sgt_majorette (not verified)

" flatweaves which I *think* would be similar to the Navajo"

That was my impression, too. The kilim, which is the base for the cut pile oriental, seems to me to be just weft-faced plain weave, which is your basic Navajo weaving, as far as I can tell! 

lesliemendelson (not verified)

The kilim is a flat weave oriental rug.  It is woven tapestry style and has slits.  Navaho weaving as far as I know does not have slits and the weaving technique is different.  In Kilim the ends are woven in or left out (I can't remember, maybe both), whereas the Navaho feather the old and the new ends together so it is truly reversible.

Virag (not verified)

Thank you for the info!  I just found a book on Kilims and Flatweaves to spend the afternoon with but have no info on the Navho techniques.  What are the Navaho pieces purposed for?  I understand at least in some areas of Central Asia that the Kilim are put down over felt rugs but under the cutpile for lining yurts.  I'm not sure about elsewhere but I guess you'd never see the back of a kilim in use under those circumstances:>.  Do you know anything about the techniques used in Mafrash bags?

sgt_majorette (not verified)

Navajo rugs don't generally have slits, and in the Oriental weaving workshop I attended, you could weave in the ends or secure them in the back. But the basic theory is much the same. The killim can be thought of as the base for the cutpile. I took up Navajo weaving instead of continuing with the Oriental because the learning process was more affordable.

Navajo weaving began as dresses, blankets for wearing and sleeping, and saddleblankets. Except for wearing-blankets, you wouldn't see the reverse side so it didn't originally matter. Then after the tribe returned from internment at Bosque Redondo wearing government-provided clothing, traders saw that easterners and other tourists liked the "Indian Blanket" patterns and would pay good money for the best work. They would work with the women weavers, discussing what designs sold best where. (Put red in it. My customers like red. I don't get much call for those pale colors, but Mr. -- at ----- Post said some lady has been asking about pastels.) Any perceived imperfection (like slits where the colors change) would lower the price; the most skillful weavers could do commission work and name their prices. In this way, some women are the main breadwinners.

Navajo weavers have a pragmatism about their work that is refreshing. For example, you may see a resemblance between some of the Navajo styles and Persian or Turkish patterns. This is no coincidence: the traders showed the Navajo women the high-priced Orientals and suggested that these would sell well. The instructions I got for my online class show the old-fashioned way to tie up your warp, but it also says use turnbuckles like a sensible person. Tradition and progress are not mutually exclusive. Only the ladies who have a following of collectors have the time to spin their own yarn; the others buy from mills they like and overspin it.

lambspin (not verified)

I wish there was an agree button so I could just click it :).  Thanks for your post, great information.  

francorios (not verified)

I agree with that agree.

That post puts little bits of info from different sources and puts it in a succinct package.

Have a good day!

jenadina (not verified)

I haven't spun for cut pile weaving, but if I remember correctly from an article I read, the wool used in most of the middle east usually comes from meat sheep of undetermined breed. Maybe you could google for duel-purpose sheep to find a good starting place? I have a breed on the tip of my tongue but can't quite get it out. I'll post again if I remember.

~Jen

Alison (not verified)

There are a few reasons your yarn is more prickly.

1)  The wool could be courser (thicker) than the wool in the band,

2)  The wool in the band may be spun worsted.

3)  The wool in the band may be spun with more twist.

For cutpile weaving, you probably want a loosly spun single - very different that a warp yarn.

Hope this is helpful.  If I'm missing the point, please clarfiy and ask again. 

Alison

Caroline (not verified)

Virag, they would have used wool from one of their fat-tailed sheep, and the quality of wool would be very variable, depending on how good the pasture was the year the sheep was shorn.

Virag (not verified)

That's a great idea.  I think I even have some in a box that would work.  Thanks:>.