I am considering buying a wider RH loom, and am hoping someone can give me a good comparison between the Flip Loom and the Knitters Loom. They are the only 2 folding looms I can get here in Australia, so comparisons to other brands are not really helpful. To me, the fact that the Flip has a breast and warp beam should mean I can get a better tension than on the Knitters loom, but is this really so? Just how much better is the Flip to justify the extra money I would have to lay out to get it?

I really love my knitters loom.

Comments

SteveL (not verified)

True - the Schacht Flip does have a breast and back beam.  As a result, the shed doesn't change in size as cloth accumulates on the cloth beam or warp unwinds off of the warp beam.

I thought I read that the Knitters Loom did NOT have a positive lock at the fold pivot point - to keep the loom from folding, the knobs must be tightened well and are subject to loosening - particularly with a tight warp.

The Flip has a thumb screw near the pivot point on both sides that creates a positive lock - the loom cannot fold no matter how high the warp tension!

This may not be a real issue.... or could be important.

Steve

fantasticfelter (not verified)

have you considered the emilia by glimakra if you can get it. they are coming out with a 18" any dat now.

 i have a ashford KL and a flip and a emilia. i use my KL , and emilia more. the flip is very well made and great wood, but i like the portability and weight of the KL . the cogs and ratchets do not slip and are different than the reg  non folding ashford ridged heddle looms in that the kl cogs  are beefier  and heavier and i have never had any problem with them slipping.i have had that problem with the regular non folding  ashford rh loom ratchets slipping, but even then it was not that bad. if it is just a matter of money i think you will fine with the KL. the filp does come in wider sizes  up 25" but i think for a rh loom 20" is as wide as i want to go. the heddle gets pretty unwilling and heavier and more "dippy" if you are doing, say a 7" scarf ,on a 25" loom.

Caroline (not verified)

hi, I live in Australia, and we have only the 2 brands available here.  Thank you for the info on the Ashford regular loom, as I had sort of considered that too, if I could have found somewhere to store it - most of my looms hang off  curtain rails and I'm running out of space fast, hehe!

I do love my 12 inch KL, its very easy to use, and warping is a breeze, which is why I prefer to go with a folding loom again. Its so portable, so i can take it to my spinning and weaving group with me.

janetdawson (not verified)

I've woven on both my own 12" KL and a borrowed 20" Flip. There were things I liked better about each one of them so it's really hard to say which one I prefer but I can at least share my observations:

I like the way the Flip folds better than the KL. The KL folds up, i.e. with the warp inside the loom's frame, whereas the Flip folds down, with the warp on the outside. I find this keeps the tension better.

Actually, I find that the Flip holds tension better than the KL in general. I've found that the KL cogs don't hold well and that it tends to unreel itself when the tension's off, as when you're folding the loom or even just advancing the warp. I've got a somewhat older KL; maybe the cogs on newer looms hold better?

I find that the breast beam of the Flip presses on the underside of the web and, if you're weaving fabric with an open set (e.g. 8/4 cotton at 8 EPI and PPI), the beam will push the weft threads around so it bunches up in some places and is very much more open in others, with the end result that you wind up with big streaks in the fabric. You can straighten them out with a tapestry needle and a lot of patience, but my patience with that kind of thing is pretty minimal.

I really liked the feel of the Flip and in particular liked weaving with it in a stand. I'm not sure what I'd think of it without the stand.  I haven't tried a stand for my KL - I really want to test one out but there are no nearby dealers so I can't do that around here.

The KL cogs are on the outside of the frame which keeps them from interfering with the rods on the back beam.  OTOH, the Flip cogs hold better.  (The Emilia's cogs look like they'd hold at least as well as the Flip's and are on the outside of the loom - best of both worlds!)

At first I really preferred the way that the rods are attached to the KL beams as opposed to the Flips (the texsolv cord tends to throw the rods off kilter if they don't lie really flat on the beam as they wind on) but then I realized the KL arrangement as it comes out of the box doesn't allow you to put on a warp that's wound separately (as opposed to direct warping) so I added extra dowels to my KL so that now it's like the Flip I borrowed. 

As for portability, the Flip I borrowed was 20" wide and had the stand. Folded up and put into its bag, the loom by itself was light and easy to carry. My friend generally folded it down but left it mounted on the stand to take it places and it was easy to carry around that way, too. It fit into the back seat of her car like that.

Hope that helps some!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on