amount of difference in weaver "oomph" required can be startling, especially in wider pieces. Cheers!

Laurie Autio

ReedGuy

Did you beat with the shed open? Then release the treadle when returning the beater? Maybe this can help pack it better?

Michael White

You get your maximum beat when your cloth fall line is at 90 deg to the beater, with a fix beater. When your fall line is far from the beater you are in fact beating at a downward angle. This is the advantage of a moveable overhead beater.

Michael White

You get your maximum beat when your cloth fall line is at 90 deg to the beater, with a fix beater. When your fall line is far from the beater you are in fact beating at a downward angle. This is the advantage of a moveable overhead beater.

tisserande (not verified)

ReedGuy: Thanks for your suggestion - I had to go and check what I do as it is so automatic, but yes, that is actually how I beat!

Michael: Thanks for your input too - I guess you are saying to keep the fall as close as possible to the beater. 

I will bear all these suggestions in mind when  I next attempt to use 60/2 silk in a plain weave (though that may be a while :) )  Thank you!

ReedGuy

Keeping close with a fixed beater also means restricting the shed opening. Or advancing the warp more often. As Michael suggests a loom that has a beater that can be adjusted forward and back at the tower has an advantage, the shed can be the same, just a bigger swing back to the shafts when far forward on the tower. But you beat more square when it hits the fall line.

Ellen (not verified)

I have actually learnt that if you beat in an open shed you pack the weft in less! And that is also what I do if I aim for an open and airy beat. 

ReedGuy

Ellen are you closing the shed before returning the beater?I'm currently weaving double weave blankets with open shed beat and it's packing in well. I also do this to reduce draw in, am I am also using a temple. But I close the shed before returning. I would think with a closed beat the yarn would rotate back (twist) toward the shafts as the beater was pulled away. It was packed under higher friction.Tension may also be at play, because once off the loom most fibres would relax and pull in.

Michael White

No, not close to the beater. You will get you max beat when the beater is "beating" when it is straight up and down. This point is normally midway from the beater at rest and the cloth beam. 

Sara von Tresckow

Have you tried beating once, changing the shed and beating again?

Actually, beating on an open shed influences the NEXT TO THE LAST pick more than the current pick. In many cases, I use a double beat to get a tabby nicely squared and firmed up.

Some of your issue is due to the fact that twill and tabby usually have different setts. When using both in one piece, the sett is usually a compromise -a tad loose for trhe twill and a tad too tight for the tabby.

tisserande (not verified)

Thanks Sara - no I only beat it once because whilst it was on the loom it looked perfectly ok.  It wasn't till I took it off and washed it that I had this problem.  I thought whilst I was weaving that I was getting a warp faced weave as the sett was too close so didn't attempt to beat the weft down extra hard.

I had thought about the difference between twill and plain weave and their different sett requirements but I have used this combination often before in shawls and scarves without any problem.

Thanks very much for your comments.

Ellen (not verified)

LOL, I am actually like Tisserande not 100 % sure when I do what, but I think I close the shed at the moment the beater gets to the fell line, then change treadles and open the new shed on the way back. I was on a weaving course some years ago and there the very skilled professional weaver told us about using an open shed when for example weaving with wool, where you don't want to pack it in hard to make a stiff fabric. She said it was easier to control in an open shed. 

I am weaving a double weave silk shawl at the moment, and I think I do as described above, :-)

ReedGuy

I'll have to let ya know Ellen after these blankets are done, because my throws were all packed with the shed closed and they aren't stiff. And I sometimes (most actually) beat them a couple times to pack it in good. You know your weaving better than me making speculations on unseen fabric, but we have had two different experiences it seems. :)

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on